Idaho Supreme Court Civil Opinions
The Idaho Supreme Court and Idaho Court of Appeals cited opinions are made available online as a public service. All cited opinions are posted the day of their release. West Publishing Company publishes all cited opinions in the Pacific Reporter and Idaho Reports volumes. The Summary constitutes no part of the opinion of the Court, but has been prepared by court staff for the convenience of the public. All cited opinions are removed from this site one-year upon release.
NOTICE: These opinions are subject to formal revision before publication in the preliminary print of the Pacific Reporter. Readers are requested to notify the Clerk of the Court/Reporter of Decisions, Supreme Court of Idaho, Boise, Idaho, 83720-0101, of any typographical or other formal errors, in order that corrections may be made before the preliminary print goes to press.
By Release Date
-
- *Video Archives are posted if and when available. For best results, use Internet Explorer.
Release Date Docket# Case Name Opinion
Summary
Notes Nov. 27, 2024
50287 Mitchell v. Ramlow Opinion
SummaryMootness; Exceptions to Mootness; Civil Protection Order Nov. 25, 2024
50846 Castell v. IDOL Opinion
SummaryUnemployment Benefits; Employment-Related Misconduct; Judicial Notice; Idaho Industrial Commission Nov. 19, 2024
49487 TCR, LLC v. Teton County Opinion Substitute
SummaryIdaho Condominium Property Act; Idaho Declaratory Judgment Act; Motion to Enforce; I.A.R. 13(b); Summary Judgment; Attorney Fees Nov. 8, 2024
50261 Severinsen v. Tueller Opinion
SummaryIdaho Property Condition Disclosure Act; Fraud By Misrepresentation; Evidence of Damages Nov. 7, 2024
51314 Murray v. Dalton Opinion
SummaryIdaho Parental Rights Act; I.C. §§ 15-5-209, 15-5-212; Termination of a Guardianship Nov. 1, 2024
50736 Terteling v. Terteling Opinion
SummaryTrust Reformation October 28, 2024
50719 Hess v. Hess Opinion
SummaryUniform Child Custody Jurisdiction and Enforcement Act; Concurrent Jurisdiction; Physical and Legal Custody; Child Support Award; I.C. § 32-717; I.C. § 32-717C October 28, 2024
50200 Clover v. Crookham Company Opinion
SummaryWorker's Compensation; Exclusive Remedy Rule; Willful or Unprovoked Physical Aggression October 4, 2024
49818 Schriver v. Raptosh Opinion
SummaryLoss of a pet; emotional distress damages; trespass to chattels/conversion; negligent infliction of emotional distress (NIED); duty of care; intentional infliction of emotional distress (IIED); "value to owner" measure of damages Sept. 25, 2024
50507 Sullivan v. Blaine County Opinion
SummaryLLUPA; Prejudice to Substantial Rights; I.C. 67-5279(3), 67-5279(4); Attorney Fees; I.C. 12-117(1) Sept. 24, 2024
50625 Wilde v. Taggart Opinion
SummaryRetroactive Award of Child Support; I.C. § 32-709 Sept. 6, 2024
51562/51565 IDHW v. Jane and John Doe Opinion
SummaryChild Protective Act; Adjudicatory Decree; Shelter Care Order; Parental Rights; Due Process; Equal Protection; Fourth Amendment Seizure; Appellant Jurisdiction; Mootness Sept. 5, 2024
50403 Wurdemann v. State Opinion Amended
SummaryIdaho Wrongful Conviction Act; I.C. §§ 6-3501-3505; Legal Error; Factual Innocence; Statutory Interpretation Sept. 3, 2024
50830 Roy v. IDHW Opinion
SummaryIdaho Code § 19-2604; Dismissed Conviction; Prejudice to Substantial Rights; Issue Preservation August 19, 2024
50094 Evans v. Wright Opinion
SummaryMedical Malpractice Claim; Statute of Limitations; Idaho Code § 5-219(4); I.A.R. 14; Timely Appeal; Motion to Convert; I.R.C.P. 12(d); Equitable Estoppel August 19, 2024
50471/50472 Von Wandruszka v. City of Moscow Opinion
SummaryMunicipal Water Services and Utilities; City of Grangeville v. Haskin; Utility Guarantees; Duress; Liens; Vague and Indefinite Contract Provisions; Standing August 16, 2024
49856 Upper Valley Community Health Svcs, Inc. v. Madison County Opinion
SummaryI.C. 63-602C; Property Tax Exemption; Exclusive Use August 16, 2024
49787 Angelos v. Schatzel Opinion
SummaryMotion to Intervene; I.R.C.P. 24(a); Real Party in Interest; Security Agreement; Default; Chose in Action as Collateral. August 16, 2024
49788 Angelos v. Schatzel Opinion
SummaryProperty Subject to Execution; Assignability of Chose in Action for Defamation; Sheriff's Sale; I.C. §§ 11-201 and 203. August 15, 2024
50662 JK Homes, LLC v. Brizzee Opinion
SummaryI.C. § 5-248; Statutory Interpretation; Tolling Statute of Limitations August 14, 2024
52089 Labrador v. Idahoans for Open Primaries Opinion Amended
SummaryWrit; Duty to Act; Ripeness August 14, 2024
50543 Hickman v. Boomers, LLC Opinion
SummaryExclusive Remedy Rule; Willful or Unprovoked Physical Agression; Consciously Disregarded Knowledge; I.C. §72--209(3) August 13, 2024
51788 Hawkins Companies, LLC v. State of Idaho Opinion
SummaryOriginal Action; Standing; Redressability; Relaxed Standing August 6, 2024
50279 Gomez v. Hurtado Opinion
SummaryMaterial Elements of Contract; Breach of Fiduciary Duty; Dissolution and Winding Up of Limited Liability Company August 6, 2024
50485 Nelson v. State of Idaho, Industrial Special Indemnity Fund Opinion
SummaryTotal and Permanent Disability; Credibility; Idaho Industrial Commission August 5, 2024
50667 Wiseman v. Rencher Opinion
SummaryI.C. §§ 6-1001 to 6-1011; Prelitigation Hearing Panel; Disqualification of Judge August 2, 2024
49967 Porter v. Remmich Opinion
SummaryDismissal; I.R.C.P. 12(b)(8) ("another action pending between the same parties for the same cause") July 19, 2024
50096/50097 Jones v. Sligar Opinion
SummaryI.R.C.P. 60(b); I.C. 12-121; I.C. 12-123; Timeliness; Summary Judgment; Res Judicata; and Attorney Fees July 3, 2024
50441 Lanningham v. Farm Bureau Opinion
SummaryUnderinsured motorist coverage; household exclusion; wrongful death; Farm Bureau v. Eisenmann; Idaho Code §§ 41-2502, 49-1212(12), and 41-1839 July 3, 2024
50457 Hennig, Jr. v. Money Metals Exchange Opinion
SummaryUnemployment Benefits; employment-related misconduct; Standards of Behavior Test; judicial notice; Idaho Industrial Commission
July 2, 2024
50408 & 50455 Carter Dental v. Carter Opinion
SummaryEnforceablility of settlement agreement; judicial estoppel; attorney fees
July 1, 2024
49628 Axelrod v. Reid Limited Partnership Opinion Substitute
SummaryEasement; Trespass; Real Property; Summary Judgment; Settlement Agreement; Attorney Fees
June 28, 2024
48954 Pinkham v. Plate Opinion Substitute
SummaryDefault; Default Judgment; void judgment; Idaho Rule of Civil Procedure 11.3; Idaho Rule of Civil Procedure 60(b)(4). June 27, 2024
50000 Whittaker v. Idaho Department of Water Resources Opinion Substitute
SummaryWater Right Transfer, Water Law, Snake River Basin Adjudication, SRBA June 27, 2024
50558 Simmons v. Loertscher Opinion
SummaryCattle; trespass; open range; herd districts; "fence-out" rule; I.C. § 25-2402.
June 27, 2024
50570 Coray v. Idaho Regional Hand & Upper Extremity Center Opinion
SummaryWorker's Compensation; Independent Medical Examination; I.C. §§ 72-433-34; "a duly qualified physician"; Reasonableness of Exam as Scheduled.
June 27, 2024
50491 Davis v. Blast Opinion
SummaryCertified Question; Punitive Damages; I.C. § 6-1604(2); Motion to Amend a Complaint or Counterclaim; "weighing the evidence".
June 12, 2024
50747 ISB v. John Doe Opinion
SummaryApplication for Admission to Practice Law; I.B.C.R. 201 Eligibility Requirements; Character and Fitness; Rehabilitation of Conduct; First Amendment
June 7, 2024
50756 Barton v. Board of Regents Opinion
SummarySummary Judment; I.R.C.P. 15(a)(2); I.A.R. 35(a)(6)
June 5, 2024
50088 Hill v. Blaine County Opinion
SummaryI.C. § 40-203A; Road Validation
June 4, 2024
49904 Oksman v. City of Idaho Falls Opinion
SummarySummary Judgment; Use of Deposition at Trial; Trial Objections; Slip and Fall; Abuse of Discretion; I.R.C.P. 32; Leading Questions; Loss of Value of Household Services
June 3, 2024
50746 White v. ITD Opinion
SummaryAdministrative License Suspension; DUI, Necessity Defense; I.C. § 18-8002A(7); Reagan v. ITD; Sixth Amendment; Due Process
May 8, 2024
50039 Kelso v. Applington Opinion
SummaryDonative Intent; I.C. § 15-6-104; Issues of Credibility on Summary Judgment; Rule 56; Clear and Convincing Evidence Standard; Attorney Fees Under I.C. 12-121; Consideration of the Case in its Entirety
April 24, 2024
50273 Hastings v. IDWR Opinion
SummaryStatute of Limitations for IDWR Enforcement Action; Stream Channel Alteration Act; I.C. § 42-3809; Judicial Notice; Motion to Continue
April 11, 2024
50302 IDHW v. Beason Opinion
SummaryMedicaid Recovery; Adequate Consideration; Statute of Frauds; Statute of Limitations; I.C. § 5-202; I.C. § 5-218; I.C. § 5-224; I.C. § 56-218
April 11, 2024
51227 Babe Vote/League of Women Voters of Idaho v. McGrane Opinion
SummaryArticle VI, section 4 of the Idaho Constitution; Right of Suffrage; Equal Protection; Rational Basis Test; Strict Scrutiny; Standing
April 10, 2024
49916 Lands v. Sunset Manor, LP Opinion
SummaryDiscovery Sanctions; Scheduling Order; Expert Witnesses; Harmless Error; Causation
April 2, 2024
49940 Thompson v. Burley Inn, Inc. Opinion
SummaryWorkers' Compensation; Idaho Code section 72-432; Medicaid
March 25, 2024
49755 Medical Recovery Services v. Moser Opinion
SummaryDebt Collection; Summary Judgment; Idaho Appellate Rules 28, 29, 30, & 31 ("record on appeal"); I.R.C.P. 83 (requesting transcripts on appeal); I.C. § 12-120(1) & (3) ("attorney fees," "prevailing party")
March 21, 2024
50703 Blasch v. HP, Inc. Opinion
SummaryIdaho Human Rights Act; Idaho Equal Pay Act; Wage Discrimination; Statute of Limitations March 5, 2024
50197 Renaissance Project Development, LLC v. Twin Falls Opinion
SummaryLocal Land Use Planning Act; I.C. § 67-6535 ("reasoned statement," "express approval standards," "practical considerations"); I.C. § 67-5279(3) ("substantial rights") Feb. 27, 2024
49773 Millard v. Talburt Opinion
SummaryRoad Easement; Well Easement; I.C. § 55-313; I.C. § 55-601; I.C. § 12-121 Feb. 22, 2024
49801 Pickering v. Sanchez Opinion
SummaryIdaho Consumer Protection Act; Collateral Source Rule; Unjust Enrichment Feb. 2, 2024
49418 & 49483 Snap! Mobile v. Vertical Raise Opinion
SummaryAdditur, discretionary costs, Idaho Rule of Civil Procedure 65(d), collateral bar rule, overbroad injunction Feb. 1, 2024
49915 Nipper V. Wootton Opinion
SummarySummary judgment; I.R.C.P. 56(d); motion to extend time for obtaining responsive affidavits; medical malpractice; proof of community standard of care; sufficiency of record on appeal January 29, 2024
51211 Idaho State Athletic Commission v. Office of the Administrative Rules Coordinator Opinion
SummaryOriginal Jurisdiction; Idaho Constitution Article II, section 1; Article III, sections 1, 15, and 29; Article IV, section 10; Idaho Administrative Procedure Act; Administrative Rulemaking January 18, 2024
50795 IDHW v. John Doe & Jane Doe Opinion Appeal Dismissed January 12, 2024
49632 South Valley Ground Water v. ID Dept of Water Resources Opinion
SummaryGroundwater; surface water; prior appropriation; Idaho Code § 42-237a.g. January 12, 2024
49371 Miller v. Rocking Ranch No. 3 Opinion
SummaryProperty Dispute; Attorney Fees; Prevailing Party January 11, 2024
49279 GSN Capital, LLC v. Shoshone City & Rural Fire District Opinion
SummaryIdaho Tort Claims Act; Negligence; Statutory Duty of Care; Special Relationship; Assumption of Duty; Idaho Code section 31-1401 January 3, 2024
49547 Skehan v. ISP Opinion
SummaryIdaho Administrative Procedure Act; Sex Offender Registration Act; Substantially Equivalent Offense; Issue Preservation; Arbitrary or Capricious January 3, 2024
49976 Worthington v. Crazy Thunder Opinion
SummaryConstitutional Right to Jury Trial; Legal and Equitable Remedies; Unlawful Detainer; Idaho Code section 6-311A Dec. 28, 2023
50045 Shumway v. IDOL Opinion
SummaryUnemployment Benefits; Misconduct; Idaho Code section 72-1366(5) Dec. 20, 2023
49562 Yellowstone Log Homes, LLC v. City of Rigby Opinion
SummaryNegligence; Idaho Underground Facilities Damage Prevention Act; Summary Judgment Dec. 19, 2023
49237 A.C. & C.E. Investments, Inc. v. Eagle Creek Irrigation Company Opinion
SummaryShareholder Derivative Actions; I.R.C.P. 78; Pleading Requirements; Nonprofit Corporations; Ripeness; Standing; Attorney Fees Dec. 19, 2023
49693 Milus v. Sun Valley Company Opinion
SummaryPETITION FOR REHEARING GRANTED - I.C. § 6-1103; I.C. § 6-1106; Ski Area Liability Act; Negligence; Assumption of Risk Dec. 19, 2023
49535 Davis v. George and Jesse's Les Schwab Tire Store, Inc. Opinion
SummaryRecord on Appeal; False Arrest; Defamation Per Se; Breach of Employment Contract; Qualified Privilege; At-Will Employee; Idaho Rule of Civil Procedure 54; I.C. § 18-705; I.C. § 12-121; Idaho Appellate Rule 11.2; Sanctions Dec. 18, 2023
49708 Datum Construction, LLC v. Re Investment Co. Opinion
SummaryMechanic's Lien Bond; Judgment Releasing Bond; Statute of Limitations; In Rim; In Personam Dec. 18, 2023
50987 SAPD v. Fourth Judicial District Opinion
SummaryWrit of Mandamus; Duties of the State Appellate Public Defender; I.C. § 19-5906; Substitution of Counsel; Pro Hac Vice Rules; Original Jurisdiction; Standing; Disqualification of District Judge Dec. 8, 2023
49679 Midtown Ventures, LLC v. Capone / Capone v. City of Coeur d'Alene Opinion
SummaryStanding; Waiver; Assignment of Rights; Agreement to Agree; Promissory Estoppel; Idaho Code section 12-120(3) Nov. 29, 2023
49859 Martinez v. Carretero Opinion
SummaryCommon Law Marriage; The Presumption of Marriage; Relevance; I.C. § 32-201 Nov. 29, 2023
49452 Jordan v. Walmart Associates, Inc. Opinion
SummaryWorker's Compensation; Industrial Accident; Compensable Injury; I.C. § 72-228 ("injury arose out of the course of employment") Nov. 29, 2023
49419 Montierth v. Dorssers Opinion
SummaryStatute of Limitations; I.C. § 5-238; Mortgages; Summary Judgment; Lis Pendens Nov. 28, 2023
49606 Hanks v. City of Boise Opinion
SummaryPremises Liability; Slip and Fall; Invitee; Negligence, Dangerous Condition; Isolated Incident; Operating Method Nov. 3, 2023
50875 IDHW v. John Doe Opinion
SummaryChild Protection Case; Legal Custody; Verbal and Written Findings of Fact; Fundamental Rights Nov. 2, 2023
49510 Morley v. IDOL Opinion
SummaryIdaho Industrial Commission; Filing Deadlines; Pro Se Litigants; Good Faith Misinterpretation of the Rules October 30, 2023
50134 D.L. Evans Bank v. Dean Opinion
SummaryI.C. § 10-1111; Judgment Renewal; Collateral Attack on a Void Judgment; Idaho Rule of Civil Procedure 60(b)(4); Idaho Rule of Civil Procedure 4.1(b)(7); Personal Jurisdiction October 27, 2023
50868/50897 IDHW v. Jane Doe / IDHW v. John Doe Opinion
SummaryIdaho Code section 16-1603(2); Child Protective Act; "at risk of being a victim of abuse, neglect, or abandonment"; Protective Supervision; Idaho Rules of Evidence 201(b) and (c); Judicial Notice October 26, 2023
49633 Farms, LLC v. Isom Opinion
SummaryBankruptcy; Automatic Stay; Statutes of Limitation October 26, 2023
50143 Cook v. Van Orden Opinion
SummaryPrescriptive Easement; Adverse Use; Presumption of Permissive Use October 4, 2023
48799 Tidwell v. Blaine County Opinion
