Idaho Supreme Court Criminal Opinions

Idaho Supreme Court opinions are made available online as a public service. All opinions are posted the day of their release. West Publishing Company publishes all cited opinions in the Pacific Reporter and Idaho Reports volumes. The Summary constitutes no part of the opinion of the Court, but has been prepared by court staff for the convenience of the public.

NOTICE: These opinions are subject to formal revision before publication in the preliminary print of the Pacific Reporter. Readers are requested to notify the Clerk of the Court/Reporter of Decisions, Supreme Court of Idaho, Boise, Idaho, 83720-0101, of any typographical or other formal errors, in order that corrections may be made before the preliminary print goes to press.

Release Date	Docket#	Case Name	Opinion Summary Video*	Notes
October 1, 2025	52335	State v. Buck	Opinion Summary	First-Degree Murder; Batson Challenge; Proof of Discriminatory Impact; Disparate Questioning; Alternate Perpetrator Evidence; Alibi; Closing Argument; Cumulative Error
Sept. 4, 2025	50540	Row v. State	Opinion Summary	Successive Petition for Post-Conviction Relief; Ineffective Assistance of Post-Conviction Counsel; I.C. § 19-2717; Shinn v. Ramirez, 596 U.S. 366 (2022)
August 27, 2025	52035	State v. McGuire	Opinion Summary	Resisting and Obstructing a Law Enforcement Officer; I.C. § 18-705; Battery on a Law Enforcement Officer; I.C. § 18-915(3)(b); "Duty"; Prosecutorial Misconduct
August 20, 2025	50950	State v. Frias	Opinion Summary	Firing Timber or Prairie Lands; Carelessness; Proximate Cause; I.C. § 18-7004
August 18, 2025	52468	Smith v. State	Opinion Summary	Post-Conviction; Abandonment by Counsel; Motion to Amend; Motion for an Extension of Time; Idaho Rule of Civil Procedure 60(b)(6)
August 11, 2025	50841	State v. Adams	Opinion Summary	Idaho Code § 66-329; Fourth Amendment; Motion to Suppress; Community Caretaking Function
July 17, 2025	50700	State v. Ewing	Opinion Summary	Franks Hearing; Confrontation Clause; Fundamental Error
July 17, 2025	50452	State v. Ewing	Opinion Summary	Speedy Trial Rights; Confrontation Clause; Compilation Video; Cumulative Error Doctrine
July 14, 2025	52108	State v. Moore	Opinion	Per Curiam Opinion
July 14, 2025	52104	Bell v. State	Opinion Summary	Post-Conviction Relief; I.C. § 19-4906(b); Amended Petition; IssuePreservation; Ineffective Assistance of Counsel
July 1, 2025	50737	State v. Crist	Opinion Summary	Sexual Offender Registration; Duty to Register; Substantially Equivalent Crime
June 30, 2025	49785	State v. Sherwood	Opinion Summary	Fictitious License Plate; I.C. § 49-456; Speedy Trial; I.C. § 19-3501
June 27, 2025	51578	State v. Gonzales	Opinion	Possession of Controlled Substance; Motion to Suppress; Lacked Standing
June 27, 2025	51783	State v. Popp	Opinion Summary	Motion to Suppress; Reasonable Suspicion; Littering; Privately Owned Parking Lot
June 27, 2025	50707	State v. Fletcher	Opinion Summary	Motion to Suppress; Article 1; § 17; Drug Dog Sniffs; Automobile Exception
June 26, 2025	52221	State v. Best	Opinion Summary	Warrantless Search; Issue Preservation; Closing Argument; I.C.R. 16; Harmless Error
May 27, 2025	52062	State v. Rose	Opinion Summary	Probation Revocation; Idaho Criminal Rule 33(f); Willful Violation; Treatment Courts; Notice
May 20, 2025	49909	State v. Smith	Opinion Substitute Summary	Motion to Suppress; Fourth Amendment; Stalking; Idaho Code section 18-7906; Community Caretaker Function; Inventory Search
April 17, 2025	51654	State v. Ruiz	Opinion Summary	Relinquishment of Jurisdiction; Exercise of Reason