SummaryStanding; Procedural Due Process; 42 U.S.C. section 1983 October 3, 2023
49488 Fickenwirth v. Lanning Opinion
SummaryBoundary by Agreement; Survey; Quiet Title; Acquiescence; Implied Agreement Sept 22, 2023
49852 Grace at Fairview Lakes, LLC v. IDHW Opinion
SummaryIdaho Administrative Procedure Act; Substantial and Competent Evidence; IDAPA 16.03.22.335; Unsafe Living Environment; Core-Issue Deficiency; Idaho Code section 12-117 Sept 15, 2023
49299 Christmann v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Co. Opinion
SummaryUnderinsured Motorist Coverage; Subrogation Rights; Prejudice; I.R.C.P. 60(b)(3); Attorney Fees Under I.C. § 41-1839(4) Sept 15, 2023
49354 Sullivan v. BitterSweet Ranch, LLC Opinion
SummaryLease; Oral Modification; Breach of Contract; Summary Judgment; Attorney Fees Sept 15, 2023
48900 Smith v. Excel Fabrication, LLC Opinion
SummarySummary Judgment; Statutory Employer; Worker's Compensation; Independent Contractor; Subcontractor Sept 15, 2023
48721 Bracken v. City of Ketchum Opinion
SummaryConditional Use Permit; Exhausting Administrative Remedies; Judicial Review Sept 12, 2023
49678 International Rescue Committee v. Mohammed Opinion
SummaryTrust Formation; Charitable Trusts and Donations; Distribution of Funds; I.C. § 68-106(c); Due Process; Abuse of Discretion Sept 8, 2023
49637 Shake Out, LLC v. Clearwater Construction, LLC Opinion
SummaryArbitration Clause; Right to Arbitrate; Motion to Compel; Waiver; Forfeiture; Attorney Fees Sept 8, 2023
49933 Stiffler v. Hydroblend, Inc. Opinion
SummaryWage Claim Dispute; I.C. § 45-606(1); I.C. § 7-902(d); Idaho Wage Claim Act; Arbitration Clause; Staying Arbitrable Claims; Controlling Employment Agreement Sept 7, 2023
49179 NW Neighborhood Assoc v. City of Boise Opinion
SummaryLocal Land Use Planning Act; I.C. § 67-6535 ("reasoned statement"); issue preservation; I.C. § 67-5279(3) ("substantial rights") Sept 6, 2023
49385 McCreery v. King, M.D. Opinion
SummaryWaiver; standard of review on appeal Sept 6, 2023
49300 Rich v. Hepworth Holzer Medical malpractice; legal malpractice; expert testimony; some chance of success; case within a case August 30, 2023
49592 Sankey v. Ivey Landlord-Tenant Act; Land Surveys; Business Record Exception August 30, 2023
49342/49417 Dorsey v. Dorsey Special Master; I.R.C.P. 53; Operating Agreement; Ambiguous; Winding-Up; Accounting; Idaho Code section 30-25-405 August 22, 2023
49772 Abell v. Abell Criminal Contempt; Non-Summary Proceeding August 18, 2023
49094/49523 Bronco Elite Arts & Athletics, LLC v. 106 Garden City, LLC Specific Performance; Breach of Contract; Idaho Code section 28-22-104(1); Attorney Fees; Idaho Appellant Rule 13(a) August 16, 2023
50940 Idahoans for Open Primaries v. Labrador Writ of Certiorari; Writ of Mandamus; Original Jurisdiction; Standing; Initiative; Idaho Code section 34-1809; Short Ballot Title; General Ballot Title. August 15, 2023
49704 Watkins v. City of Ponderay Worker's Compensation; Peace Officer and Detention Officer Temporary Disability Act August 14, 2023
48898 Day v. Idaho Transportation Department Inverse condemnation; tolling of the statute of limitations; course of dealings; quasi-estoppel; attorney fees under I.C. § 12-120(3) August 4, 2023
49795 Edmonson v. Finco Mootness; Modification of Child Custody August 3, 2023
49196 Lowell v. Human Dynamics & Diagnostics, PLLC Idaho Appellate Rule 35(a)(6); Idaho Industrial Commission; Unemployment July 10, 2023
49667 Bradbury v. City of Lewiston Utility Fees and Municipal Funds; Idaho Const. Art. VIII, § 3 and Art. XII, § 4; I.C. § 63-1311; Standing; Notice Under ITCA; Attorney-Client Privilege; I.R.E. 502(b). June 27, 2023
49189 Darrow v. White Trust; Conflict of Interest; Idaho Code section 68-108(b); Idaho Code section 68-111. June 23, 2023
49572 Houston v. Houston Trust Interpretation; Ambiguity; Trial De Novo. June 23, 2023
49511 Arreola v. Scentsy, Inc. Worker's Compensation Law; Medical Exam Dispute; I.C. §§ 72-434, 72-433(1); Brewer v. La Crosse Health & Rehab, 138 Idaho 859, 71 P.3d 458 (2003), Overruled; I.C. § 72-804. June 22, 2023
48975 Herndon v. City of Sandpoint Judicial Estoppel; Leasehold Interests; 42 U.S.C. § 1983; 42 U.S.C. § 1985; Mootness. June 15, 2023
49605 Wright v. Parish Divorce; Equal Ownership Interest; Jurisdiction; Res Judicata; Issue Preclusion; Claim Preclusion. June 14, 2023
49473/49474 Alcala v. Verbruggen Palletizing Solutions, Inc. Worker's Compensation Law; Res Judicata; Law of the Case; Statutory Co-Employee Immunity; Kelly v. TRC Fabrication, LLC, 168 Idaho 788, 487 P.3d 723 (2021); Hybrid Transaction; Predominant Factor Test; Third Party Liability; Attorney Fees; I.C. § 12-120(3). June 13, 2023
49373 Eagle Rock Timber, Inc. v. Teton County Agency; Scope of Authority; Actual and Apparent Authority; Ratification; Scope of the Pleadings on Summary Judgment; Motion to Amend. June 13, 2023
49590 Reese v. City of Blackfoot Prejudice to a Substantial Right; PUD; LLUPA; Zoning; I.C. § 67-5279 June 9, 2023
49298 Wood v. ITD Breath Alcohol Testing Rules (IDAPA 11.03.01); Idaho Administrative Procedure Act; Rulemaking; I.A.R. 35(a)(6) (waiver); I.C. §§ 18-8002A, 18-8004(4); I.C. § 12-117. June 8, 2023
50107 Pottenger v. Charlton Child Custody Modification; Substantial and Material Changes; Best Interests of the Child June 7, 2023
49694 Dickenson v. Benewah County Whistleblower Act; insufficient record. May 22, 2023
49136 Bagby v. Davis Uniform Voidable Transactions Act; Substantial and Competent Evidence; Conflict of Laws. May 17, 2023
49126 Idaho Power Company v. Idaho State Tax Commission Taxation of Operating Property; Preemption; Equalization. May 17, 2023
49184 49522 Geringer Capital v. Taunton Properties, LLC Breach of Contract; Statute of Frauds; Tortious Interference; Civil Conspiracy; Idaho Code section 12-120(3). May 12, 2023
49463 Burns Concrete, Inc. v. Teton County Attorney fees; Reasonable Attorney fees; Contractual Attorney fees; Prevailing Party; Idaho Rule of Civil Procedure 54(e)(3). May 4, 2023
49187 Mattson v. IDHW Medical malpractice; Idaho Tort Claims Act; Mental Health Services; I.C. § 6-904A; Foreseeability; "Reckless, willful and wanton" exception to immunity; I.C. § 6-904C(2). May 2, 2023
50208 Plasse v. Reid Custody modification; Joint custody; material, substantial, and permanent change in circumstances; Idaho Rules of Family Law Procedure; I.C. § 32-717 March 30, 2023
49108 Demoney-Hendrickson v. Larsen Partition; Presumption of Equal Shares; I.C. §§ 6-501, 6-508; Ownership Interest; Summary Judgment. March 28, 2023
48743 Riverton Citizens Group v. Bingham County Commissioners I.R.C.P. 84; I.R.C.P. 83; Petition for Judicial Review; Caption; Signatures; Parties; I.A.R. 11.2(sanctions); Amendment and Relation Back; I.A.R. 17; Nullity Rule. March 24, 2023
48570 Terrell v. Paradis de Golf Holding, LLC Idaho Code section 12-120(3); Commercial Transaction; Attorney Fees. March 24, 2023
48919 Nordgaarden v. Kiebert Judicial Partition; Great Prejudice; Idaho Code section 6-501; Idaho Code section 6-512. March 22, 2023
48922 Greenbriar Estates Homeowners' Association, Inc. v. Esposito Easement; Settlement Agreement; Landlock; HOA; Attorney Fees; CC&Rs. March 21, 2023
49175 BrunoBuilt, Inc. v. Erstad Architects, PA Statute of limitations; I.C. § 5-219(4); Professional negligence; Economic Loss Rule; Motion to disqualify; Motion to consolidate; Sanctions; I.A.R. 11.2; I.C. § 12-121. March 20, 2023
49343 Richardson v. Blaine County LLUPA; IRCP; Conditional Use Permit; Exhaustion of Administrative Remedies; Motion for Reconsideration. March 15, 2023
49537 Owens v. Ada County Board of Commissioners Medical Indigency Act; Applicant; Reimbursement; Statutory Liens; Medical Indigency; Agency Action. March 7, 2023
49176 Brunobuilt, Inc. v. Briggs Engineering, Inc. Statute of limitations; I.C. § 5-219(4); Professional malpractice; Economic Loss Rule. March 2, 2023
48876 Whitham v. Creamer Easement; Trespass; Negligence; Burden; Declaratory Judgment; Damages. March 2, 2023
49240 Bass v. Esslinger Boundary by Agreement; Historic Boundary; Motion for Continuance; Motion to take Judicial Notice; Judicial Notice; Idaho Rule of Evidence 201(c); Res Judicata; Notice by Publication; Attorney's Fees. March 2, 2023
50023 IDHW v. Jane Doe (2022-36) Idaho Code 16-1625; Idaho Appellant Rule 11.1(b)(2); Child Protective Act; Permanency Plan; Permanency Goals; Reunificaiotn; Termination of Parental Rights; Permissive Appeal; Vesting Custody. March 1, 2023
49971 IDHW v. John Doe (2022-32) Interstate Compact on the Placement of Children; I.C. § 16-2102; Placement with out-of-state parents; Statutory Construction. February 28, 2023
48981 O'Holleran v. O'Holleran I.C.A.R. 5; Idaho Code section 1-2208; Idaho Code section 1-2210 February 28, 2023
49137 Beebe v. North Idaho Day Surgery, LLC Proximate cause jury instrution; "but for" causation; "substantial factor" causation; loss of consortium February 14, 2023
49231 Treasure Valley Home Solutions, LLC v. Chason Agreement to Agree; Enforceable Contract; Idaho Code Section 12-120(3); Commercial Transaction. February 8, 2023
49190 616 Inc. v. Mae Properties, LLC Material terms to forming a lease agreement; Statute of frauds; Part-Performance; Attorney fees; Idaho Code § 12-120(3). February 2, 2023
49139 Gilbert v. Radnovich Abuse of discretion standard; Reasonable inquiry; Rule 11 sanctions; Attorney fees. January 25, 2023
47919 Easterling v. Hal Pacific Properties, L.P. Easements by necessity; statute of limitations; I.C. § 5-224; statutory interpretation; merger; quiet title; accrual. January 20, 2023
50356 In Re: Idaho State Bar Resolution 21-01
Decision Idaho State Bar Resolution January 9, 2023
49188 Lamm v. Preston
Opinion
SummaryDivorce; Community Property; Business Valuations; Personal Goodwill; Disentanglement January 6, 2023
48705 Katseanes v. Katseanes
Opinion
SummaryValidity of Oral Order; Criminal Contempt; Order of Disgorgement January 5, 2023
49615/49817/49899 Planned Parenthood Great Northwest v. State
Opinion
SummaryAbortion Dec. 14, 2022
48335 Erickson v. Erickson
Opinion
SummaryDiscovery Sanctions; Community Property Presumption; Separate Property Dec. 8, 2022
49173 Latvala v. Green Enterprises, Inc.
Opinion
SummaryScope of Prescriptive Easement Dec. 7, 2022
48978 Vouk v. Chapman
Opinion
SummaryFiduciary Duty; Breach of Fiduciary Duty; Life Insurance; Prejudgment Interest; Distribution Agreement; TEDRA; Trust and Estate Dispute Resolution Act; Idaho Code section 28-22-104; Idaho Code section 68-108; Idaho Code section 68-106 Nov. 25, 2022
48810 Dorr v. IDOL
Opinion
SummaryPro Se; I.A.R. 35(a)(6); Cogent Argument; Forfeiture of Assigned Errors Nov. 3, 2022
49067 Grace at Twin Falls, LLC v. Jeppesen
Opinion
SummaryI.C. § 39-3316(12)(b); IDAPA 16.03.22.550.12.b; Pharmacy Choice Rule Nov. 3, 2022
49777 IDHW v. Jane Doe
Opinion
SummaryTermination of Parental Rights; Preservation Nov. 2, 2022
48926 Sheehan v. Sun Valley Company
Opinion
SummaryIdaho Industrial Commission; Filing Deadlines; Notice of Hearing; Due Process Nov. 1, 2022
48853 Fulfer v. Sorrento Lactalis, Inc.
Opinion
SummaryAffirmative Defenses; I.R.C.P. 12(b)(6); Exclusive Remedy Rule; I.C. § 72-209(3); Statutory Employers October 31, 2022
48363 Chester v. Wild Idaho Adventures RV Park, LLC
Opinion
SummaryDitch Easement; I.C. § 42-1102; Secondary Easement; Injunctive Relief; Easement Encroachments; Trespass; Nuisance; Prescriptive Easement; License Agreement October 31, 2022
48785 Blaskiewicz v. Spine Institute of Idaho
Opinion
SummaryArbitration; Non-Compete; Public Policy October 27, 2022
48636 Hood v. Poorman
Opinion
SummaryDitch easement; I.C. § 42-1102; Primary Easement; Secondary Easement; Injunctive Relief; Easement Encroachments; I.C. § 42-1207; Burden of Proof October 21, 2022
48381 Gestner v. Divine
Opinion
SummaryTestamentary Capacity; Presumption of Undue Influence; Elements of Undue Influence; Preservation Doctrine October 19, 2022
49243 Uzzle v. Estate of Eric Milo Hirning
Opinion
SummaryI.C. § 15-720; Recovery of legal expenses incurred in administration of the estate October 18, 2022
49320 Carver v. Hornish
Opinion
SummaryChild custody dispute; subject matter jurisdiction; minor emancipated through marriage; nunc pro tunc; I.C. § 32-202; I.C. § 12-121 October 18, 2022
49666 Gray v. Gray
Opinion
SummaryChild relocation; modification of child custody orders; burden of proof; the "Roberts Rule"; best interest of the child; I.C. § 32-717 October 3, 2022
48224 Horton v. Horton
Opinion
SummaryDivorce; Settlement Agreement; Nunc Pro Tunc; Abuse of Discretion September 26, 2022
47506 Luck v. Rohel
Opinion Substitute
SummaryI.R.C.P.17; I.R.C.P. 15(c); Rule of Nullity; Unsigned Pleadings September 26, 2022
48591 Kelly v. Kelly
Opinion
SummaryPrenuptial Agreement Enforceability; Prenuptial Agreement and Public Policy: I.C. § 32-704; I.C. § 32-705; contract interpretation; I.C. § 12-121 September 19, 2022
49570 Eldridge v. Agar Livestock, LLC
Opinion
SummaryWorker's Compensation Act; category one statutory employer; I.C. § 72-102(12)(a) ("employer") September 19, 2022
49529 Jane Doe I & John Doe I v. John Doe
Opinion
SummaryDue process; unwell biological fathers; paternity petition; adoption petition; putative father registry; Idaho Code 16-1504; Idaho Code 16-1513 September 16, 2022
49233 Nelson v. Evans
Opinion
SummaryGrandparent Visitation; Idaho Code Section 32-719; Parental Rights September 16, 2022
48353 Access Behavioral Health v. IDHW
Opinion
SummaryPetition for Judicial Review; Medicaid Recoupment; I.C. § 56-209(h)(5); False Claims Act; Doctrine of Laches September 9, 2022
48790 Hall v. Exler
Opinion
SummaryLost deed doctrine; statute of frauds; clear and convincing evidence; execution; delivery; contents; quiet title September 2, 2022
48359 Litster Frost v. Idaho Injury Law Group
Opinion
SummaryI.C. § 48-608 (Idaho Consumer Protection Act or "ICPA"); rescission; quantum meruit; restitution; I.R.P.C. 1.7(a)(1) (concurrent conflict of interest); sanctions for a conflict of interest August 31, 2022
48457 United Heritage v. Zech
Opinion
SummarySummary judgment; I.C. § 41-2401 (property and fire insurance); expiration; cancellation; renewal; waiver; reinstatement; equitable estoppel August 30, 2022
48492 Mortensen v. Baker
Opinion
SummaryMedical malpractice; causation; foundation; expert testimony August 24, 2022
49356 Chambers v. Idaho Board of Pharmacy
Opinion
SummaryAttorney fees; late filing; good cause; prejudice; IDAPA Rule 741; I.C. § 12-117(5) August 23, 2022
48567 Neeser v. Inland Empire Paper Company
Opinion
SummaryPrescriptive easement; summary judgment August 22, 2022
48538 Greenfield Family Trust v. Olive Fountain Land Company, LLC
Opinion
SummaryCivil trespass; I.C. § 6-202; proof of damages; nominal damages; substantial and competent evidence August 22, 2022
48731 Hartman v. Canyon County
Opinion
SummaryAdministrative remedies; administrative exhaustion doctrine; grievance procedures; county personnel system August 22, 2022
48489/48703 Breckenridge Property Fund 2016, LLC v. Wally Enterprises, Inc.