April 1, 2025	50333/50715	State v. Bundy	Opinion Summary	Criminal Trespass; Resisting and Obstructing; Statutory Interpretation; Vague as Applied; Overbroad as Applied; Separation of Powers; Unbridled Discretion
March 4, 2025	49945	State v. Radue	Opinion Summary	Insanity Defense; 404(b) Evidence; Expert Testimony; Coerced Confession; Peremptory Challenges
February 27, 2025	50705	State v. Webb	Opinion Summary	Charge Entrapment; Sentencing Entrapment
February 27, 2025	51402	State v. Eaton	Opinion Substitute Summary	Retroactive Application of Statute; Ameliorative Sentencing Amendment; Legislative Intent; Illegal Sentence
February 26, 2025	51527	State v. Grewell	Opinion	Per Curiam Opinion
February 26, 2025	50675	State v. Alvarez	Opinion	Per Curiam Opinion
February 25, 2025	50239	State v. Marble	Opinion Summary	Frequenting; I.C. § 37-2732(d); Moving Vehicle; Void for Vagueness; Idaho Criminal Rules 12(b), 47, and 48
February 21, 2025	52260	State v. Regan	Opinion Summary	Fundamental Error; Jury Instruction; Harmless Error; Conspiracy
February 14, 2025	51530	State v. Hoover	Opinion Summary	I.C. § 18-918(5); sentencing enhancement; domestic battery; domestic assault
February 6, 2025	50087	State v. Von Ehlinger	Opinion Summary	Fundamental Error; State v. Perry; Tactical Decisions; Confrontation Clause; Sixth Amendment; Leading Question; Harmless Error; Sufficiency of the Evidence
January 8, 2025	50127	State v. Ortiz	Opinion Summary	Fourth Amendment Standing; Exigent Circumstances; No Contact Order; Stare Decisis
Dec. 19, 2024	52330	State v. Dills	Opinion	Amended PSI
Dec. 19, 2024	48486/48511/49440/ 49441/49442/49443/ 49444/49445/49446	State v. Roberts	Opinion Summary	I.C.R. 35(a); Post-Conviction Procedure Act; I.C. § 19-4901(a)(1)
Dec. 6, 2024	49435	State v. Al Muthafar	Opinion Substitute Summary	Hearsay; Statements made for Medical Diagnosis and Treatment; Foundational Requirements of I.R.E. 803(4); Motion to Dismiss the Information; Harmless Error
Dec. 5, 2024	51842/52307	State v. Blazek / State v. Smith	Opinion	Decision on Order to Show Cause
Dec. 4, 2024	49953	State v. Chavez	Opinion Summary	Sixth Amendment; Deliberately Elicited Incriminating Statements; Jailhouse Informant; Excessive Sentence; Acquitted Conduct; Post-Verdict Contact With Jurors; Prosecutorial Misconduct
Nov. 29, 2024	49710	State v. Pulizzi	Opinion Summary	Motion to Suppress; Article I, Section 17; Municipal Ordinance; Reasonable Expectation of Privacy; Trash Searches
Nov. 27, 2024	52373	Creech v. Randy Valley	Opinion Summary	Habeas Corpus; Eighth Amendment; Cruel and unusual punishment; Method of execution
Nov 26, 2024	49742	State v. Mansfield	Opinion Summary	I.C. § 19-3501; Speedy Trial
Nov 26, 2024	50513	State v. Rodriguez	Opinion Summary	Riot; I.C. § 18-6401; "disturbing the public peace"; "acting together"
Nov 7, 2024	51269	State v. Wilde	Opinion Summary	Restitution; Idaho Code section 37-2732(k); Appellant Waiver
Nov 5, 2024	52327	Creech v. State	Opinion Summary	Cruel and unusual, double jeopardy, failed execution attempt, second attempted execution
Nov 4, 2024	49848	State v. Soliz	Opinion Summary	Idaho Code section 37-2739C(2); Overdose Immunity; As A Result Of; Sole Cause
August 7, 2024	49919	State v. Martin	Opinion Summary	"Specific Instances of Sexual Behavior"; Impeachment; I.R.E. 412(b) and (c)
August 2, 2024	50130	State v. Karst	Opinion Summary	Invalidated Conviction; Fees; Subject Matter Jurisdiction; Personal Jurisdiction; Due Process
July 15, 2024	51046	Araiza v. State	Opinion Summary	Petition for Post-Conviction Relief; I.R.C.P. 60(b)
July 3, 2024	50971	Hollis v. State	Opinion Summary	Post-Conviction Relief I.R.C.P. 11.3; Motion to Withdraw; Motion to Continue; Abuse of Discretion.