Opinion
SummaryNonjudicial foreclosure sale; public auction; terms of sale; commercial transaction August 12, 2022
49615, 49817, 49899 Planned Parenthood v. State of Idaho Opinion Injunctive Relief; I.R.C.P. 65(e) August 9, 2022
48558 City of Ririe v. Gilgen Opinion
SummaryStanding; Petition for Judicial Review; LLUPA August 3, 2022
47857 Van Orden v. Van Orden Opinion
SummaryPost-Nuptial Property Settlement Agreement; I.C. § 32-917; Void for Violation of Public Policy; I.C. § 18-2403; Overreaching; Unconscionability August 2, 2022
49375 IDHW v. John Doe Opinion
SummaryTermination of parental rights; subject matter jurisdiction; Idaho Rule of Evidence803(6); service by publication; abandonment; neglect; inability to discharge parental responsibilities July 15, 2022
49155 Idaho State Bar v. Smith Opinion
SummaryAttorney discipline; professional misconduct; sanctions; suspension July 8, 2022
48720 Elsaesser v. Black Diamond Compost, LLC Opinion
SummaryNonconsensual common law liens; I.C. § 45-811 July 6, 2022
48701 Elsaesser v. Riverside Farms, Inc. Opinion
SummaryRes Judicata; personal representative; standing to bring ejectment action July 1, 2022
48980 Kuna Rural Fire District v. PERSI Opinion
SummaryPERSI; Firefighters' Retirement Fund; employer contributions; plain meaning June 30, 2022
48418 Shoshone County v. S&W OPS LLC Opinion
SummaryProperty Tax Appeal June 29, 2022
49372 Glatte v. Hernandez Opinion
SummaryStepfather's custody petition; Stockwell v. Stockwell, 116 Idaho 297, 775 P.2d 611 (1989); divorce; I.C. § 32-717 ("children of the marriage"); failure to state a claim June 29, 2022
48722 Allen v. Partners in Healthcare, Inc. Opinion Amended
SummaryUnemployment benefits; good cause to quit; procedural due process June 14, 2022
47652 S Bar Ranch v. Elmore County Opinion Amended
SummaryLLUPA; final agency action; I.C. § 67-6279(3); procedural due process; conflict of interest; I.R.C.P. 84, I.C. § 12-117 June 6, 2022
48276 Berglund v. Dix Opinion
SummaryExpress easements; gates; reasonable use and operation; attorney fees under I.C. § 12-121; I.A.R. 7 May 18, 2022
48769 3G AG LLC v. IDWR Opinion
SummaryUnstacking overlapping water rights; "enlargement" under Idaho Code § 42-222; collateral attack; attorney fees under I.C. § 12-117(1) May 18, 2022
48568 Sharp v. Thomas Bros Plumbing Workers' compensation; I.C. § 72-425; I.C. § 72-430; disability evaluation; non-medical factors; superseding cause; compensable consequences; substantial and competent evidence May 3, 2022
48773 Aizpitarte v. Minear Implied easement by prior use; reasonable necessity; scope April 29, 2022
49171 Nelson v. City of Pocatello Workers' Comp.; firefighters; I.C. §§ 72-438(14)(b) and (c); occupational disease; presumption of causation; equal protection; rational basis test April 19, 2022
47950 Nelsen v. Nelsen Testamentary capacity; undue influence; LLC dissolution April 6, 2022
49072 Weaver v. Weaver Best interest of the child; abuse of discretion; I.C. § 32-717 March 24, 2022
48687 Cook v. Van Orden Prescriptive easement; adverse use; statutory period; presumptions March 17, 2022
48220 Von Lossberg v. State Brady Act; 18 U.S.C. § 922(t)(6); immunity; local government March 15, 2022
48601 Van Hook v. State Vexatious litigant; I.C.A.R. 59(i); due process March 15, 2022
48857 Pizzuto v. IDOC Idaho Administrative Procedure Act (APA); rulemaking; I.C. § 19-2716; lethal injection March 9, 2022
48195 Manning v. Micron Technology, Inc. Idaho Wage Claim Age; bonus compensation; Idaho Code section 45-614; statute of limitations March 9, 2022
48512 Martin v. Garrett Living Trust I.C. 15-3-104; contract for wills; personal representative March 3, 2022
48654 Groveland Water and Sewer Dist v. City of Blackfoot Standing; insufficient record March 2, 2022
48042 Byrd v. Idaho State Brd. of Land Commissioners Encroachment application; littoral rights; agency and statutory authority; Lake Protection Act I.C. §§ 58-1301 to 58-1312; collateral estoppel March 1, 2022
49261, 49267, 49295 & 49353 Durst et al v. ID Comm. for Reapportionment Legislative redistricting; Equal Protection; Idaho Code section 72-1506; original jurisdiction March 1, 2022
47835 Idaho State Tax Commission v. James Net operating loss; I.C. § 63-3072(d); I.C. § 63-3072(e); I.C. § 63-3022(c)(2) February 25, 2022
48289 Williamson v. Ada County Idaho Tort Claims Act; Governmental Immunity February 11, 2022
49351 Pentico v. Idaho Commission for Reapportionment Congressional reapportionment; Idaho Code section 72-1506; original jurisdiction February 9, 2022
47978 Munden v. Bannock County Ex parte temporary restraining order; attorney fees; bond amount; motion to dismiss; Idaho Code section 40-208(7); dismissal with prejudice; final appealable judgment February 3, 2022
48997 Swanson v. Swanson UCCJEA; home state jurisdiction; simultaneous proceedings February 1, 2022
48379 Pena v. Viking Insurance Company of Wisconsin Underinsured motorist coverage; illusory coverage Jan. 6, 2022
48380 Taylor v. Taylor Noncompete provision; breach of contract; severability Jan. 5, 2022
48419 Fuentes v. Cavco Industries, Inc. Industrial Commission, JRP 12, JRP 16, dismissal, discovery sanction Dec. 21, 2021
48007 Sommer v. Misty Valley, LLC Express easement; Idaho Code section 5-224; statute of limitations; quiet title; declaratory relief; deed ambiguity; discovery sanction; harmless error; easement termination Dec. 8, 2021
48254 Valentine v. Valentine Idaho Child Support Guidelines; potential income; harmless error Dec. 3, 2021
46961 Safaris Unlimited, LLC v. Jones Opinion
SummaryMootness; sheriff's sale; I.C. § 12-120(5); I.C. § 10-1115 Dec. 2, 2021
48452 Allen v. Campbell Opinion
SummaryTrust administration; subject matter jurisdiction; venue; Idaho Code section 15-7-203 Nov. 26, 2021
48414 Robirds v. Robirds Opinion
SummaryDivorce; community and separate property; commingling; tracing; Idaho Family Law Rule 809 (currently Rule 805); IRCP 60(b) Nov. 22, 2021
48092 Stanger v. Walker Land & Cattle Opinion
SummaryContract / lease interpretation; improvements; default; irrigation pivots Nov. 22, 2021
48291 Gifford v. West Ada Joint School District #2 Opinion
SummaryStanding; Idaho Const. art. IX, § 1; free public education; kindergarten Nov. 22, 2021
46735 Jones v. Lynn Idaho Dram Shop Act; Federal Maritime Law Nov. 17, 2021
47952 Walker v. Meyer Insufficient record; NORA Nov. 16, 2021
48256 Christiansen v. Potlatch #1 FCU Motion to compel discovery; I.R.C.P. 56(d); I.R.C.P. 37; summary judgment Oct. 22, 2021
48160 Eich v. Revocable Trust Abuse of discretion; entry of judgment Oct. 20, 2021
48228 Smith v. Kount Inc. Contract interpretation; Idaho Wage Claim Act Oct. 13, 2021
48424 Alpha Mortgage Fund v. Drinkard Renewal of judgment, Rule 11.2 sanctions Oct. 8, 2021
48766 Hepworth Holzer, LLP v. Fourth Judicial District Writ of mandamus; disqualification of counsel Oct. 8, 2021
47941 Herr v. Herr Divorce; community and separate property; commingling; tracing; principle of party presentation Sept. 27, 2021
47487 Hilton v. Hilton Divorce; omitted assets; community and separate property Sept. 27, 2021
48735 IDHW v. John Doe Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction and Enforcement Act (UCCJEA); Idaho Child Protective Act; temporary emergency jurisdiction; substantial and competent evidence Sept. 24, 2021
47710 Gatsby v. Gatsby Parental rights; same-sex marriage; Artificial Insemination Act (I.C. §§ 39-5401-5407); equal protection Sept. 2, 2021
48156 Frost v. Gilbert Prescriptive easement, quiet title, attorney fees Sept. 1, 2021
47848 Medical Recovery Svcs V. Eddins Opinion Substitute
SummaryProof of assignment; limited admission of evidence; judicial estoppel August 31, 2021
47946 Summerfield v. St. Luke's McCall Medical malpractice; I.C. § 6-1012; standard of care; motion for reconsideration August 23, 2021
48784 & 48760 Reclaim Idaho/Gilmore v. Denney Opinion
SummaryIdaho Const. art. III, § 1; initiative; referendum; I.C. §§ 34-1805(2) and 34-1813(2)(a); original jurisdiction; justiciability; standing; fundamental rights; strict scrutiny; private attorney general doctrine August 4, 2021
47194 SRM Arms, Inc. v. GSA Direct, LLC Opinion
SummaryRemittitur; statute of frauds; breach of contract; fraud; unjust enrichment August 4, 2021
48479 & 48499 Doe I v. Doe Opinion
SummaryPleading requirements; termination of parental rights August 3, 2021
48075 Allen v. Campbell Opinion
SummaryAttorney fees; prevailing party August 3, 2021
48012 Farms, LLC v. Isom Opinion
SummaryMootness; failure to appeal July 19, 2021
47703 Griffin v. Ste. Michelle Wine Estates LTD. Opinion Substitute
SummaryPersonal Jurisdiction; products liability July 19, 2021
47845 Waite v. Moto One KTM, LLC Opinion
SummaryUnemployment benefits; substantial and competent evidence; willful false statement or failure to report a material fact; I.C. § 72-1366(12) June 25, 2021
48290 Florer v. Walizada Opinion
SummaryIdaho Code § 6-320; Written notice; Breach of warranty of habitability June 24, 2021
47749 McCarthy Corporation v. Stark Investment Group Opinion
SummaryBreach of contract; Idaho Consumer Protection Act June 24, 2021
47846 Elgee v. Retirement Brd. of the Public Employee (PERSI) Opinion
SummaryJudicial review of agency action; Interest on unpaid PERSI benefits; Breach of fiduciary duty; Quasi-estoppel; Tax-neutralization damages June 22, 2021
48100 Tenny v. Loomis Armored US, LLC Opinion
SummaryMedical opinion; Temporal relation; Industrial Commission June 18, 2021
47984 Ada County v. Browning Opinion
SummaryMedical indigency lien; statute of limitation; attorney fees June 10, 2021
46652 Khurana v. IDHW Opinion
SummaryVexatious litigant; Idaho Court Administrative Rule 59; perfiling order; factual findings June 9, 2021
47812 Black v. DJO Global Opinion
SummaryProduct liability; malfunction theory; res ipsa loquitur; expert witnesses; summary judgment June 7, 2021
47484 Gem State Roofing, Incorp. v. United Components, Incorp. Opinion
SummaryNon-competition agreement; breach; damages; loss of profit; estoppel; injunction; prevailing party June 7, 2021
48018 Progressive Northwest Insurance Company v. Lautenschlager Opinion
SummaryInsurance policy interpretation; plain language; ambiguity; public policy; I.C. § 41-1839 May 27, 2021
47849 Ware v. City of Kendrick Opinion
SummaryNotice of tort claim; I.C. § 6-906, summary judgment May 19, 2021
47867 St. Alphonsus Regional Medical v. Ada County Opinion
SummaryMedical indigency; statutory interpretation; Idaho Code section 31-3502(18)A(e) May 19, 2021
47872 St. Luke's Health System v. Board of Commissioners of Gem County Opinion
SummaryMedical indigency; statutory interpretation; Idaho Code section 31-3502(18)A(e) May 19, 2021
47940 Off-Spec Solutions LLC v. Transportation Investors LLC Opinion
SummaryChoice-of-forum clause; choice-of-law clause; I.C. § 29-110(1); public policy; arbitration; attorney fees May 19, 2021
48003 Gangi v. Debolt Opinion
SummaryAttorney Fees; IRCP 54(e)(1) May 12, 2021
47909 Citizens Against Linscott v. Bonner County Board of Commissioners Opinion Substitute
SummaryJudicial review under IDAPA and LLUPA; associational standing; Idaho Rule for Electronic Service and Filing; effect of a void ordinance; arbitrary and capricious; I.C. § 12-117 May 3, 2021
47296 Latvala v. Green Enterprises Inc. Opinion Substitute
SummaryPrescriptive easement; scope of easement; standard of proof; costs April 26, 2021
47653 Kelly v. TRC Fabrication LLC Opinion
SummaryStatutory employer, exclusive remedy rule, category one, delivery services April 23, 2021
47138 Brockett Company LLC v. Crain Opinion Amended
SummaryPersonal jurisdiction; void judgment, long-arm statute, due process, minimum contacts, default judgment April 16, 2021
47668 Rouwenhorst v. Gem County Opinion
SummaryArbitrary or capricious; rezoning application; substantial and competent evidence; development agreement April 15, 2021
47917 Dupuis v. Eastern Idaho Health Services Inc Opinion
SummaryPremises liability; invitee; licensee; hospital visitor April 14, 2021
47304 Owen v. Smith Opinion Substitute
SummaryBoundary dispute; bona fide purchasers; irrigation easement April 14, 2021
46912/46913 Tricore Investments LLC v. Estate of Warren Opinion
SummaryStatute of frauds; repudiation; Idaho Consumer Protection Act; civil conspiracy; attorney fees; supersedeas bond; damages April 9, 2021
47687/47884/48132 Elsaesser v. Gibson Opinion
SummaryEjectment, uniform probate code, estate administration, personal representative, absolute owner. April 8, 2021
46882 Tucker v. State Opinion
SummarySixth Amendment (right to counsel); public defense system; injunctive relief; declaratory relief; class action. Mar 31, 2021
47918 Hayes v. Medioli Opinion
SummaryName change petition; attorney fees Mar 23, 2021
47865 Reagan v. Idaho Transportation Department Opinion Amended
SummaryDUI; State v. Clarke; misdemeanor arrest; unlawful arrest; unreasonable search and seizure; Idaho Code Section 49-1405(1)(b) Mar 23, 2021
46949 Tech Landing LLC v. JLH Ventures LLC Opinion
SummaryExpert witnesses; Idaho Rule of Evidence 702; Summary judgment; Circumstantial evidence of negligence Mar 23, 2021
47590 Hoffman v. City of Boise Opinion
SummaryTax increment financing; Urban renewal; Idaho Const. Art. VIII, Sec. 3; Local Economic Development Act ("LEDA") Mar 22, 2021
47364 Radford v. Van Orden Opinion Amended
SummaryStanding; trespass; I.C. § 35-103; partition fence; unjust enrichment Mar 22, 2021
47140 Agstar Financial Services v. Northwest Sand & Gravel Opinion
SummaryUnjust enrichment; restitution; prejudgment interest Mar 22, 2021
47149 Secol v. Fall River Medical PLLC Opinion
SummaryMotion for a new trial; IRE 614; expert witnesses; relevance; jury instructions; mootness doctrine Mar 19, 2021
47664 Gomersall v. St. Luke's Regional Medical Center Opinion
SummaryMedical malpractice; statute of limitations; I.C. § 5-230; Idaho Const. art. I, § 18; open courts provision; equal protection; equitable estoppel; declarations Mar 18, 2021
47020 Knudsen v. J.R. Simplot Company Opinion
SummarySummary judgment; hiring fraud; affirmative misrepresentation; duty to disclose; promissory estoppel; good faith and fair dealing; negligent infliction of emotional distress; I.C. § 12-120(3) Feb 19, 2021
46860 Wittkopf v. Stewart's Firefighter Food Catering, Inc. Opinion
SummaryIdaho Industrial Commission; unemployment; substantial and competent evidence; good cause; willful; false statement; material fact Feb 17, 2021
47924 Stanley v. Idaho Industrial Special Indemnity Fund Opinion
SummaryIndustrial Commission; statute of limitations; statutory interpretation Feb 10, 2021
46732 Cook v. Wiebe Opinion
SummaryIdaho Court Administrative Rule 59, sufficiency of factual findings, vexatious litigant, due process, administrative district judge Feb 9, 2021
47684 Asher v. McMillan Opinion
SummaryRestitution; Unjust enrichment; Unenforceable contract; Costs as evidence of value; Attorney fees on appeal Feb 9, 2021
46544 Choice Feed Inc. v. Montierth Opinion
SummaryFraud; damages Jan 26, 2021
48268 Bedke v. Ellsworth Opinion
SummaryPolitical question; standing; nondelegation doctrine; statutory interpretation; I.C. § 67-1602(3) Jan 06, 2021
47460 Wallace v. Heath Opinion
SummarySummary Judgment, Idaho Real Estate Brokerage Representation Act, customer, client, duty, real estate Dec 23, 2020
47488 Hollingsworth v. Thompson Opinion
SummaryIdaho Tort Claims Act; ITCA; medical malpractice; political subdivision; due diligence Dec 22, 2020
47483 Weitz v. Weitz Opinion
SummarySummary judgment; closely held corporations; genuine issue of material facts; ownership; declaratory judgment Dec 22, 2020
47602 Bromund v. Bromund Opinion
SummaryStatutory interpretation; retroactivity; 10 U.S.C. § 1408; community property; harmless error Dec 18, 2020
47133 Hawes v. Western Pacific Timber LLC Opinion
SummaryWage claim; contingency fee; oral agreement; special verdict; treble damages; I.C. 45-615(2); attorney fees; severance Dec 10, 2020
47548 Palmer v. ESHD Opinion
SummaryPublic interest; validation proceedings; I.C. 40-208; I.C. 40-203A; right-of-way Dec 04, 2020
47511 Merrill v. Smith Opinion
SummarySummary judgment; attorney fee agreement; burden of proof Dec 04, 2020
47543 Frizzell v. DeYoung Opinion
SummaryTEDRA Agreement; law of the case; attorney fees; IRCP 54(e) Nov 20, 2020
47004 Cover v. ID Board of Correction Opinion
SummaryIdaho Public Records Act; Board of Correction Rules 108 and 135; Idaho Rule of Civil Procedure 74; writs of mandamus; attorney fees on appeal Nov 20, 2020
47196 Siercke v. Siercke Opinion
SummaryAbsolute litigation privilege; qualified privilege; issue preservation; defamation per se Nov 10, 2020
47449 Uzzle v. Estate of Hirning Opinion
SummaryHarmless error; issue preservation; I.C. § 15-3-706; I.C. § 15-3-1001; probate proceedings; attorney's fees Nov 2, 2020
46827 Burns Concrete v. Teton County Opinion
SummaryBreach of contract; implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing; reliance damages; declaratory judgment; prejudgment interest; causation; attorney fees Nov 2, 2020
47246 Carter v. Gateway Parks LLC Opinion
SummaryRes judicata Nov 2, 2020
48053 Williams v. Hollinshead Opinion
SummaryWrit of habeas corpus; conditions of confinement; exhaustion of administrative remedies; cruel and unusual punishment; deliberate indifference; Eighth Amendment; summary judgment; attorney fees Nov 2, 2020
47122 Berian v. Berberian Opinion
SummaryQualified privilege, intentional infliction of emotional distress, malicious prosecution, defamation, invasion of privacy Oct 23, 2020
46639 Fisk v. McDonald Opinion
SummaryMedical malpractice; standard of care; expert witness, summary judgment, actual knowledge, foundation Oct 19, 2020
47165 Dlouhy v. Kootenai Hospital District Opinion
SummaryMedical malpractice, standard of care, expert witness, summary judgment, board certification, national standard of care Oct 16, 2020
47101 Schoeffel v. Idaho Dept. of Labor Opinion
SummaryIndustrial Commission; unemployment benefits; statutory interpretation; I.C. § 72-1367(4) Oct 9, 2020
47057 Kalb v. Wise Opinion
SummaryExtent of attorney's duty to beneficiary of will Oct 8, 2020
47098 Lingnaw v. Lumpkin Opinion
SummaryMeaning of "school" in I.C. § 18-8329(1)(d), declaratory relief and jurisdiction Oct 6, 2020
47482 State v. Zarinegar Opinion
SummaryMisrepresenting and omitting material facts, I.C. § 30-14-501(2), fraudulently diverting investor funds, I.C. § 30-14-501(4), summary judgment motions, counsel's motion to withdraw, pro se, sanctions for frivolous filing Oct 5, 2020
46832 Smith v. Smith Opinion
SummaryDivorce; division of property; community property; subject matter jurisdiction; out-of-state real property; receiver Oct 5, 2020
47261 Oswald v. Costco Opinion
SummaryNegligence; premises liability; duty to exercise reasonable care; foreseeability of harm; scope of discovery; expert witness reports Sept 24, 2020
46731 Ferguson v. Ferguson Opinion Substitute
SummaryTrustee duty; Idaho Code § 15-7-303; Trust no-contest provisions Aug 31, 2020
47346 Bennett v. Bank of Eastern Oregon Opinion
SummaryQuiet-title, I.C. § 45-1503, I.R.C.P. 12(b)(6), deeds of trust Aug 17, 2020
46930 Duncan V. Long Opinion
SummaryPremises liability for injury occurring on adjacent property Aug 7, 2020
46721 Davis v. Tuma Opinion
Summaryfraud; constructive fraud; constructive notice; record-as-notice; summary judgment; statute of limitations Aug 7, 2020
47270 Vickers v. Idaho Bd of Veterinary Medicine Opinion
SummaryAPA; contested case; aggrieved party; agency's prosecutorial discretion; I.C. § 67-5270 Aug 5, 2020
47099 Griffiths v. Griffiths Opinion
SummaryDivorce; minority share valuation; tax consequences Aug 5, 2020
47536 Goodrick - Certified Question of Law Opinion
SummaryCertified question of law regarding prisoner employment under I.C. § 20-209(1) Aug 3, 2020
46964 Packer v. Riverbend Communications Opinion
SummaryPremises liability; vendor; invitee; licensee; summary judgment Aug 3, 2020
46443 Porcello v. Estates of Porcello Opinion
SummaryPromissory note; deed of trust; latent ambiguity; integration; interpretation; parol evidence rule July 30, 2020
46334 Newton v. MJK/BJK MBK Lake; KAKM and Idaho Dept of Lands Opinion
SummaryLake Protection Act; Public Trust Doctrine, Nuisance July 30, 2020
47201 Neustadt v. Colafranceschi Opinion
SummaryInsurable interest; life insurance; public policy; fraudulent inducement July 30, 2020
46675 Roberts v. Jensen Opinion
SummaryNatural servitude; nuisance; trespass; summary judgment; ditch July 30, 2020
47427 Davis v. Davis Opinion
SummaryBeneficiary right to compel accounting of trust July 27, 2020
47074 Puckett v. Bergmann Opinion
SummarySetting aside a sheriff's sale July 22, 2020
46172 Richel Family Trust v. Worley Hwy Dist Opinion
SummaryValidation of public right-of-way; extrinsic evidence; statute of frauds; real property July 21, 2020
47363 Drakos v. Sandow Opinion
SummaryPromissory note; statute of limitations; acknowledgment July 21, 2020
47286 Frantz v. Osborn Opinion
SummaryAttorney fees; mootness July 21, 2020
47927 Johnson V. Murphy Opinion
SummaryChild custody order, abuse of discretion, I.C. § 32-717 July 15, 2020
46374 Bliss v. Minidoka Irrigation District Opinion
SummaryIdaho Tort Claim Act; notice; malicious prosecution; declaratory judgment July 15, 2020
46818 Gregory v. Stallings Opinion
SummaryOral contract; statute of limitations; I.C. § 5-217; equitable estoppel July 15, 2020
46852 Cazier Revocable Trust v. Cazier Opinion
SummaryQuiet title; I.R.C.P. 12(b)(6); hearsay; attorney fees July 15, 2020
46741 Williams v. St. Alphonsus Medical Center Opinion
SummaryDeclaratory judgments; justiciability; standing July 9, 2020
47789 IDHW and John Doe v. GAL and 4th Judicial District Casa Opinion
SummaryBiological parents presumption; home study; placement; guardian ad litem July 7, 2020
47193 City of Eagle v. Two Rivers Subdivision HOA Opinion
SummaryCommon law dedication July 6, 2020
47056 Wilson v. Mocabee Opinion
SummaryPartition; contribution; donative intent July 6, 2020
46627 IDJC v. Dudley Opinion
SummaryAppealable order; Idaho Dept of Juvenile Corrections; reimbursement July 2, 2020
46247 Investor Recovery Fund v. Hopkins Substitute Opinion
SummaryDirected verdict; fraud by nondisclosure July 2, 2020
46692 Lorenzen v. Pearson Opinion
SummaryShared driveway easement; ambiguity; quitclaim deed July 2, 2020
46993 Fell v. Fat Smitty's Opinion
SummaryIdaho Dram Shop Act; I.C. § 23-808 July 1, 2020
47041 Christopher W. James Trust v. Tacke Opinion
SummaryAmended judgment; prejudgment interest; I.R.C.P. 54(a)(1); contract interpretation and ambiguity June 22, 2020
47991 Ybarra v. Legislature of the State of Idaho & ID Bd of Education Opinion
SummaryIdaho Constitution Art. IX, Sec. 2; original jurisdiction; constitutional duties of Superintendent of Public Instruction June 18, 2020
46840 Travelers Insurance v. Ultimate Logistics Opinion
SummaryPetition for Judicial Review, Statutory Authority, Department of Insurance, Final Agency Action June 11, 2020
46936 McCandless v. Pease Opinion
SummaryMotion for a new trial; I.R.C.P. 59 June 9, 2020
46477 Ellis v. Ellis Opinion
SummaryMotion to intervene; reasonableness of fees for court-ordered receiver May 22, 2020
46941 Noell Industries v. State Tax Commission Opinion
SummaryBusiness income; I.C. § 63-3027; unitary business test May 21, 2020
47069 Nelson v. Evans Opinion
SummaryGrandparent visitation rights; I.C. § 32-719; best interests of child Apr 30, 2020
47061 Nelson v. IDOL and Franklin Group Opinion
SummaryTimeliness of appeal; unemployment benefits; mail and USPS postmarks Apr 28, 2020
46180 Smith v. Glenns Ferry Hwy Dist Opinion
SummaryWhistleblower Act; right to jury trial; lost wages; front pay; back pay; damages; advisory verdict; attorney fees Apr 22, 2020
46885 Walsh v. Swapp Law Opinion
SummaryI.C. 5-219(4); legal malpractice; statute of limitations; accrual; damages Apr 17, 2020
47029/47071/47086 Nampa Hwy Dist #1 v. Knight Opinion
Summary"Shelter rule"; bona fide purchasers; deed interpretation Apr 17, 2020
46819 Medrain v. Lee Opinion
SummaryFailure to timely appeal Apr 16, 2020
47534 DHW v. John Doe Opinion
SummaryTermination of parental rights; continuance; I.R.C.P. 15(b); inability to discharge parental responsibilities Apr 16, 2020
47230 DHW v. Jane Doe Opinion
SummaryTermination of parental rights; consent form; waiver of notice; revocability; guardian ad litem; I.C. 16-2005(4); I.C. 16-2007(3) Apr 16, 2020
47087 River Range v. Citadel Storage Opinion
SummaryContract interpretation; earnest money; waiver; covenant of good faith and fair dealing Apr 16, 2020
47077 Industrial Commission v. Sky Down Skydiving Opinion
SummaryEmployee or independent contractor; right to control; I.C. § 72-301; Workers Compensation insurance; recanted testimony
Apr 16, 2020
46743 Woolley v. IDOL Opinion
SummaryUnemployment benefits; corporate officer Apr 16, 2020
45425 Noel v. City of Rigby Opinion
SummaryDirected verdict; expert witnesses; collateral sources; comparative responsibility; premises liability Apr 14, 2020
46184 Alsco v. Fatty's Bar Opinion
SummarySuccessor liability; implied assumption; statute of frauds Apr 13, 2020
46350 Good v. Harry's Dairy Opinion
SummarySUBSTITUTE OPINION - UCC; breach of contract; implied warranty Mar 26, 2020
46926 Brown v. Brown Opinion
SummaryIdaho Code sections 15-2-201, 202 and 203; Elective shares; Quasi-community property; Attorney fees Mar 20, 2020
46587 Richardson v. Z & H Construction, LLC Opinion
SummaryWorker's compensation; Third party liability; Exclusive remedy rule; Idaho Code section 72-209(3) Mar 12, 2020
46403 Shubert v. Ada County Opinion
SummarySUBSTITUTE OPINION - Quasi-judicial immunity; Public defender; Idaho Tort Claims Act; Discretionary function exception Mar 12, 2020
46742 Employers Resource Mgmt Co v. Kealey Opinion
SummaryIdaho Reimbursement Incentive Act, separation of powers Mar 11, 2020
45890 Phillips v. Eastern ID Health Svcs Opinion
SummarySummary judgment; Medical Malpractice Act; expert witness; standard of care; I.R.C.P. 30(b)(6); I.C. 6-1012 Mar 11, 2020
46217 DEQ v. Gibson Opinion
SummaryTimely appeal; waiver; preemption; I.C. § 39-108(4); § 39-108(2); solid waste; Environmental Protection and Health Act; Solid Wast Management Rules; attorney's fees Feb 25, 2020
46114 Hungate v. Bonner County Opinion
SummaryI.C. § 67-5279(4); prejudice to substantial right Feb 21, 2020
46797 Fitzpatrick v. Kent Opinion
SummaryEasement; merger doctrine; attorney fees Feb. 18, 2020
45214 Eldridge v. West Opinion
SummarySubstitute Opinion. Medical malpractice; collateral sources; summary judgment Feb. 18, 2020
46258 Guenther v. Ryerson Opinion
SummaryPartnerships, winding up, dissolution, Idaho Uniform Partnership Act Feb 14, 2020
45552 Day v. Idaho Transportation Dept Opinion
SummaryMotion to dismiss standards; standing to pursue an inverse condemnation claim Feb 14, 2020
46672 Hiatt v. Health Care ID Credit Union; Dept of Labor Opinion
SummaryUnemployment benefits; workplace-related misconduct Feb 13, 2020
46027 Nelson v. Kaufman Opinion
SummaryNegligence; express agent; independent contractor; apparent agent; summary judgment Feb 10, 2020
45542 Gomez v. Crookham Opinion
SummarySubstitute Opinion. Worker's compensation; exception to the exclusive remedy rule Feb 6, 2020
46205 Ackerschott v. Mtn View Hospital; Redicare Opinion
SummaryMedical malpractice comparative negligence; proximate cause; expert witness Feb 5, 2020
46638 Brunobuilt v. Strata Opinion
SummaryEnforceable settlement agreement Feb 4, 2020
47415 IDHW v. Jane Doe Opinion
SummaryTermination of parental rights; best interests standard Feb 4, 2020
45980 Brauner v. AHC of Boise Opinion
SummaryMedical malpractice; expert witness disclosures; settlement agreements; I.R.C.P. 60(b)(3) motions; draft reports Feb 3, 2020
46595 Primera Beef v. Ward Opinion
SummaryAgency; scope of authority; attorney-client relationship Jan 31, 2020
47466 IDHW v. Jane Doe Opinion
SummaryTermination of parental rights Dec 23, 2019
46430 ABK v. Mid-Century Insurance Opinion
SummaryInsurance; breach of contract; water exclusion; bad faith Dec 23, 2019
47200 IDHW v. John Doe Opinion
SummaryTermination of parental rights Dec 23, 2019
47190 IDHW v. Jane Doe Opinion
SummaryTermination of parental rights Dec 23, 2019
46340 Ciccarello v. Davies Opinion
SummaryLegal malpractice; summary judgment; expert affidavit required Dec 23, 2019
47132 IDHW v. Jane Doe Opinion
SummaryTermination of parental rights Dec 23, 2019
47130 IDHW v. John Doe Opinion
SummaryTermination of parental rights Dec 20, 2019 47250 Jane Doe I and John Doe I v. Jane Doe Opinion
SummaryTermination of parental rights; abandonment; neglect; best interests of child Dec 20, 2019 45277 Papin v. Papin Opinion
SummaryDivorce; division of the marital estate; characterization of property Dec 20, 2019 46765 Wood v. Farmers Insurance Co of Idaho Opinion
SummaryUnderinsured motorist coverage; offset provision; public policy Dec 18, 2019 45202 Gordon v. U.S. Bank Opinion
SummaryNonjudicial foreclosure; preliminary injunction; summary judgment; dual tracking; postponement of a foreclosure Dec 17, 2019 46133 Trumble v. Farm Bureau Opinion
SummaryNon-competition clause; forteiture; misappropriation of trade secrets; intentional interference with a prospective economic advantage Dec 11, 2019 45553 Eastside Hwy Dist v. Delavan Opinion
SummaryBoundary by agreement; statutory public highway; deed interpretation; hearsay; bench trial Dec 11, 2019 45697 Hamberlin v. Bradford Opinion
SummaryI.C. § 7-1106; material mistake of fact Dec 11, 2019 45764 & 45883 Kenworth Sales v. Skinner Trucking Opinion
SummaryUnjust enrichment; officious intermeddler; affirmative defense; attorney fees Dec 6, 2019 45819 Lamont Bair Enterprises v. City of Idaho Falls Opinion
SummaryIdaho Tort Claims Act, immunity, discretionary function exception Dec 6, 2019 46354 Berrett v. Clark County School District Opinion
SummaryThe law of the case doctrine Whistleblower Act, wrongful termination, hearsay Nov 29, 2019 45721 Losee v. Deutsche Bank Nat'l Trust Opinion
SummaryHearsay; Rules of Evidence; affidavits; summary judgment Nov 29, 2019 46474 Rencher/Sundown LLC v. Pearson Opinion
SummaryFailure to timely serve Nov 26, 2019 46314 Klein v. Farmers Insurance Co. Opinion
SummaryUnderinsured motorist benefit claim; statute of limitations Nov 26, 2019 46118 Nemeth v. Shoshone County Opinion
SummaryRight -of-way validation; R.S. 2477, I.C. § 40-208(7); Quiet Title Act Nov 18, 2019 46000 First Bank of Lincoln v. Land Title of Nez Perce County Opinion
SummaryChoice of law; deficiency judgment; negligence; breach of contract; attorney's fees Nov 15, 2019 46056 Caldwell Land & Cattle v. Johnson Thermal Opinion
SummaryCommercial lease; unlawful detainer; breach of contract; proof of damages; attorney's fees Nov 13, 2019 46099 Fletcher v. Lone Mtn Rd Association Opinion
SummaryAttorney fees; Declaratory judgment; CC&Rs Nov 7, 2019 46323 Eagle Springs HOA v. Rodina Opinion
SummaryHomeowner's association; restrictive covenants; summary judgment Oct 28, 2019 45911 Johnson v. Idaho Dept of Labor Opinion
SummaryIRCP 59(e), IRCP 60(b), post-judgment motions, untimely appeal Oct 28, 2019 46144/46147 First Security v. Belle Ranch Opinion
SummaryRes judicata; water law; SRBA Oct 25, 2019 46748 Kelly v. Kelly Substitute Opinion
SummaryIRFLP 719; parenting time evaluation Oct 23, 2019 46193 Zeyen v. Pocatello/Chubbuck School Dist 25 Opinion
SummaryI.C. § 6-2202, Constitutionally Based Educational Claims Act; Idaho Rule of Civil Procedure 15(a); motion for leave to amend the pleadings; Idaho Rule of Civil Procedure 77, motion to certify the class; standing. Oct 18, 2019 46272 Raymond v. Idaho State Police Opinion
SummaryIntentional tort; prospective civil action; spoilation of evidence; motion to dismiss Oct 07, 2019 46026 D.A.F. v. Lieteau and Juvenile Corrections Nampa Opinion
SummaryIdaho Tort Claims Act; Notice of a tort claim; Tort actions in child abuse cases Oct 04, 2019 46696 Dodge v. Bonners Ferry Police Department Opinion
SummaryIdaho Tort Claims Act, tort claim, immunity, notice Oct 04, 2019 45205 Erickson v. Idaho Board of Licensure of Professional Engineers and Professional Land Surveyors Substitute Opinion
SummaryAppeal arising from revocation of license; statute of limitations for disciplinary proceedings Sept 10, 2019 45499 Picatti v. Miner Substitute Opinion
SummaryExcessive force; collateral estoppel; qualified immunity Sept 10, 2019 46269 Parkinson v. Bevis Opinion
SummaryBreach of fiduciary duty claim against attorney Sept 09, 2019 45896 Edwards v. Transportation Dept Opinion
SummaryCommercial driving privileges; disqualification; license holder Sept 05, 2019 45381/82/83/84 USA & Coeur d'Alene Tribe v. State of Idaho Opinion
SummaryWater law (CSRBA); federally reserved water rights Aug 27, 2019 45675 Eagle Creek Irrigation v. A.C & C.E Investments Opinion
SummaryWater rights, mutual irrigation company shares, appurtenancy Aug 27, 2019 45418 McInturff v . Shippy Opinion
SummaryWater law (CSRBA); collateral attacks; jurisdiction; license interpretation Aug 26, 2019 45917 Nye v. Katsilometes Opinion
SummaryContest of election; attorney fees; statutory interpretation Aug 26, 2019 46191 Stender v. SSI Food Services, Inc. Opinion
SummaryProperty taxes; Board of Tax Appeals July 25, 2019 46126 Wadsworth Reese v. Siddoway & Co Opinion
SummaryAttorney fees; compelling arbitration,; unjust enrichment July 12, 2019 46186 Ayala v. Meyers Farms Opinion
SummaryDue process, Industrial Commission July 10, 2019 45679 Aspen Park v. Bonneville County Opinion
SummaryProperty tax exemption, Idaho Code §63-602GG July 10, 2019 46364 Yu v. ID State University Opinion
SummaryStatutes of limitation June 17, 2019 46081 Austin v. Bio Tech Nutrients Opinion
SummaryNotice of Claim Status; Termination of PPI Benefits June 14, 2019 46062 Sylte v. IDWR Opinion
SummaryWater rights distribution June 13, 2019 46458 Does v. Doe Opinion
SummaryTermination of parental rights June 13, 2019 46023, 46024, 46112 McGimpsey v. D&L Ventures Opinion
SummaryUnregistered foreign corporation; Breach of contract June 13, 2019 45649 Regdab, Inc. v. Graybill Opinion
SummaryPleading requirements; Mechanic's lien; Attorney fees June 13, 2019 45700 McGivney v. Aerocet, Inc Opinion
SummaryWorker's compensation; permanent partial impairment; permanent partial disability; attorney fees June 13, 2019 45769 Idaho Retired Firefighters v. Public Employy Retirement Bd Opinion
SummaryJurisdiction; declaratory judgments; Industrial Commission June 7, 2019 45920 Turcott v. The Estate of Clarence D. Bates Opinion
SummaryUnjust enrichment versus quantum meruit damages June 7, 2019 45674 Smith v. State of Idaho, Industrial Special Indemnity Fund Opinion
SummaryOdd-lot worker; worker's compensation May 24, 2019 45698-45699 Eller v. Idaho State Police Opinion
SummaryIdaho Tort Claims Act; Whistleblower Act, non-economic damages May 23, 2019 45969 Security Investor Fund v. Crumb Opinion
SummaryEasement; merger clause; statute of frauds; doctrine of part-performance; attorney fees May 20, 2019 45933 Hardy v. Phelps Opinion
SummaryNotice under I.C. § 63-1005 May 15, 2019 46004 Moser v. Rosauers Opinion
SummaryI.C. § 72-433 medical examination May 14, 2019 45779 Kosmann v. Dinius Opinion
SummarySettlement agreement void; public policy; ethics May 3, 2019 45580 Dickinson Frozen Foods v. J.R. Simplot Co. (2nd Amnd) Opinion
SummaryLitigation privilege; breach of contract Apr 4, 2019 45845 Ehrlich v. IDOL Opinion