July 1, 2024	49921	State v. Bujak	Opinion Summary	Credit for time served; Idaho Criminal Rule 35(c); I.C. § 19-2603; I.C. § 19-2601.
June 28, 2024	49412	State v. Ish	Opinion Summary	Speedy trial; reattachment of speedy trial right on retrial; prejudicial delay; change of venue; challenging a juror for cause; sentencing upon second conviction; I.C.R. 35.
June 27, 2024	49269	State v. Campbell	Opinion Summary	PETITION FOR REHEARING GRANTED - Fourth Amendment; motion to suppress; de facto arrest; officer safety; inevitable discovery.
June 20, 2024	49930	State v. Shackelford	Opinion Summary	I.C.R. 36; I.C.R. 35(a); Sentencing; Judgment; Correction
June 6, 2024	50538	State v. Goullette	Opinion Summary	Alford Plea; Knowing, Voluntary, and Intelligent Plea
June 6, 2024	49376	State v. Barr	Opinion Summary	I.C. § 19-2520G(3); Idaho Constitution Article V, section 13; Separation of Powers; Consecutive Sentence
May 30, 2024	50927	State v. Hawking	Opinion Summary	Restitution; Crime Victims; Idaho Code section 19-5304
May 21, 2024	49786	Marsalis v. State	Opinion Summary	Post-Conviction Relief; Ineffective Assistance of Counsel; Strickland Prejudice; Interstate Agreement on Detainers; Speedy Trial Right
May 1, 2024	50701	State v. Buehler	Opinion Summary	I.C. § 18-8006; Aggravated DUI; Intervening and Superseding Cause; BAC Evidence
April 3, 2024	50765	State v. Rose	Opinion Summary	Idaho Criminal Rule 35(b); Idaho Criminal Rule 38(b)(1); Idaho Criminal Rule 45; Subject Matter Jurisdiction
April 1, 2024	48808	State v. Van Zanten	Opinion Summary	Traffic stop; reasonable suspicion; commercial vehicle
Feb 29, 2024	50026	State v. Johnson	Opinion Summary	Idaho Rule of Evidence 608(b); Idaho Rule of Evidence 403; Theft Conviction; Character for Truthfulness
Feb 9, 2024	51229	Creech v. State	Opinion Summary	Sua Sponte Dismissal of Successive Petition For Post-Conviction Relief; Idaho Code section 19-2719; Evolving Standards of Decency
Feb 9, 2024	50336	Creech v. State	Opinion Summary	Shinn v. Ramirez, 596 U.S. 366 (2022); Triggering Event; Successive Petition for Post-Conviction Relief; Ineffective Assistance of Post-Conviction Counsel
Feb 8, 2024	49079	State v. Green	Opinion Summary	Cell Phone Data Extraction; Sixth Amendment's Confrontation Clause; Authentication; I.R.E. 901(b) (testimony of a witness with knowledge "that an item is what it is claimed to be")
Feb 8, 2024	50523	State v. Parsons	Opinion Summary	Sixth Amendment; Confrontation Clause; Testimonial Statements; Forensic Interviews; Primary Purpose Test
January 31, 2024	49266	State v. Rodriguez	Opinion Summary	Sleeping or Inattentive Juror; Juror Misconduct; Motion for a New Trial; I.C.R. 34; I.C. § 19-2406(3)
Dec 20, 2023	48949	State v. Rambo	Opinion Summary	Relevancy; Expert Opinion Testimony; Lay Opinion Testimony; Idaho Rule of Evidence 103; Idaho Rule of Evidence 401; Idaho Rule of Evidence 403; Idaho Rule of Evidence 602; Idaho Rule of Evidence 701; Idaho Rule of Evidence 702; Harmless Error
Dec 19, 2023	49492	State v. Thompson	Opinion Summary	No Contact Order; Abuse of Discretion; Domestic Violence
Dec 6, 2023	48939	State v. Augerlavoie	Opinion Summary	Idaho Rule of Evidence 605; Judicial Testimony; Fundamental Error
Dec 5, 2023	48677	Abdullah v. State	Opinion Summary	Post-Conviction relief in Capital Case; Statute of Limitations; I.C. § 19-2719 ("known or reasonably should be known"); Brady material; material or prejudicial impeachment information; verdict worthy of confidence.