SummaryUnemployment benefits; attorney fees Mar 28, 2019 45782 Oliveros v. Rule Steel Opinion
SummaryWorker's compensation; PPD benefits Mar 18, 2019 46230 DHW v. Jane Doe Opinion
SummaryTermination of parental rights Mar 15, 2019 45404 Greenwald v. Western Surety Opinion
SummaryInsurance contract; summary judgment Mar 14, 2019 46482 DHW v. John Doe Opinion
SummaryTermination of parental rights Mar 14, 2019 46476 DHW v. Jane Doe Opinion
SummaryTermination of parental rights Mar 14, 2019 45581 Aguilar v. State ISIF Opinion
SummaryWorker's Compensation, total and permanent disability benefits Mar 12, 2019 46440 & 46441 DHW v. Jane Doe & John Doe Opinion
SummaryTermination of parental rights Mar 5, 2019 46457 DHW v. Jane Doe Opinion
SummaryTermination of parental rights Mar 4, 2019 45530 Verity v. USA Today, et al Opinion
SummaryDefamation by implication Mar 4, 2019 45450 Jackson v. Crow Opinion
SummaryBankruptcy; no-direct-action rule; nominal party Feb 27, 2019 45614 St. Lukes v. Bd of Commissioners of Gem Co Opinion
SummaryMedical indigency Feb 26, 2019 45052 SilverWing v. Bonner County Opinion
SummaryDamages for promissory estoppel Feb 25, 2019 45554 Colafranceschi v. Moody Opinion
SummaryVexatious litigant Feb 21, 2019 45093 T3 Enterprises v. Safeguard Business Sys Opinion
SummaryForum selection clause; arbitration Feb 21, 2019 45184 Mulberry v. Burns Concrete Opinion
SummaryRight of first refusal; extinguishment Feb 19, 2019 45092 Thurston and T3 v. Safeguard Opinion
SummaryBreach of distributorship agreement Feb 8, 2019 45451 Bailey v. Birch Opinion
SummaryAttorney fees Feb 8, 2019 45578 Galvin v. City of Middleton Opinion
SummaryAbandonment of prescriptive easement; attorney fees Feb 8, 2019 45555 Keller v. Ameritel Inns; IDOL Opinion
SummaryUnemployment benefits; statutory interpretation; attorney fees Feb 5, 2019 46545 Brent Regan v. Lawerence Denney Opinion
SummaryRe: Medicaid eligibility Jan 30, 2019 45781 McFarland v. Liberty Insurance Corp Opinion
SummaryInterpretation of policy; Dwelling Coverage; Other Structures Jan 29, 2019 45421 Floyd v. Bd of Ada County Commissioners Opinion
SummaryDue process; Tax deed Jan 29, 2019 45349 Scout, LLC v. Truck Insurance Opinion
SummaryInsurance; Four corners rule; Prior publication exclusion Jan 29, 2019 45459 Order Re: Vexatious Litigant (Van Hook) Opinion
SummaryVexatious litigant Jan 29, 2019 45918 Atkinson v. 2M Company, Inc. Opinion
SummaryException to the "going and coming" rule Jan 29, 2019 45543 Smith v. Treasure Valley Seed Co. Opinion
SummaryRule 11 Sanctions Jan 9, 2019 45517 Monitor Finance v. Wildlife Ridge Estates Opinion
SummaryRes judicata; statute of limitations of judicial foreclosure; Rule 19 required and indispensable parties Dec 29, 2018 45644 Idaho Power and IPUC v. Tidwell Opinion
SummaryIntervenor funding Dec 28, 2018
45181 No ID Bldg Cont Assoc v. City of Hayden Opinion
SummaryLegality of sewer connection fee Dec 21, 2018
45613 Crawford v. Guthmiller Opinion
SummaryFailure to timely serve Dec 21, 2018
45995 John and Jane Doe I v. Jane Doe Opinion
SummaryTermination of parental rights Dec 20, 2018
46021 Overholser (Taylor) v. Overholser Opinion
SummaryChild custody, and custodial grandparents Dec 20, 2018
45338 Bergeman v. Select Portfolio Svc Opinion
SummaryHome foreclosure sale and consolidation of cases Dec 19, 2018
45580 In the Matter of Adoption by Step-Parent Opinion
SummaryConsent required for adult adoption Dec 19, 2018
46182 DHW v. Jane Doe Opinion
SummaryTermination of parental rights Dec 18, 2018
45313 Smith v. Smith Opinion
SummarySubstitute Opinion - Uniform Power of Attorney Act; undue influence in will creation Nov. 29, 2018
45449 State v. Gibson Opinion
SummaryExoneration of cash deposit; attorney fees Nov 28, 2018
44722 & 45368 Westover v. Idaho Counties Risk Mgmt Opinion
SummarySubstitute Opinion - Legality of ICRMP; Attorney Fees Nov 28, 2018
46041 State v. Jane Doe Opinion
SummaryChild Protective Act; Justiciability; Mootness Nov 28, 2018
45390 Lee v. Willow Creek Ranch Est. Opinion
SummaryEasement; Equitable Servitudes Nov 7, 2018
45488 Lanham v. Fleenor Opinion
SummaryLegal malpractice; untimely appeal; will interpretation; general power of appointment Nov 1, 2018
44585 Valiant Idaho v. VP Incorporated Opinion
SummaryPrescriptive easement; equitable servitude; injunction; costs Oct 17, 2018
45116 H20 Environmental v. Farm Supply Opinion
SummaryAttorney fees Oct 15, 2018
44584 Valiant Idaho v. JV, LLC Opinion
SummaryMortgage priority; Rule 11 sanctions; costs Oct 11, 2018
44583 Valiant Idaho v. No. Idaho Resorts Opinion
SummaryCost award; abuse of discretion Sept 21, 2018
44532 Idaho First Bank v. Bridges Opinion
SummaryDeficiency claims; Rule 15(c); stay during appeal Sept 19, 2018
44543 Seward v. Musick Auction, LLC Opinion
SummarySettlement agreement enforcement Sept 14, 2018
46020 IDHW v. Jane Doe Opinion
SummaryTermination of parental rights Sept 10, 2018
45420 Sparks v. Idaho Dept of Labor Opinion
SummaryUnemployment benefits Sept 7, 2018
46304 Hart v. Idaho Secretary of State Opinion
SummaryIn Re: The Contest of the Election Sept 7, 2018
45884 Health & Welfare v. John Doe Opinion
SummaryTermination of parental rights Sept 6, 2018
44372 Western Community Ins v. Burks Tractor Opinion
SummaryIdaho Consumer Protection Act Sept 6, 2018
44567 Herrett v. St. Luke's Magic Valley RMC Opinion
SummaryMedical malpractice Sept 6, 2018
45454 Boswell v. Steele Opinion
SummaryDog bite liability standard Sept 6, 2018
44722 & 45368 Westover v. Idaho Counties Risk Mgmt Program Opinion
SummaryLegality of ICRMP Aug 22,2018
45805 In the Interest of Jane Doe II (under 18 years) Opinion
SummarySubstitute Opinion Guardianship Aug 3, 2018
45415 Marquez v. Pierce Painting Opinion
SummaryPermanent disability eligibility for undocumented immigrant Aug 3, 2018
45306 Johnson v. Wal-Mart Opinion
SummaryPremises liability; Operating methods; Negligence Aug 1, 2018
45146 PHH Mortgage v. Nickerson Opinion
SummaryJudicial foreclosure; Law of the case; Redemption July 30, 2018
45010 KDN v. WinCo Opinion
SummaryDenial of jury trial motion; piercing the corporate veil July 30, 2018
44889 Eastman v. Farmers Insurance Opinion
SummaryUnderinsured motorist coverage July 30, 2018
44634 Brooks v. Wal-Mart (Substitute Opinion) Opinion
SummarySummary judgment; premises liability; constructive notice July 27, 2018
45673 Woods v. Woods Opinion
SummaryModification of custody July 27, 2018
45336 Hodge v. Waggoner Opinion
SummaryOwnership of funds; slayer statute July 27, 2018
45727 Boe v. Boe Opinion
SummaryCustody dispute arising from relocation July 27, 2018
44833 Taylor v. Taylor Opinion
SummaryDivorce settlement; redemption of shares July 24, 2018
44909 Wittkopf v. Idaho Dept of Labor Opinion
SummaryDenial of unemployment benefits June 29, 2018
44914 Safaris Unlimited v. Jones Opinion
SummaryHandwriting exemplar; prodedural due process; motion to vacate sheriff's execution sale. June 28, 2018
45200 Lunneborg v. My Fun Life Opinion
SummaryDispute over severance pay in breach of employment contract. June 27, 2018
45018 Ekic v. Geico Opinion
SummaryUnderinsured motorist coverage June 26, 2018
45012 Clarke v. Latimer Opinion
SummaryPrevailing party; satisfaction of judgment; prejudgment interest; fees and costs June 12, 2018
44970/45069 Smith v. Smith Opinion
SummaryRes judicata; judgment renewal; failure to timely appeal June 8, 2018
45185 Hansen v. White Opinion
SummaryWhat constitutes "good cause" for failing to timely serve May 18, 2018
45105 Middleton v. Coleman Homes Opinion
SummaryPrevailing party; Attorney Fees; Entry of Judgment May 2, 2018
44927 Medical Recovery Svc v. Ugaki-Hicks Opinion
SummaryWhether I.R.C.P. 55(b)(1) requires proof of assignment May 1, 2018
45143 Savage v. Scandit, Inc. Opinion
SummaryIdaho Wage Claim Act Apr 27, 2018
44735 Litke v. Munkhoff Opinion
SummaryNegligence; new trial; remitittur; I.R.C.P. 60(b) Apr 26, 2018
44794 Irish v. Hall Opinion
SummaryClaim involving defamatory statement conveyed via wireless internet designation Apr 24, 2018
44625 Davison v. DeBest Plumbing Opinion
SummaryBreach of contract, negligence Apr 24, 2018
45020 Dept of H&W, et al v. Does I Opinion
SummaryPost-termination Child Protection Act Apr 24, 2018
44886 Idaho Falls v. H-K Contractors Opinion
SummaryStatute of limitations in municipal contract action Apr 20, 2018
45082-45083 Budget Truck Sales v. Tilley Opinion
SummaryFraud in the inducement of a settlement agreement Apr 13, 2018 45435 H & W v. John Doe Opinion
SummaryJudgment terminating John Doe's parental rights is vacated Apr 5, 2018 44855 Baker v. KAL, LLC Opinion
SummaryWhether an express easement was granted Apr 5, 2018 44836 Medical Recovery Svc v. Neumeier Opinion
SummaryMedical services bill; implied-in-fact condition precedent Apr 4, 2018 44975 Frizzell v. DeYoung Opinion
SummaryAppeal involving the Trust and Estate Dispute Resolution Act Apr 4, 2018 44864 Nielson v. Talbot Opinion
SummaryProperty line dispute regarding boundary by agreement. Apr 4, 2018 44784 Petrus Family Trust v. Kirk Opinion
SummaryClaim for breach of the implied warranty of habitability. Mar 30, 2018 44897 Farm Bureau Ins v. Cook Opinion
SummaryDuty to defend; occurrence; intentional acts; insurance policy Mar 13, 2018 44498 Verdell Olson v. Phillip F. Moulton Opinion
SummaryWater rights; easement; natural servitude Mar 8, 2018 45419 Jane Doe I v. John Doe (2017-31) Opinion
SummaryTermination of parental rights Mar 7, 2018 44944 Ricky Holden v. Jackie Weece Opinion
SummarySRBA; waiver of issue on appeal Mar 6, 2018 45363 and 45385 H&W v. John Doe and Jane Doe Opinion
SummaryTermination of parental rights Mar 5, 2018 43848 Brent Regan v. Jeff Owen Opinion
SummaryOn Rehearing. Tax deed does not extinguish easement Mar 5, 2018 44552 Charles Hartgrave v. City of Twin Falls and SIF Opinion
SummaryINDUSTRIAL COMMISSION appeal involving compensability under Idaho's Worker's Compensation Act Mar 2, 2018 44716 Gary and Glenna Eden v. State of Idaho Opinion
SummaryLate claims; SRBA; water rights Mar 2, 2018 44887 William R. Fischer v. James F. Croston Opinion
SummaryAppeal involving boundary by agreement between coterminous owners as opposed to agents Mar 2, 2018 45016 St. Al's RMC v. Ada Co Sheriff & Bd of Comm Opinion
SummaryCounty responsibility for inmate medical expenses Feb 14, 2018 45019 Medical Recovery Svcs. v. Lopez Opinion
SummaryPostjudgment attorney fees Feb 9, 2018 45485 IDHW v. Doe (2017-36) Opinion
SummaryTermination of parental rights Jan 18, 2018 44718 MFG Financial Inc. v. Justin Vigos Opinion
SummaryBreach of Contract Jan 18, 2018 44562 Hull v. Geisler Opinion
SummarySubdivision of property dispute Jan 17, 2018 45187 Pocatello Hospital v. Corizon Opinion
SummaryCertified Question of Law Re: privatized correctional medical providers under contract with IDOC Jan 17, 2018 44090 Mendez v. University Health Svcs BSU Opinion
SummaryClaim of discrimination in termination of employment Jan 10, 2018 44791 David Johnson v. David Crossett Opinion
SummaryClaims of former members of an LLC for breach of fiduciary duties are dismissed Jan 9, 2018 44863 Dea Haight v. Idaho Dept of Transportation Opinion
SummaryComplaint for damages and declaratory and injunctive relief Jan 9, 2018 44894 Barnes v. Kirk Jackson Appeal from dismissal of lawsuit seeking declaration of forfeiture as to water rights Jan 4, 2018 44768 Jadwiga Melton v. Heinz Alt Appeal from district court reversal of magistrate decision holding that a claim against an estate was timely Jan 2, 2018 44636 Black Canyon Irrig Dist v. State / Suez Water Late Claims; "supplemental beneficial use storage water rights" Dec 27, 2017 44477 Clark v. Jones Gledhill Fuhrman Gourley Attorney lien Dec 26, 2017 44612 Lincoln Land Co v. LP Broadband Dispute arising out of placement and use of antenna equipment Dec 22, 2017 45207 Dept of Health & Welfare v. Doe I (2017-21) Statutory termination of parental rights by two adoptive parents after John Doe I ("Child") was alleged to have sexually assaulted a sibling. Dec 21, 2017 44416 Nettleton v. Canyon Outdoor Media Opinion
SummaryThis case specifically raises issues regarding entitlement to commission wages following resignation Dec 21, 2017 44635 USA v. Black Canyon Irrigation Dist Opinion
SummaryWater rights Dec 21, 2017 44898 Ada Co Bd of Equalization v. J.R. Simplot Opinion
SummaryCharitable property tax exemption Dec 21, 2017 44604 Jobe v. Dirne Clinic / Heritage Health Opinion
SummaryINDUSTRIAL COMMISSION Occupational disease claim Dec 21, 2017 44303 Mortensen v. Berian and Sturgis Opinion
SummaryAppeal from district court ruling in favor of Mortensen's claims for repair of damages to a ditch on adjoining properties. (Berian's counterclaim for tresspass was nominally awarded). Dec 13, 2017 44240 Swafford v. Huntsman Springs Inc Opinion
SummarySUBSTITUTE OPINION Easement Dec 8, 2017 45180 John Doe & Jane Doe (2017-19) v. John Doe I & Jane Doe I Opinion
SummaryParents appeal magistrate decision granting Grandparent's petition for termination of parental rights of mother & father to daughter (one of six children) Dec 6, 2017 44297 Sharon Wechsler v. Norman J. Wechsler Opinion
SummaryIssues on appeal relate to Sharon's attempt to collect on a Foreign Judgment filed in Idaho from a Divorce Judgment entered in New York Dec 4, 2017 44683 Dennis B. Current v. Dept of Labor Opinion
SummaryUnemployment benefits Dec 4, 2017 44418 State Board of Land v. Philip Hudson Opinion
SummaryAppeal from finding that Hudson violated the Idaho Lake Protection Act Nov 29, 2017 44446 Daniel Paslay v. A&B Irrigation District Opinion
SummaryLandowners' complaint against Irrigation District for diverting water Nov 29, 2017 44526 CMJ Properties v. JP Morgan Chase Bank Opinion
SummaryLandowner's claim that the lender's time to foreclose the deed of trust had expired Nov 29, 2017 43890 Peggy Cedillo v. Farmers Ins Co of Idaho Opinion
SummaryInsurance bad faith claim for underinsured motorist coverage Nov 28, 2017 44249 SCHWEITZER BASIN WATER CO v. SCHWEITZER FIRE DIST Opinion
SummaryWrit of prohibition preventing the District from taking action against the Company related to fire hydrants ownned by third-party homeowners Nov 8, 2017 45029 Searle v. Searle Opinion
SummaryChild custody dispute Nov 8, 2017 44594 Todd J. Phillips v. Richard D. Gomez Opinion
SummaryAppeal from denial of request to recover actual damages; finding a claim for breach of contract had been fully satisfied by retention of non-refundable earnest money as liquidated damages Nov 3, 2017 44393 Manwaring Inv v. City of Blackfoot Opinion
SummaryManwaring alleges the City was overcharging for wastewater utilities. Nov 3, 2017 44478 Coeur d' Alene Tribe v. Johnson Opinion
SummaryAppeal from default judgment in district court recognizing a tribal judgment imposing a civil penalty Nov 3, 2017 44511 Employers Resuorce Mgmt Co v. Ronk Opinion
SummaryEmployer's complaint for declaratory relief for lack of standing Oct 31, 2017 43936 & 44190 Washington Federal v. Hulsey Opinion
SummaryForeclosure Sept 25, 2017 44378 Linda Dunn v. Idaho Tax Commission Opinion
SummaryTax deficiency Sept 22, 2017 44997 Doe II v. Doe I Opinion
SummaryParental Rights Sept 22, 2017 44171 Bedard & Musser v. City of Boise Opinion
SummaryClaim to quiet title Sept 21, 2017 44874 Jane Doe I v. Jane Doe II Opinion
SummaryAppeal from decision to vacate adoption judgment and to dismiss petition for co-adoption Sept 20, 2017 43686 Taylor v. Riley Opinion
SummaryAppeal from judgement dismissing claims Sept 7, 2017 44036 Watkins v. Watkins Opinion
SummaryBreach of Contract Sept 6, 2017 44074 Hill-Vu Mobile Home Pk v. City of Pocatello Opinion
SummaryAction seeking to recover money unlawfully collected from City water users Aug 25, 2017 44447 Sharon R. Hammer v. Nils Ribi Opinion
SummaryAppeal from order dismissing complaint for claims of civil assault Aug 24, 2017 43832 Krucker v. State Tax Commission Opinion
SummaryEstate appeals the amount of tax imposed on an inheritance Aug 24, 2017
44554 Barrios v. Zing, LLC & State Ins Fund Opinion
SummaryAppeal from Industrial Commission order requiring employer & surety to pay for a guardian and conservator for claimant July 18, 2017
45001 Nate, et al. v. Lawerence Denney Opinion
SummaryWrit of mandate - Original proceeding regarding grocery tax July 12, 2017
44357 Bailey v. Peritus I Assets Management Opinion
SummaryAppeal from judgment dismissing breach of contract claim July 11, 2017
44211 Chandlers-Boise v. State Tax Commission Opinion
SummaryAppeal from deficiency determination; sales tax on gratuities automatically added July 11, 2017
44109 Weymiller v. Lockheed Idaho Technologies Opinion
SummaryAppeal from order denying additional medical care. July 11, 2017
43724 Bret and Marti Kunz v. Nield, Inc. Opinion
SummaryInsurance contract dispute regarding profit sharing distribution July 11, 2017
44326 Krinitt v. Idaho Dept of Fish & Game Opinion
SummaryAppeal from ruling that statutory employer was entitled to immunity from work-related death. July 10, 2017
44252 Idaho Independent Bank v. Marty D. Frantz Opinion
SummaryAppeal from a judgment in favor of the lender against the guarantors of construction loans made to the guarantors' closely held corporation. June 30, 2017
43712 Lisa A. Ellefson v. Stephen Palmer Opinion
SummaryPalmer appeals from order granting new trial June 29, 2017
43547 Jack McCall v. Silva Dairy Opinion
SummaryBusiness dispute involving claims and counterclaims for livestock herd management June 29, 2017
44155 John E. Fuquay v. Susie Low Opinion
SummaryProperty dispute; easement June 29, 2017
44764 H & W v. Jane Doe (2017-3) Termination of Parental Rights (mother)
June 23, 2017
44148 H20 Environmental v. Proimtu MMI Contract dispute involving whether personal jurisdiction is proper over an out-of-state defendant.
June 21, 2017
43741 Fletcher v. Lone Mountain Rd Assoc Opinion
SummaryProperty owners dispute with "Subdivision" over Covenants, Conditions and Restrictions
June 20, 2017
44053 Forbush & Hymas v. Sagecrest POA Opinion
SummaryAppeal from district court's grant of summary judgment in death by carbon monoxide case
June 20, 2017
44129 Whitney L. Bright v. Roman Maznik Opinion
SummaryAppeal from district court's grant of summary judgment in claims arising from dog attack June 20, 2017
44207 City of Blackfoot v. Gary Spackman Opinion
SummaryWater rights June 20, 2017
44622 Carlos Martinez v. Evelia Carrasco Opinion
SummaryAppeal from order for custody rotation June 20, 2017
44795-44796 Health & Welfare v. Jane Doe (2017-6) and John Doe (2017-7) Opinion
SummaryAppeals from termination of mother's and father's parental rights June 9, 2017
44767 Health & Welfare v. John Doe (2017-4) Opinion
SummaryParental rights termination (father) June 9, 2017
44095 Hauser Lake Rod & Gun Club v. City of Hauser Opinion
SummaryAppeal from district court order denying attorney fees to prevailing party June 7, 2017
44419 Jane Doe v. Jane Doe I Opinion
SummaryCustody dispute in separation between child's biological mother and mother's life partner June 6, 2017
43831 Christina J. Greenfield v. Ian D. Smith Opinion
SummaryLegal malpractice claim June 2, 2017
44704 Health & Welfare v. Jane Doe (2016-47) Opinion
SummaryParental rights termination (mother) June 1, 2017
43346 Portfolio Recovery Assoc v. MacDonald Opinion
SummaryDebt collection May 31, 2017
44091 Henrie v. Church of Latter-Day Saints Opinion
SummaryTort claim for personal injury against the Church May 31, 2017
43968 Jimmy Christy Jr v. Grasmick Produce Opinion
SummaryINDUSTRIAL COMMISSION Unemployment May 31, 2017
44662 John & Jane Doe II v. John Doe I Opinion
SummaryParental rights termination (father) May 26, 2017
43548 Jack McCall v. Max Silva Opinion
SummaryPersonal liability and claim for attorney fees May 26, 2017
44241 Steven Andrews v. State Industrial SIF Opinion
SummaryINDUSTRIAL COMMISSION Workers' Compensation claim May 26, 2017
43640 Nathon A. Baughman v. Wells Fargo Bank Opinion
SummaryForeclosure May 26, 2017
44117 Shammie L. Fisher v. Garrison Property Opinion
SummarySUBSTITUTE OPINION. Plaintiff seeks to recover loss of her house under insurance policy May 23, 2017
43452 Ada Co Hwy Dist v. Brooke View, Inc Opinion
SummaryACHD appeals from district court judgment award including prejudgment interest and attorney's fees May 12, 2017
43868 Thomas Arnold v. City of Stanley Opinion
SummaryAppeal from denial of building permit May 11, 2017
43725 Jaymie Quigley v. Travis Kemp Opinion
SummaryDiscovery dispute in medical malpractice case May 11, 2017
43802 Harmon v. State Farm Mutual Auto Ins Co Opinion
SummaryClaims for bad faith and breach of insurance agreement May 09, 2017
44186 Leticia M. Salinas v. Bridgeview Estates Opinion
SummaryINDUSTRIAL COMMISSION. Employer and Surety appeal the Commission's grant of attorney fees May 01, 2017
42634 Melinda Deiter v. Donald Coons Opinion
SummaryA steer purchased for slaughter was later contaminated with E. coli. Appeal from dismissal of claims against seller. Apr 28, 2017
43011 American Semiconductor v. Sage Silicon Solutions Opinion
SummaryClaims for damages Apr 28, 2017
43922 Tracy Tucker, et al v. State of Idaho Opinion
SummaryClass action complaint - Criminal defendants challenge Idaho's public defense system Apr 28, 2017
44139 Medical Recovery Svcs v. Penny R. Siler Appeal from district court order denying attorney fees Apr 27, 2017
43907 Russell Joki v. State Bd of Education Action challenging the constitutionality of fees Apr 14, 2017
44046 Val and Laree Westover v. Jase Cundick Appeal from judgment and denial of request for writs of mandate and prohibition. Apr 12, 2017
44160 Lopez v. Vanbeek Herd Partnership; SIF Appeal from denial of additional Workman's Comp benefits for hearing loss in workplace accident Apr 10, 2017
44133 Seth Griffith v. Jumptime, Meridian Appeal from judgment dismissing an action against JumpTime, Meridian. Mar 10, 2017
44408 H&W v. Jane Doe (2016-32) Opinion
SummaryTermination of parental rights (mother) Mar 2, 2017
42301 Michael L. Kelly v. Pamela Wagner Opinion
SummaryAppeal from judgment awarding payments for construction work; damages and prejudgment interest. Feb 28, 2017
43730 John E. Wyman v. John J. Eck, M.D. Opinion
SummaryMedical malpractice claim / statute of limitations Feb 28, 2017
43677 Channel (Blacker) Rish v. Home Depot Opinion
SummaryINDUSTRIAL COMMISSION Worker's Compensation Feb 27, 2017
43747 Agstar Financial v. Gordon Paving Co, Inc Opinion
SummaryBreach of personal guarantee Feb 24, 2017
42932 Agstar Financial v. NW Sand & Gravel Opinion
SummaryAppeal from award of attorney fees Feb 24, 2017
43863 Davis v. Hammack Mgmt / ISIF Opinion
SummaryINDUSTRIAL COMMISSION Permanent disability Feb 24, 2017
43440 Nicholson v. Coeur d'Alene Placer Mining Corp Opinion
SummaryAppeal from judgment denying recovery on alleged oral promise Feb 24, 2017
43432 Douglas Visser v. Auto Alley, LLC Opinion
SummaryAppeal from order granting writ of possession and quieting title to certain real property Feb 24, 2017
43649 The Watkins Co v. Estate of Michael Storms Opinion
SummaryAppeal from award of attorney fees Feb 23, 2017
43708 Rodriguez v. Consolidated Farms, LLC Opinion
SummaryINDUSTRIAL COMMISSION Permanent disability under the odd-lot doctrine Feb 2, 2017 43902 Donald Schoorl v. Guild Mortgage Co Opinion
SummaryAdverse possession Jan 27, 2017 42467 Union Bank, N.A. v. North Idaho Resorts Opinion
SummaryAppeal from decision holding Union Bank possessed a superior lien Jan 27, 2017 42479 Union Bank, N.A. v. JV L.L.C Opinion
SummaryMortgage priority dispute Jan 24, 2017 43755 Michael S. Molen v. Ronald D. Christian Opinion
SummaryAppeal from dismissal of legal malpractice action. Jan 23, 2017 43603 G. Lance Salladay v. Eric Bowen Opinion
SummaryOrder remanding case to irrigation district is reversed. Jan 23, 2017
42916 Dwight Green v. James Green Opinion
SummaryLawsuit brought by siblings of a trust alleging undue influence Jan 20, 2017
43554 Grant Lee v. Jeremy Litster Opinion
SummaryEnforceability of promissory notes Jan 19, 2017
43695 Gallagher v. Best Wester Cottontree Opinion
SummaryAppeal from dismissal of complaint for personal injury Dec 30, 2016
43538 Maravilla v. J. R. Simplot Co. Opinion
SummaryINDUSTRIAL COMMISSION. Industrial accident - Worker's Compensation Dec 30, 2016
42566 Duane Kemmer v. Bob Newman Opinion
SummaryAppeal from decision that directors elected at a special membership meeting was proper. Dec 22, 2016
44376 Re: Termination of Parental Rights Opinion
SummaryMother appeals Dec 21, 2016
43295 Jeanette Hoffman v. Bd of Local Improvement Dist No. 1101 Opinion
SummaryAMENDED 1-04-2017 Assessments levied on properties
Dec 21, 2016
43697 Evangelical Lutheran Good Samaritan Society v. Bd of Equalization of Ada County Opinion
SummaryCharitable property tax exemption Dec 21, 2016
43315 Jose Garcia v. Absolute Bail Bonds Opinion
SummaryAppellant contends the district court award of damages was insufficient. Dec 21, 2016
43079 Sharon R. Hammer v. City of Sun Valley Opinion
SummaryAppeal from judgment dismissing lawsuit seeking to recover under Idaho Protection of Public Employees Act. Dec 21, 2016
43620 R. Gordon Schmidt v. Tim Huston Appeal from judgment denying a claim for contribution on equitable principles between co-guarantors Dec 12, 2016
43296 David Kosmann v. Leo Gilbride Attorney's fees Dec 9, 2016
43627 Harrentsian v. Gennieve and Frank Hill Constructive trust Dec 8, 2016
42465 Prehn and Bandak v. Michael L. Hodge, II Breach of fiduciary duty Dec 8, 2016
43343 Marian G. Hoke v. NeYada, Inc. Opinion
SummaryLease / option to purchase Dec 2, 2016
43410 Candace Elliott v. Steve Murdock Opinion
SummaryElliott alleges defamation Nov 30, 2016
43078 Silver Creek Seed v. Sunrain Varieties Opinion
SummaryClaim & counter claim for breach of contract Nov 25, 2016
42850 Eagle Equity Fund v. TitleOne Corp Opinion
SummaryClaims for tortious interference Nov 23, 2016
42245 Inclusion, Inc v. Idaho Dept of Health & Welfare Opinion
SummaryAward of attorney fees Nov 23, 2016
42719/43007 Robert Wolford v. Shawn Montee Opinion
SummaryPromissory notes and district court's order of contempt Nov 23, 2016
42698 Dennis J. Sallaz and Marcy Fox v. Eugene (Roy) Rice Opinion
SummaryDenial of motion for a directed verdict Nov 18, 2016
43639 Ronnel e. Barrett v. Hecla Mining Co Opinion
SummaryMining incident (rock burst) causing injury Nov 18, 2016
43269 Patricia Marek v. Hecla, Limited Opinion
SummaryMining accident, fatal injury Nov 16, 2016
43326 The David and Marvel Benton Trust v. McCarty Opinion
SummaryMotion to quiet title to certain property Nov 3, 2016
44219 John Doe v. Idaho State Bar Opinion
SummaryReview of decision of the Professional Conduct Board Nov 3, 2016
42596 Victoria H. Smith v. Treasure Valley Seed Co. Opinion
SummaryAttorney fees Nov 3, 2016
43458 Drug Testing Compliance Grp v. DOT Compliance Service Opinion
SummaryViolation of settlement agreement between parties. Nov 3, 2016
43005 CNW v. New Sweden Irrigation Dist Opinion
SummaryNotice of tort claim issue Nov 3, 2016
44268 Re: Termination of Parental Rights Opinion
SummaryMother appeals Nov 3, 2016
43473 James Adam Slavens v. Melanie Slavens Opinion
SummaryEstate Nov 2, 2016
43618 Thomas C. Millard v. ABCO Construction Opinion
SummaryINDUSTRIAL COMMISSION Workers Compensation Nov 2, 2016
43920 Jane Doe I v. John Doe II; John Doe II and Jane Doe II v. Jane Doe I and John Doe I Opinion
SummaryCustody Nov 2, 2016
43576 Martin Frantz v. Hawley Troxell Opinion
SummaryLegal malpractice and breach of fiduciary duty Nov 2, 2016
43122 Jessica E. Barr v. CitiCorp Credit Svc Opinion
SummaryINDUSTRIAL COMMISSION Unemployment benefits Nov 2, 2016
42313 Path to Health v. Daren Long Opinion
SummaryClaims of negligence and fraud alleging misrepresentation that property purchased was zoned for commercial when it was actually zoned for residential use. Nov 1, 2016
44285 Re: Termination of Parental Rights Opinion
SummaryFather appeals Nov 1, 2016
41869 David Samples v. Dr. Ray W. Hanson Opinion
SummaryMedical malpractice Nov 1, 2016
42538 Pend Oreille View Estates Homeowners' Association v. T.T. LLC and Farner Opinion
SummaryAppeal from judgment upholding money judgments against lot owners for the cost of paving a road providing access from the county road. Nov 1, 2016
42958 Shatto v. Syringa Surgical Center Opinion
SummaryMedical malpractice Nov 1, 2016
43527 Burns Concrete, Inc v. Teton County Opinion
SummaryAppeal from judgment holding that the force majeure clause did not apply Nov 1, 2016
42864 Betty S. Harper v. Dept of Labor Opinion
SummaryINDUSTRIAL COMMISSION Appeal from denial of claim for unemployment benefits Nov 1, 2016
42517 City of Sandpoint v. Independent Hwy Dist Opinion
SummaryConcerning the legality of a Joint Powers Agreement between the City and IHD. Sept 29, 2016
42938 Nancy J. Shepherd v. John M. Shepherd - Opinion
- SummaryAppeal from magistrate decision in a divorce decree allowing visitation rights to non-parent father. Sept 28, 2016
42087 Randy Hoffer v. Scott A. Shappard, D.O. - Opinion
- SummaryAppeal from denial of post-trial motions following a jury verdict of medical negligence. Sept 15, 2016
43774 Jane Doe (2016-01) v. John Doe - Opinion
- SummaryProtection Order (father/daughter) Sept 14, 2016
42332 Thornton v. Pandrea - Opinion
- SummaryEasement rights Sept 14, 2016
44064 H&W v. Jane Doe (2016-11) - Opinion
- SummaryTermination of parental rights (mother) Sept 13, 2016
42742 The Estate of Kurt Aikele v. City of Blackfoot - Opinion
- SummaryAppeal from denial of Workers' Compensation & death benefits Sept 13, 2016
42980 Robert A. Kantor v. Sondra Louise Kantor - Opinion
- SummaryProperty settlement Sept 13, 2016
41946 Robert A. Kantor v. Sondra Louise Kantor - Opinion
- SummaryProperty settlement Sept 12, 2016
43532 Kenneth Eyer v. Idaho Forest Group - Opinion
- SummaryAttorney fees Sept 12, 2016
43081 Cummings v. No Title Co of Idaho - Opinion
- SummaryAttorney fees & costs Sept 12, 2016
42593 Andrew Kirk v. Ann B. Wescott - Opinion
- SummaryQuiet title; easement Sept 12, 2016
44174/44175 H&W v. Jane Doe / John Doe - Opinion
- SummaryTermination of parental rights Sept 9, 2016
43281 Edward Jordan v. Dean Foods - Opinion
- SummaryWorker's Compensation Sept 9, 2016
43161 Tasha Jeffcoat v. Idaho Dept of Correction - Opinion
- SummaryUnemployment Insurance Sept 9, 2016
44092 H&W v. Jane Doe (2016-14) - Opinion
- SummaryTermination of parental rights Sept 9, 2016
43191 Turner House v. Treasure Valley Area of Narcotics Anonymous - Opinion
- SummaryNegligence action Sept 9, 2016
42621 Stafford L. Smith v. Woodruff D. Smith - Opinion
- SummaryContract for a commercial transaction and award of attorney fees. Sept 9, 2016
43147 Medical Recovery Svcs. v. Olsen - Opinion
- SummaryAMENDED 9-27-16: Attempt to collect post-judgment costs and attorney fees. Sept 9, 2016
44056 Chelsea Reed v. Zane Reed - Opinion
- SummaryChild custody Aug 4, 2016
42611 Ballard v. Kerr, M.D,; Silk Touch Laser - Opinion
- SummaryWrongful death action July 27, 2016
43082 Spectra Site Communications v. Lawrence - Opinion
- SummaryEasement dispute July 27, 2016
43376 Parks v. Safeco Ins Co of Illinois - Opinion
- SummaryClaim of bad faith July 27, 2016
42859 Gearhart v. Mutual of Enumclaw Ins Co - Opinion
- SummaryEnumclaw seeks to enforce the anti-stacking policy limits for maximum coverage July 22, 2016
43019 Barry Searcy v. State Bd of Correction - Opinion
- SummaryPrisoner civil rights claim Re: unlawful charges for fees July 22, 2016
42625 Barbara Morrison v. St. Luke's RMC - Opinion
- SummaryMedical malpractice July 22, 2016
44010 H & W v. John Doe (2016-09) - Opinion
- SummaryTermination of parental rights of FATHER July 12, 2016
42947 Carol English v. James Taylor, D.O. - Opinion
- SummaryMedical negligence claim July 7, 2016
43289 David W. Stiles v. Walter A. Amundson - Opinion
- SummaryA premises liability action brought against the property owner in a personal injury case. July 7, 2016
42999 Richard T. Wright v. Ada County - Opinion