Dec 5, 2023	49207	State v. Kimbley, III	Opinion Summary	Fundamental Error; Issue Preservation; Right to a Public Trial; Evidence of Flight; Prosecutorial Misconduct; I.R.E. 403.
Nov 17, 2023	49358	State v. Oldenburg	Opinion Summary	Sealing Court Records; I.C. § 67-3004(10); I.C.A.R. 32
Nov 9, 2023	48839	State v. Harrell	Opinion Summary	Right to Jury Trial; Peremptory Challenges; COVID-19 Pandemic; Idaho Const. Article I, §§ 7, 13; U.S. Constitution Fourteenth Amendment Due Process.
October 27, 2023	48846	Hooley v. State	Opinion Substitute Summary	Post-Conviction; Summary Dismissal; Actual Innocence; Time-Barred; Brady Material.
October 4, 2023	49255	State v. Monroe	Opinion Summary	Lesser Included Offense Instructions; Reasonable View of the Evidence; I.C. § 19-2132(b); Battery on an Officer; I.C. § 18-915(3); Resisting or Obstructing an Officer
Sept 29, 2023	50470	State v. Ramos	Opinion Summary	Motion to Suppress; Fourth Amendment; Impoundment; Inventory Search
Sept 20, 2023	50078	State v. Pendleton	Opinion Summary	Challenges to Drug Dog's Reliability; Discovery of Drug Dog's History; I.C.R. 16(b)(4); Unduly Burdensome Discovery Request; Scope of Prosecutor's "Possession, Custody, or Control."
Sept 11, 2023	50430	Bracali-Gambino v. State	Opinion Summary	Post-Conviction Relief; Major Contraband; Ineffective Assistance of Counsel; Persistent Violator
Sept 5, 2023	49619	State v. John Doe	Opinion Summary	Interlocutory Appeal; Juvenile Corrections Act; I.C. § 20-528; Statutory Interpretation
August 30, 2023	49029	State v. Head	Opinion Summary	Restitution; Civil Process; Exculpatory Evidence; Due Process
August 18, 2023	48825	State v. Wilson	Opinion Substitute Summary	Persistent Violator Enhancement; Unlawful Possession of a Firearm; Judicial Notice; Foreign Statute; Idaho Code section 18-3316; Prior Conviction
August 15, 2023	49099	State v. Bell	Opinion Summary	Warrantless Arrest of Completed Misdemeanor; Collective Knowledge Doctrine; State v. Clarke, 165 Idaho 393, 446 P.3d 451 (2019)
July 20, 2023	49241	State v. Miller	Opinion Summary	Fundamental Error; Sentencing Enhancement; Sufficiency of the Evidence; Trial Error.
July 12, 2023	47522	State v. Lankford	Opinion Summary	Late Disclosure of Evidence; Law of the Case Doctrine; Speedy Trial.
June 28, 2023	49305	Bahr v. State	Opinion Summary	Post-conviction relief; statute of limitations; I.C. § 19-4902(a); equitable tolling; lack-of-access to Idaho courts; reasonable diligence
June 22, 2023	47871	Hall v. State	Opinion Substitute Summary	Ineffective Assistance of Appellate Counsel; Post-Conviction Relief; Death Sentence.
June 7, 2023	48985	State v. Anderson	Opinion Summary	Fatal Variance; Issue Preservation; Included Offense;Sentencing Discretion.
May 2, 2023	48522	State v. Ingraham	Opinion Summary	I.C. § 19-2604; I.C. § 19-2514; Persistent violator enhancement; Sentencing enhancement; COVID 19 precautions; Presentation of evidence; Failure to raise an issue; Voir Dire; Amendment of judgment.