- SummaryEmployment related claims including violation of the Idaho Protection of Public Employees Act, Family Medical Leave Act, negligent and intentional infliction of emotional distress. June 29, 2016
42326 Capstar Radio v. Douglas P. Lawrence - Opinion
- SummaryEasement June 28, 2016
43461 Bryan Trucking v. Terry Gier - Opinion
- SummaryAppeal from costs & attorney fees awarded following a stipulation to dismiss claims. June 28, 2016
43484 Susan J. Warner v. Idaho Transportation Dept - Opinion
- SummaryDUI; the Department appeals the district court's reduction of the duration of Warner's license suspension June 28, 2016
43482 Tiller White, LLC v. Canyon Outdoor Media, LLC - Opinion
- SummaryEasement June 28, 2016
42690 John B. Kugler v. Ron Nelson - Opinion
- SummaryAppeal from district court's dismissal of Kugler's case finding all claims to be derivative. June 28, 2016
42921 H-D Transport v. Michael D. Pogue - Opinion
- SummaryLegal malpractice June 2, 2016
43796 In The Matter of The Declaration of Parentage - Opinion
- SummaryAppeal from the district court's ruling in a request for a declaratory judgment by the Gestational Carrier (surrogate mother). June 1, 2016
43086 Lori Ann Wilson v. David Wayne King - Opinion
- SummaryChild support May 27, 2016
43564 Rangen, Inc v. North Snake Ground Water Dist. - Opinion
- SummaryWater rights May 27, 2016
43234 Joseph Gerdon v. Con Paulos, Inc. - Opinion
- SummaryINDUSTRIAL COMMISSION - Appeal from denial of benefits for psychological care after a work related injury. May 27, 2016
43651 DOES I v. DOES II - Re Conservatorship of Minor Child - Opinion
- SummaryAppeal from Magistrate judgment appointing co-guardianship of minor child. May 3, 2016
43158 Senor Iguana's v. ISP - ABC - Opinion
- SummaryCancelled liquor license May 3, 2016
43468 Mayer v. TPC Holdings, Inc. - Opinion
- SummarySUBSTITUTE OPINION INDUSTRIAL COMMISSION Survivability of claims for permanent partial disability when a claimant dies for reasons unrealted to the work accident. May 3, 2016
42744 Doble v. Interstate Amusements, Inc. - Opinion
- SummaryAppeal from award of attorney fees. Apr 27, 2016
42163 PHH Mortgage v. Nickerson - Opinion
- SummaryForeclosure Apr 27, 2016
42726 Dennis L. Akers v. Marti Mortensen - Opinion
- SummaryMortensen appeals from the district court's award of attorney's fees. Apr 27, 2016
42707 Loren Wagner v. Russell Wagner; Wanooka Farms - Opinion
- SummaryAppeal from the determintion of fair value of shares in a family owned farming corporation Apr 26, 2016
42782 Roy Green v. Industrial Special Indemnity - Opinion
- SummaryISIF appeals decision assigning responsibility for a portion of disability benefits where a pre-existing condition exists. Apr 26, 2016
42540 Lucia Navo v. Bingham Memorial Hospital - Opinion
- SummaryWrongful death Apr 26, 2016
42063 Sheets v. BofA / Countrywide Home Loans - Opinion
- SummaryDispute over a mistakenly released deed of trust. Apr 26, 2016
43370 Rangen, Inc. v. Dept of Water Resources - Opinion
- SummaryWater rights. Apr 26, 2016
43135 Judith Weible v. Dept of Labor - Opinion
- SummaryINDUSTRIAL COMMISSION Appeal from denial of unemployment benefits during an employment leave of absence. Mar 25, 2016
42333 Mary Pandrea v. Kenneth Barrett - Opinion
- SummaryAppeal from district court decision partitioning property in kind rather than by sale. Mar 24, 2016
43652 H&W v. Jane Doe (2015-21) - Opinion
- SummaryTermination of parental rights Mar 23, 2016
42053 Melene James v. City of Boise - Opinion
- SummarySUBSTITUTE OPINION in Police dog-bite case Mar 23, 2016
42875 Linda Kesting v. James Kesting - Opinion
- SummarySpousal support Mar 23, 2016
42756 Coalition for Agricultures's Future v. Canyon County and Canyon Co Bd of Commissioners - Opinion
- SummaryDeclaratory relief action related to planning and zoning Mar 23, 2016
42775/42836 Idaho Ground Water Appropriators v. Dept of Water Resources (42775) and City of Pocatello v. Rangen, Inc. (42836) - Opinion
- SummarySRBA - Water Rights Mar 23, 2016
43125 Robert Mena, M.D. v. State Bd. of Medicine - Opinion
- SummaryAppeal from the district court's decision upholding action taken by the Board against appellant physician. Mar 23, 2016
42434 Patricia McKay v. Thomas G. Walker - Opinion
- SummaryLegal malpractice action Mar 23, 2016
43058 Wilson v. Conagra Foods Lamb Weston - Opinion
- SummaryINDUSTRIAL COMMISSION Worker's Compensation
Mar 9, 2016
41990 Charles W. Houpt v. Wells Fargo Bank - Opinion
- SummarySUBSTITUTE OPINION -Foreclosure
Mar 4, 2016
42514 Strong and Hawk v. Intermountain Anesthesia - Opinion
- SummaryAppeal from dismissal for failure to prosecute a claim
Mar 4, 2016
42575 Morgan v. New Sweden Irrigation Dist - Opinion
- SummaryAppeal from declaratory judgment
Mar 4, 2016
43004 Lepper v. Eastern Idaho Health Services - Opinion
- SummaryMedical malpractice
Mar 3, 2016
41882 Ryan M. Mitchell v. State of Idaho - Opinion
- SummaryAppeal from order granting summary judgment in favor of the State; victims' rights.
Mar 2, 2016
41887 Jeffrey Edward Huber v. Lightforce USA, Inc. - Opinion
- SummarySUBSTITUTE OPINION. Breach of contract; failure to pay wages.
Mar 1, 2016
43027 Syringa Networks v. Dept of Administration - Opinion
- SummaryAppeals arising from an action challenging the bidding process for the Idaho education Network.
Feb 29, 2016
42772 Rangen, Inc. v. Idaho Dept of Water Resources - Opinion
- SummaryWater rights
Feb 26, 2016
42822 Estate of John H. Cornell v. Toni C. Johnson - Opinion
- SummaryAdministration of a trust
Feb 26, 2016
41604 Kara Alexander v. Vianna Stibal - Opinion
- SummaryFraud, breach of contract
Feb 26, 2016
43501 Stanley Sweet v. Rebecca Foreman Child custody order
Feb 26, 2016
42718 McAdams, LLC v. Peter J. Cintorino Promissory note
Feb 11, 2016
42876 Unifund CCR, LLC v. Lorene K. Lowe Appeal from a judgment for balance owed on credit accounts.
Feb 01, 2016
43165 John Doe v. Shoshone-Bannock Tribes The Tribes challenge the district court's finding that an adopted child was not an "Indian Child" under the Indian Child Welfare Act.
Jan 26, 2016
42684 Fagen v. Rogerson Flats Wind Park Breach of contract
Jan 26, 2016
42592 Fagen v. Lava Beds Wind Park Breach of contract
Jan 25, 2016
42158 Easterling v. Kendall, M.D. Medical malpractice claim
Jan 22, 2016
41897 Robert Humphries v. Eileen Becker Transfer of real property
Jan 22, 2016
42065 Skinner v. U.S. Bank Home Mortgage Appeal from dismissal of claims of negligence Re: insurance funds.
Jan 22, 2016
42873 Clarence L. Copper v. Ace Hardware Unemployment benefits denied
Jan 6, 2016
41993 Liberty Bankers Life Ins. Co. v. Witherspoon, Kelley, etc. Competing security interests in real property
Dec 23, 2015
42191 Roger Carl Gordon v. Shannon Lee Hedrick Establishing paternity
Dec 23, 2015
41514 John Wickel v. David J. Chamberlain, D.O. Mdedical malpractice
Dec 22, 2015
41994 Kelli Sevy v. SVL Analytical, Inc. Failure to meet burden of establishing total and permanent disability
Nov 25, 2015
43233 John Doe I v. John Doe II Appeal from termination of father's parental rights and adoption
Nov 25, 2015
42473 Chadwick v. Multi-State Electric, LLC INDUSTRIAL COMMISSION - Worker's Compensation claim
Nov 25, 2015
42515 Todd Rich v. State of Idaho Appellant seeks a declaratory judgment restoring his right to bear arms.
Nov 20, 2015
43169 Coeur d'Alene Tribe v. Lawerence Denney - Fees
SUBSTITUTE OPINION - The Tribe's Writ of Mandamus Re: Senate Bill 1011.
Nov 2, 2015
42658 Kelly v. Blue Ribbon Linen Supply, Inc. Worker's compensation claim stemming from auto accident Nov 2, 2015
41077 Sherman Storage v. Global Signal Acq Property dispute. October 15, 2015
43074 Greater Boise Auditorium District v. Frazier Petition for Judicial Confirmation Sept 30, 2015
42216 Sky Canyon Properties v. The Golf Club at Black Rock, LLC Appeal from denial of attorney fees and costs on remand Sept 30, 2015
42125 Martin Hayes v. City of Plummer Premises liability claim Sept 25, 2015
41951 Kennedy v. Hagadone Hospitality Co. INDUSTRIAL COMMISSION Sept 25, 2015
42161 Rice v. Sallaz Breach of contract Sept 25, 2015
43152 Jane Doe (2015-03) v. John Doe Termination of parental rights (father) Sept 25, 2015
42018 Idaho Transportation v. Ascorp, Inc. Appeal from award of attorney fees Sept 25, 2015
41113 Burlile v. Bd of Co Commissioners, Payette Appeal from the approval of a conditional rezone Sept 25, 2015
41956 City of Challis v. Consent of the Governed Caucus SUBSTITUTE OPINION The City sought imporvements to their water distribution system incurring a debt without a public vote. Sept 25, 2015
42296 Walco, Inc v. County of Idaho Misappropriation of trade secrets Sept 25, 2015
42237 Fairchild v. Kentucky Fried Chicken INDUSTRIAL COMMISSION Worker's Compensation Sept 25, 2015
42417 Perry Krinitt v. Dept of Fish and Game Wrongful death Sept 4, 2015
42243 St. Alphonsus RMC v. Gooding County Third-party medical indigency. Aug 27, 2015
42189 DOE(s) v. Boy Scouts of America Certification re Questions of Law. (Constructive fraud claims) Aug 24, 2015
42112 Eric Kawamura v. Jessica Kawamura Divorce. Nature of property. Aug 20, 2015
40625 American Bank v. BRN Dev. & Taylor Eng. Foreclosure action and cross-claim asserting negligence. July 23, 2015
42173 Michelle Campbell v. Parkway Surgery Breach of contract. July 23, 2015
41679 State v. Philip Morris, R.J. Reynolds SUBSTITUTE OPINION. State appeals settlement award. (RE: 1998 Tobacco Master Settlement Agreement.) July 22, 2015
41898 Monica Garner v. Christopher Garner Child support. July 17, 2015
42614 Safaris Unlimited v. Mike Von Jones Appeal from grant of summary judgment in favor of Safaris' claims for breach of contract. July 16, 2015
41742 Colafranceschi v. Briley & Robinson Defamation and professional malpractice. July 16, 2015
41451 Stilwyn, Inc. v. Rokan Corporation Claims for relief from failed transaction. July 16, 2015
42384 Jackson Hop v. Farm Bureau Insurance Appeal from ruling that insured was not entitled to prejudgment interest. July 14, 2015
41397-41398 Podsaid v. Outfitters & Guides Licensing Appeals arising from termination of guide license. July 13, 2015
42092 La Bella Vita v. Amanda Shuler Misappropriation of trade secrets. July 7, 2015
42589 Sohar Chavez v. Kevin Stokes INDUSTRIAL COMMISSION. Life Flight costs in work related injury case. June 30, 2015
42372 John Doe v. State Sex Offender Registry Appeal from dismissal of Verified Petition for Declaratory Judgment. June 24, 2015
42821 Termination of Parental Rights of John Doe (2015-01) Termination of father's righs. June 23, 2015
41868 Tracfone Wireless v. State of Idaho RE: Fees June 23, 2015
42165 Judy Charney v. Dennis Charney Appeal from award of attorney fees. June 22, 2015
42192 Virgil Adams v. Kimberley One Townhouse From an amended HOA Declaration restricting renting out a unit. June 22, 2015
41825 Federal National Mortgage v. Hafer Foreclosure. June 22, 2015
42521 Todd L. Hamilton v. Alpha Services, LLC INDUSTRIAL COMMISSION - Worker's compensation, death benefits. June 22, 2015
41972 Pines, D.O. v. State Board of Medicine Appeal from disciplinary order. May 28, 2015
42675 Termination of Parental Rights of John Doe (2014-25) Father's appeal from magistrate judgment terminating parental rights and allowing adoption. May 22, 2015
42175 St. Al's RMC v. Elmore County Appeal from denial of applications for medical indigency May 21, 2015
42093 James Hilliard v. Murphy Land Company Admissibility of affidavits during summary judgment proceedings. May 21, 2015
41178 Christina J. Greenfield v. Eric J. Wurmlinger One neighbor's complaints against another for claims of violations of the CC&R and City Code. May 21, 2015
41615 Gary Holdaway v. Broulim's Supermarket Suit for personal injury April 23, 2015
42700 Dept of H&W v. John Doe (2014-26) RE: Termination of Parental Rights April 23, 2015
42220 Gina Poledna v. Dept of Labor INDUSTRIAL COMMISSION - Denial of Unemployment benefits April 21, 2015
42588 Krissy M. Lamont v. Matthew J. Lamont Expedited permissive appeal - child custody dispute April 7, 2015
41524 Cherri Lynn Nix v. Elmore County Appeal from termination of employment April 1, 2015
41583 Daryl K. and Linda L. Mullinix v. Killgore's Salmon River Fruit Co. Right to use pipeline to convey water April 1, 2015
42141 Hilary Beth Candland Firmage v. Howard Hunter Snow Modification of Child Custody Arrangement March 30, 2015
41286 Dennis Ray Hennefer v. Blaine County School District #61 School District Tort Liability March 5, 2015
41683 Cedillo v. Farmers Insurance Co of Idaho - Opinion
- SummarySUBSTITUTE OPINION: Underinsured motorist March 2, 2015
41265 Big Wood Ranch v. Water Users' Association of the Broadford Slough and Rockwell Bypass Lateral Ditches, Inc. - Opinion
- SummaryCollection of assessments for maintenance Feb 27, 2015
41467 LuAnn Shubert v. Macy's West, Inc. - Opinion
- SummaryINDUSTRIAL COMMISSION Worker's Compensation / Disability Benefits Feb 26, 2015
41668 Jayo Development, Inc. v. Ada County Bd. of Equalization - Opinion
- SummaryProperty tax exemption Feb 26, 2015
42141 Hilary Firmage v. Howard Snow - Opinion
- SummaryModification of child custody Feb 26, 2015
41600 Thomas Arnold v. City of Stanley - Opinion
- SummaryOpen meeting law Feb 26, 2015
41454 Nampa Education Association v. Nampa School District No. 131 - Opinion
- SummaryAn addenda to the teachers' employment contracts were illegal and unenforceable. Feb 26, 2015
41846 Marjorie Ellmaker v. Calvin Tabor - Opinion
- SummaryPromissory note (inherited) Feb 26, 2015
41452 Duane R. Mueller v. Carolyn Hill - Opinion
- SummaryDamages for common law trespass and attorney fees for statutory trespass. Feb 26, 2015
41316 No. Idaho Bldg Contractors Assoc. v. City of Hayden - Opinion
- SummarySewer connection fee Feb 11, 2015
40168 Dept of Transportation v. HJ Grathol - Opinion
- SummaryEminent domain. Appeal from judgment in just compensation from ITD. Feb 10, 2015
41214 917 LUSK, LLC v. City of Boise - Opinion
- SummaryAppeal from City Council's decision granting a conditional use permit Feb 6, 2015
41745 Dalrie Cook v. Hugo Marcelo Arias - Order Order Denying Reconsideration and Vacating Judgment Feb 4, 2015
41501 Alan Golub v. Kirk-Hughes Development - Opinion
- SummaryAppeal from grant of Golub's summary judgment finding their lien had priority Feb 2, 2015
40474 Keith A. Sims v. Dan S. Jacobson - Opinion
- SummaryAppeal from grant of attorney fees Jan 30, 2015
41505 Alan Golub v. Kirk-Scott, LTD - Opinion
- SummaryTwo creditors dispute whose claim against debtor's property has priority Jan 26, 2015
42442 Dept of H&W v. Jane Doe (2014-22) - Opinion
- SummaryRE: Termination of Parental Rights Jan 26, 2015
41338 Mosell Equities, LLC v. Berryhill & Co, Inc - Opinion
- SummaryAppeal from order granting new trial Jan 23, 2015
42529 Dept of H&W v. Jane Doe (2014-23) - Opinion
- SummaryRE: Termination of Parental Rights Jan 23, 2015
41448 Plane Family Trust v. Skinner - Opinion
- SummaryAppeal from decision denying a motion to void a portion of a stipulated judgment Jan 23, 2015
41584 Flying "A" Ranch v. County Commissioners of Fremont County - Opinion
- SummaryAppeal from the district court's determination to vacate the Boards designation of a county road Jan 23, 2015
41991 Thrall v. St. Luke's Regional Med Cntr - Opinion
- SummaryINDUSTRIAL COMMISSION - Unemployment Benefits Jan 23, 2015
41523 Boyd-Davis v. Macomber Law, PLLC - Opinion
- SummaryINDUSTRIAL COMMISSION - Unemployment Benefits Jan 21, 2015
41269 ACI Northwest, Inc. v. Monument Heights, LLC - Opinion
- SummaryForeclosure of mechanic's liens on property encumbered by deeds of trust. Jan 09, 2015
41663 Minnick v. Hawley Troxell Ennis & Hawley, LLP and Geoffrey M. Wardle - Opinion
- SummaryProfessional malpractice Dec 30, 2014
41297 Int'l Real Estate Solutions, Inc. v. Arave - Opinion
- SummaryAppeal from decision to dismiss motion to compel the filing of a satisfaction of judgment Dec 18, 2014
41605 Bill Gailey v. Kim Whiting - Opinion
- SummaryProfessional negligence Dec 18, 2014
41589 Pocatello Hospital v. Quail Ridge Medical Investor - Opinion
- SummaryGround lease Dec 18, 2014
41592 Charles Bell v. IDOL and Sears - Opinion
- SummaryUnemployment benefits Dec 18, 2014
41485 Re: Guardianship: Bond v. Round - Opinion
- SummaryRe: Visitation and attorney fees Dec 18, 2014
40848 Brent Regan v. Jeff Owen - Opinion
- SummaryWhether Owen's deed should be reformed to grant easment Dec 18, 2014
42234 H&W v. John Doe (2014-15) - Opinion
- SummaryTermination of parental rights Dec 15, 2014
42291 H&W v. Jane Doe (2014-17) - Opinion
- SummaryTermination of parental rights Dec 12, 2014
40615 H&W v. Cathie Peterson RE: The Estate of Melvin Peterson (deceased) - Opinion
- SummarySUBSTITUTE OPINION - The Opinion of August 13, 2014 is withdrawn. RE: Medicaid benefits Dec 8, 2014
41277 H.F.L.P., LLC v. City of Twin Falls - Opinion
- SummaryEasment Dec 2, 2014
41013 Stephanie Reed v. Scott Reed - Opinion
- SummaryDivorce Dec 2, 2014
40438 Terri Boyd-Davis v. Timothy Baker - Opinion
- SummaryReal property boundary dispute Nov 28, 2014
41593 Trudy Deon v. H & J, Inc. - Opinion
- SummaryIndustrial Commission - Worker Compensation Nov 28, 2014
41560 Mercedes E. Turner v. City of Lapwai - Opinion
- SummaryUnpaid compensation and reimbursement for expenses during employment Nov 28, 2014
41041 Franklin Building Supply v. Aaron Hymas - Opinion
- SummaryConstruction liability Nov 28, 2014
41469 Newman K. Giles v. Eagle Farms, Inc. - Opinion
- SummaryIndustrial Commission - Income Benefits Nov 25, 2014
40587 Christian Westby, et al v. Schaefer, M.D. - Opinion
- SummaryAppeal from district court's denial of motion to reconsider a protective order Nov 13, 2014
41976 Emily E. Suter v. Jeffrey C. Biggers - Opinion
- SummaryCustody dispute Nov 13, 2014
40514 Stanley Consultants v. Integrated Financial Associates - Opinion
- SummaryThis appeal involves several cases with common claims for nonpayment against a developer Nov 6, 2014
41209 Su Warren v. Williams & Parsons - Opinion
- SummaryIndustrial Commission - Worker's Compensation Oct 29, 2014
41193 Timothy Williams v. Idaho State Board of Real Estate Appraisers - Opinion
- SummaryDisciplinary proceedings for professional misconduct Oct 29, 2014
40762 Gene L. Mattox v. Life Care Centers of America - Opinion
- SummaryMedical Malpractice Oct 29, 2014
41421 Samuel J. Zylstra v. Boise State University - Opinion
- SummaryNegligence Oct 29, 2014
41188 Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corp. v. Margaret A. Butcher - Opinion
- SummaryForeclosure Oct 29, 2014
41252 U.S. Bank National Association N.D. v. Citimortgage, Inc. - Opinion
- SummaryLien priority dispute Oct 29, 2014
41296 Richard J. Braese, Jr. v. Stinker Stores, Inc. - Opinion
- SummaryClaim for injuries Oct 29, 2014
41305 Cable One, Inc. v. Idaho State Tax Commission - Opinion
- SummaryIncome earned by multistate corporation was taxable. Oct 29, 2014
40427 Vianna Stibal v. April Fano - Opinion
- SummaryBreach of Release Agreement Oct 29, 2014
40865 Spirit Ridge Mineral Springs v. Franklin County - Opinion
- SummaryRequest for abatement of a private nuisance and injunction against a gun range Sept 26, 2014
40883 Brad C. Carr v. Crystal (Pridgen) Edgar - Opinion
- SummaryChild custody dispute Sept 24, 2014
40749 Kevin D. Hope v. Industrial Special Indemnity Fund - Opinion
- SummaryWorker's Compensation Sept 19, 2014
41301 Jeremy J. Gugino v. Dennis J. Sallaz - Opinion
- SummaryCollateral attack on divorce decree. Sept 19, 2014
41889 Jay Brown v. Auga Greenheart - Opinion
- SummaryAn action for the reformation of a deed to real property. Sept 19, 2014
41446 Tracy Sales v. Stacie Peabody - Opinion
- SummarySuit against Day Spa claiming infection resulting from pedicure. Sept 19, 2014
41256 Idaho Youth Ranch v. Ada County Bd of Equalization - Opinion
- SummaryDenial of application for property tax exemption. Sept 19, 2014
40887 Scott Bybee v. Patrick D. Gorman, M.D. - Opinion
- SummaryMedical Malpractice claim Sept 19, 2014
40793 Steven B. Cummings v. Roger L. Stephens and Northern Title Co of Idaho - Opinion
- SummaryThis is a cross-appeal from judgments wherein the buyer was denied damages against the seller and awarded judgment against the title company. Aug 28, 2014
40581 Frontier Development Grp v. Caravella - Opinion
- SummaryBreach of residential construction agreement. Aug 25, 2014
41012 Corgatelli v. Steel West, Inc. - Opinion
- SummaryIndustrial Commission - Award of credit for benefits paid Aug 22, 2014
40742 Ryan Conner v. Bryan F. Hodges, M.D. - Opinion
- SummaryMedical malpractice Aug 22, 2014
40970 Serrano v. Four Seasons Framing - Opinion
- SummaryIndustrial Commission - Accident injury
Aug 22, 2014
42020 Termination of Parental Rights (Father) - Opinion
- SummaryFather's Rights Aug 22, 2014
40595-40599 Taylor v. Riley / Taylor v. Cummings - Opinion
- Summary** SECOND ** AMENDED 8/27/14
Permissive appeal out of Ada Co. re: ruling by the district court that two attorneys who signed an opinion letter on behalf of a corporation affirming the validity of a stock redemption agreement could be liable to the person whose stock was redeemed when that redemption was later held unlawful.Aug 21, 2014
40966 MRS v. Bonneville Billing and Collections - Opinion
- SummarySubstitute Opinion. Garnishment Aug 18, 2014
40340 Agrisource, Inc v. Johnson - Opinion
- SummaryBreach of Contract Claim Aug 15, 2014
40375 Camp Easton Forever, Inc v. Inland NW Council Boy Scouts of Amierica - Opinion
- SummaryUnambiguous deed Aug 6, 2014
41306 Gregory Hull v. Richard Giesler - Opinion
- SummaryContract rights Aug 6, 2014
40573 ABC Agra v. Critical Access Group - Opinion
- SummaryReal property use restriction Aug 4, 2014
40974-40975 SRBA: A&B Irrigation v. State of Idaho - Opinion
- SummaryStorage Water Rights Aug 4, 2014
40012 St. Als v. MRI Associates - Opinion
- SummarySubstitute Opinion - Breach of Contract Aug 4, 2014
40232 Billy J. Bringman v. New Albertsons, Inc. - Opinion
- SummaryUnemployment benefits Aug 1, 2014
41688 Health & Welfare v. John Doe (13-29) - Opinion
- SummaryParental Rights Aug 1, 2014
41023 J&M Cattle Co v. Farmers National Bank - Opinion
- SummarySecurity interest in agister's lien Aug 1, 2014
38793 Mark Van v. Portneuf Medical Center - Opinion
- SummaryWhistleblower Act Aug 1, 2014
40566 Pocatello Hospital v. Quail Ridge Medical Investor - Opinion
- SummaryGround Lease Aug 1, 2014
41234 Chance Lebow v. Commercial Tire - Opinion
- SummaryIndustrial Commission - Unemployment Benefits July 31, 2014
41100 Lynn Urrutia v. Ty (Cliff) Harrison - Opinion
- SummaryForeclosure; Attorney Fees July 31, 2014
40738 DAFCO v. Stewart Title Guaranty Co - Opinion
- SummaryDeed of Trust July 31, 2014
40992 NW Farm Credit Svcs v. Lake Cascade Airpark - Opinion
- SummaryDeficiency Judgment July 8, 2014
39964 Profits Plus Capital Mgmt. v. Jeffrey Podesta and Street Search - Opinion
- SummaryBreach of Contract June 24, 2014
40563 Irina N. Shea v. Kevic Corporation - Opinion
- SummaryJune 24, 2014 41681 Re: Termination of Parental Rights (Father) - Opinion
- SummaryJune 20, 2014 41208 Talbot v. Desert View Care Center - Opinion
- SummaryJune 18, 2014 40212 April Beguesse, Inc. v. Kenneth Rammell - Opinion
- SummaryJune 18, 2014 40124 Wandering Trails v. Big Bite Excavation - Opinion
- SummaryJune 17, 2014 39909 Idaho Military HS v. Holbrook Baslen - Opinion
- SummaryJune 17, 2014 40436 Shinn v. Bd. of Co. Comm. Clearwater Co. - Opinion
- SummaryJune 17, 2014 39685 John Block v. City of Lewiston - Opinion
- SummaryJune 17, 2014 40504 Karrin Massey v. Conagra Foods - Opinion
- SummaryJune 17, 2014 40939 Tina Venable v. Internet Auto - Opinion
- SummaryJune 17, 2014 40368 Joseph Pierce v. Steve McMullen - Opinion
- SummaryJune 17, 2014 40882 Idaho Power v. New Energy Two & IPUC - Opinion
- SummaryJune 17, 2014 40559 Muchow v. Varsity Contractors, Inc. - Opinion
- SummaryJune 17, 2014 40987 & 41132 Karl H. Lewies v. Fremont County - Opinion
- SummaryJune 17, 2014 41157 Bank of Idaho v. First American Title - Opinion
- SummaryApr 8, 2014 40672 Terrie H. Rowley - Opinion
- SummaryApr 7, 2014 40013 Sanders v. Bd. of Trustees - Mt. Home School Dist. 193 - Opinion
- SummaryMar 27, 2014 39774 Janice Blizzard v. Lundeby, M.D. - Opinion
- SummaryMar 19, 2014 40234 Credit Suisse v. Teufel Nursery - Opinion
- SummaryMar 19, 2014 40170 Marvin F. Morgan v. Michael A. Demos, M.D. - Opinion
- SummaryMar 19, 2014 40463 Edged In Stone v. NW Power Systems - Opinion
- SummaryMar 19, 2014 40578 Marco Fonseca v. Corral Ag., Inc. - Opinion
- SummaryMar 19, 2014 40827 MRS v. Strawn; Lewis and Knight - Opinion
- SummaryMar 18, 2014 41213 Re: Termination of Parental Rights (Mother) - Opinion
- SummaryMar 18, 2014 40142 Jamee Lee Wade v. Bryan F. Taylor - Opinion
- SummaryMar 18, 2014 41017-2013 Debra Peterson v. Dept of H&W - Child Support - Opinion
- SummaryMar 18, 2014 39556-2012 William J. Waters v. All Phase Const. - Opinion
- SummaryMar 18, 2014 40262 Karen White v. Valley County - Opinion
- SummaryMar 13, 2014 39624 Morgan v. New Sweden Irrigation - Opinion
- SummaryFeb 20, 2014 38705 McVicars v. Christensen - Opinion
- SummaryFeb 18, 2014 38823-2011 Judy Nield v. Pocatello Health Services - Opinion
- SummaryFeb 11, 2014 40462 Western Home Transport v. Dept. of Labor - Opinion
- SummaryFeb 11, 2014 40809 Clearwater REI v. Mark Boling - Opinion
- SummaryFeb 11, 2014 40516 Cuevas v. Barraza - Opinion
- SummaryFeb 10, 2014 39991 Mulford v. Union Pacific Railroad - Opinion
- SummaryFeb 10, 2014 40369 State v. John Doe (2012-10) - Opinion
- SummaryFeb 10, 2014 40002 CUMIS Insurance v. Wade Massey - Opinion
- SummaryFeb 10, 2014 41463 In the Matter of Adoption - Opinion
- SummaryFeb 10, 2014 40502 Teurlings v. Larson - Opinion
- SummaryFeb 7, 2014 39708 Guzman v. Piercy / Canyon Couny / Sutton - Opinion
- SummaryFeb 7, 2014 39160 Johnson v. Highway 101 Investments, LLC - Opinion
- SummaryFeb 7, 2014 39757 Melaleuca, Inc. v. Foeller - Opinion
- SummaryFeb 7, 2014 40084/ 40106 Ada County v. Garden City / Meridian - Opinion
- SummaryFeb 7, 2014 40660 Michael Vawter v. UPS, Inc. - Opinion
- SummaryFeb 7, 2014 39493 Dennis Akers v. D.L. White - Opinion
- SummaryFeb 7, 2014 39182 Dennis Akers v. Marti Mortensen - Opinion
- SummaryFeb 7, 2014 41233 RE: Termination of Parental Rights - Opinion
- SummaryJan 24, 2014 40101 Farmers Nat'l. Bank v. Green River Dairy - Opinion
- SummaryJan 3, 2014 40568 Verdene Page v. McCain Foods, Inc. - Opinion
- SummaryDec 30, 2013 39650 Campbell v. Kvamme - Opinion
- SummaryDec 20, 2013 40230 American West Ent. v. CNH, LLC - Opinion
- SummaryDec 18, 2013 39975 Rita Turner v. Robert Turner - Opinion
- SummaryDec 18, 2013 40344-2012 Rule Steel Tanks, Inc. v. Dept. of Labor - Opinion
- SummaryDec 18, 2013 41387-2013 Jane Doe (13-23) v. John Doe - Opinion
- SummaryDec 18, 2013 40512-2012 Gregory Renshaw v. MERS - Opinion
- SummaryDec 18, 2013 39151-2011 Idaho Power v. Grouse Creek - Opinion
- SummaryPress Release Dec 17, 2013 38191/ 38192/ 38193 A&B Irrigation v.
ID Dept. of Water Resources- Opinion
- SummaryDec 17, 2013 39942 Bremer v. E. Greenacres Irrig. Dist. - Opinion
- SummaryDec 13, 2013 39788 John M. Hoch v. Robb Vance - Opinion
- SummaryDec 11, 2013 39319 Beers v. President -
Church of Jesus Christ of LDS- Opinion
- SummaryDec 6, 2013 39346 Robby Mowrey v. Chevron Pipeline Co. - Opinion
- SummaryDec 4, 2013 39690 BV Beverage Company v. Idaho ABC - Opinion
- SummaryNov 27, 2013 39409 Silicon Int'l. v. Monsanto Co. - Opinion
- SummaryNov 27, 2013 40087 Geff Stringer v. William Robinson - Opinion
- SummaryNov 27, 2013 39945 Frogley v. Meridian Joint School Dist. 2 - Opinion
- SummaryNov 27, 2013 39822 Jeffry Black v. Idaho State Police - Opinion
- SummaryNov 27, 2013 40393 Dallas Clark v.
Shari's Management Corp- Opinion
- SummaryNov 26, 2013 39364 Trevor Taft v. Jumbo Foods, Inc., - Opinion
- SummaryNov 26, 2013 40061 Norman Riley v.
Spiral Butte Development, LLC- Opinion
- SummaryNov 26, 2013 39957 Liberty Northwest Ins. Co., v.
Spudnick Equip. Co.- Opinion
- SummaryNov 26, 2013 39033/ 39034 / 39035/ 39036 State v. Keithly - Opinion
- SummaryNov 26, 2013 39077/ 39078/ 39079 Christopher Hopper v.
Joseph and Bette Hopper- Opinion
- SummaryNov 26, 2013 41149 John Doe v. Jame Doe (2013-14) - Opinion
- SummaryNov 26, 2014 39831 Sky Canyon Properties v.
The Golf Club at Black Rock- Opinion
- SummaryNov 26, 2013 39445-2011 Robert Siegwarth v.
Opportunity Management Co.- Opinion
- SummaryNov 26, 2013 39878-2012 Holli Telfore v. Smith County - Opinion
- Summary
- *Video Archives are posted if and when available. For best results, use Internet Explorer.
-
-