April 24, 2023	50482	Associated Press v. Second Judicial District	Opinion Summary	Original Jurisdiction; Media Standing to Challenge "gag" Orders; Prerequisites for Extraordinary Relief; Writs of Mandamus and Prohibition.
April 19, 2023	49095	State v. Jane Doe (2021-38)	Opinion Summary	Battery; Self-Defense; I.C. § 19-202A; I.C.J.I. 1517 and 1518; Juvenile Corrections Act
March 24, 2023	49210	State v. Pool	Opinion Summary	Terms of Probation; Consent Exception to the Warrant Requirement; Idaho Const. Article 1, § 17; Fourth Amendment; Waiver; Motion to Suppress.
March 21, 2023	48920	State v. Plata Iniguez	Opinion Summary	Warrantless arrest of a completed misdemeanor; State v. Clarke, 165 Idaho 393, 446 P.3d 451 (2019); Exclusionary Rule; Causal Nexus; Reasonable "mistake of law" Exception.
March 21, 2023	49958	State v. Ogden	Opinion Summary	Invited Error Doctrine; Excited Utterance; Completeness Doctring; Relevancy; PSI; Redline.
March 20, 2023	48119	State v. Dorff	Opinion Summary	Drug dog sniff; Fourth Amendment; Common law trespass to chattel; Exterior of Vehicle; Intermeddling; State v. Howard, 169 Idaho 496 P.3d 865 (2021); State v. Randall, 169 Idaho 358, 496 P.3d 844 (2021); United States v. Jones, 565 U.S. 400 (2012).
March 10, 2023	49980	State v. Leavitt	Opinion Summary	I.R.E. 404(b); Notice; "Good Cause Shown"; Propensity Evidence; I.R.E. 403; Harmless Error
March 7, 2023	49270	State v. Maahs	Opinion Summary	Motion to Suppress; De Facto Arrest; Investigatory Detention; Exclusionary Rule.
March 1, 2023	49122	State v. Singh	Opinion Summary	Idaho Criminal Rule 5.2(c); Idaho Criminal Rule 54(i); Idaho Court Administrative Rule 25(g); Inherent authority of trial court.
February 13, 2023	49161	Hernandez v. State	Opinion Summary	Petition for Post-Conviction; Rebuttable Presumption; Sworn Statement
February 10, 2023	49703	Rodriquez v. State	Opinion Summary	Petition for post-conviction; Summary dismissal; Mailbox Rule; Idaho Rule of Civil Procedure 2.2
February 8, 2023	49565	State v. Roman-Lopez	Opinion Summary	Hearsay standard of review; Hearsay and implied assertions; Harmless error; Hearsay and out-of-court drawings; Redlining the presentence investigation report.
February 8, 2023	48758	State v. Marsh	Opinion Summary	Fourth Amendment; Informant's Tip; Known Informants; Reasonable Suspicion; Investigatory Detention; Motion to Suppress.
February 8, 2023	49037	State v. Cuenca	Opinion Summary	Covid-19 pandemic; Medical mask order; Confrontation Clause; Sixth Amendment; Maryland v. Craig, 497 U.S. 836 (1990).
February 1, 2023	49840	State v. Greer	Opinion Summary	Presentence investigation report; Redline; Record sufficiency; Charge dismissal; Sentence.
January 30, 2023	49886	Stark v. State	Opinion Summary	Petition for Post-Conviction; Ineffective Assistance of Counsel; Standing
Dec. 9, 2022	49573	State v. Adams	Opinion Summary	Restitution; Petit Theft; Grand Theft; Statutory Interpretation
Dec. 7, 2022	49128	Schiermeier v. State	Opinion Summary	Post-Conviction; Ultra Vires; Ineffective Assistance of Counsel; Professional Conduct
Nov. 2, 2022	48301 & 48302	State v. Ogden	Opinion Summary	I.R.E. 412(b); I.R.E. 403; PSI Requirements
Nov. 2, 2022	48138	State v. Adkins	Opinion Summary	Felony Concealment of Evidence; I.C. § 18-2603; Apprendi v. New Jersey, 530 U.S. 466 (2002); Adjudicative Fact; Legal Fact
Nov. 1, 2022	48633	State v. Lancaster	Opinion Summary	I.C. § 19-608; Idaho Const. art. I, § 17; Notice Requirements for Arrest; State v. Sutterfield; Correcting Information in PSI
October 4, 2022	49271	State v. Vivian	Opinion Summary	Motion to Suppress; Adverse Ruling; Issue Preservation; Exclusionary Rule; Inevitable Discovery Exception
September 19, 2022	49460	State v. Miramontes	Opinion Summary	Preservation; Fourth Amendmend; search and seizure
September 9, 2022	45832/45833/45834/45835	State v. Fox	Opinion Summary	I.C.R. 8(a); joinder of charges; I.C.R. 14; severance of charges; I.R.E. 404(b); excited utterance exception; prosecutorial misconduct; harmless error; cumulative error doctrine; I.C.R. 35
September 2, 2022	49461	State v. Smith	Opinion Summary	I.R.E. 401 (relevancy); motive; harmless error; mistrial; re-opening a case; abuse of discretion; I.R.E. 701 (lay opinion testimony); I.R.E. 702 (expert opinion testimony); I.C. § 19-5304 (restitution for crime victims)
August 31, 2022	48817	State v. Moore	Opinion Summary	Miranda; 5th and 6th Amendments; invoked right to counsel; coerced and involuntary confessions; preliminary hearing; I.C. § 19-815A
August 30, 2022	47179	Dunlap v. State	Opinion Substitute Summary	Post-conviction; Brady; Napue; Strickland; ineffective assistance of counsel
August 25, 2022	48782	State v. Garcia	Opinion Summary	I.C. § 19-5304 ("Restitution for Crime Victims"); foreseeable ability to pay
August 23, 2022	49489/49531	State v. Pizzuto	Opinion Summary	Idaho Commission of Pardons and Parole; commutation power; gubernatorial review; Idaho Const. art. IV, § 7; I.C. § 20-1016
August 23, 2022	48470	State v. Weaver	Opinion Summary	Hearsay; then-existing state of mind exception; I.R.E. 803(3)
August 12, 2022	48860	State v. Hall	Opinion Summary	Authority to Amend No Contact Order
August 11, 2022	48357	State v. Blancas	Opinion Summary	Exigent circumstances exception to the warrant requirement; DUI; warrantless blood draw; unavailability of magistrate judge
July 19, 2022	48295	State v. Hollist	Opinion Summary	Motion to suppress; community caretaking function; unlawful seizure; reasonable suspicion; attenuation doctrine
June 29, 2022	47981	State v. Huntley	Opinion Summary	Paid confidential informant; investigatory stop; reasonable suspicion; extension of stop
June 10, 2022	49087	State v. Riley	Opinion Summary	Traffic stop deviations; Fourth Amendment; motion to suppress
June 2, 2022	48338	Savage v. State	Opinion Summary	Post-Conviction Petition; ineffective assistance of counsel; prejudice
May 26, 2022	48423	Jimenez v. State	Opinion Summary	Appointment of post-conviction counsel; I.C. § 19-4904; limited scope representation; hybrid representation
May 23, 2022	48631	State v. Wharton	Opinion Summary	Traffic stop; passengers; warrants check; Fourth Amendment balancing test; bright line rule
May 20, 2022	47698	State v. Clapp	Opinion Substitute Summary	Confrontation clause; telephonic testimony; harmless error
May 16, 2022	47987/48426	State v. Campbell	Opinion Summary	Ambiguous sentence; Idaho Criminal Rule 35; Brady material; Eighth Amendment; youth as a consideration at sentencing
May 11, 2022	48593	State v. Karst	Opinion Summary	Fourth Amendment; extension of a traffic stop; drug dog; no de minimis exception; abandonment; and overruling State v. Still, 166 Idaho 351, 458 P.3d 220 (Ct. App. 2019)
May 3, 2022	48027	State v. Olsen	Opinion Summary	I.C. § 19-2601; withheld judgment; conviction; judgement of conviction
April 29, 2022	48561	State v. Stonecypher	Opinion Summary	Reasonable suspicion; totality of the circumstances
April 28, 2022	48174	State v. Temple	Opinion Summary	Issue preservation; harmless error; jury instructions
April 6, 2022	47667	State v. Diaz	Opinion Summary	Expert testimony; mental condition; aggravated battery; mistake of fact
April 4, 2022	48963	State v. Ross	Opinion Summary	Probation violation; petit theft; injury to a child; Idaho Code § 18-1501(5)
March 17, 2022	48748	State v. Tower	Opinion Summary	Motion to suppress; reasonable suspicion; failure to preserve
March 16, 2022	48536	State v. Poe	Opinion Summary	Criminal restitution; standing; victims' rights
March 2, 2022	48723	State v. Ochoa	Opinion Summary	Vehicular manslaughter; significant cause; I.R.E. 401 and 403; motion to continue; prejudice; I.R.E. 703
March 1, 2022	47642	State v. McDermott	Opinion Summary	Jury instructions; malice; initial aggressor; harmless error
February 4, 2022	48068/48069	State v. Casper	Opinion Summary	Sentencing; restitution; mistrial; I.C. § 37-2732(k)
February 3, 2022	48628	State v. Reyes	Opinion Substitute Summary	Cumulative error; IRE 804(a); unavailability; prosecutorial misconduct
February 3, 2022	48899	State v. Towner	Opinion Summary	I.C. § 66-326(1); community caretaker function
February 3, 2022	47847	State v. Hutton	Opinion Summary	Fourth Amendment; search warrant; nighttime service; informants; motion to suppress
January 6, 2022	48305	State v. Brown	Opinion Amended Summary	Idaho Criminal Rule 35(b); subject matter jurisdiction; procedural rules; abuse of discretion
January 4, 2022	46803	State v. Paulson	Opinion Summary	Vehicular manslaughter; jury instructions; significant cause; intervening; superseding cause
December 20, 2021	48726	State v. McGrath	Opinion Summary	Lewd conduct with a minor; Idaho Rule of Evidence 404(b); motive; Idaho Rule of Evidence 403; excessive sentence
October 26, 2021	47109	State v. Spencer	Opinion Summary	Confidential informant; confrontation clause; testimonial
October 26, 2021	48193	State v. Guerra	Opinion Summary	DUI; I.C.R. 29(c)(1); I.R.C. 34(a); Blood Draw; Hearsay
October 5, 2021	47367	State v. Howard	Opinion Summary	Motion to suppress; drug sniff of an automobile; trespass by drug-detection dog; probable cause; Fourth Amendment standing; issue preservation
October 5, 2021	48692	State v. Randall	Opinion Summary	Motion to suppress; reasonable suspicion; drug sniff of an automobile; instinctive entry rule; trespass by drug-detection dog; probable cause
Sept. 27, 2021	48693	State v. Wilson	Opinion Summary	Reasonable suspicion; failure to preserve
Sept. 23, 2021	48008	State v. Warren	Opinion Summary	Fourth Amendment; traffic stop; detention of passengers; officer safety; reasonable suspicion
August 31, 2021	47914	State v. Alvarenga-Lopez	Opinion Summary	Motion to suppress; consensual encounter
August 4, 2021	47521	State v. Ahmed	Opinion Summary	Separation of powers; due process; harmless error; jury instructions; cumulative error
August 3, 2021	48454	USA v. Gutierrez	Opinion Summary	Certified question; I.C. § 19-2604; I.C. § 18-310
August 3, 2021	47695	State v. Amstutz	Opinion Summary	Motion to suppress; collective knowledge doctrine; State v. Clarke
July 21, 2021	47497	State v. Dacey	Opinion Summary	Drug Recognition Experts; expert witness disclosure; I.C.R. 16(b)(7); harmless error
July 2, 2021	48594	State v. Dempsey	Opinion Summary	Grand theft; Sufficiency of evidence; Prosecutorial misconduct; Idaho Code section 19-5304; Restitution; Out-of-pocket expenses
June 30, 2021	46916	State v. Cox	Opinion Summary	Persistent violator enhancement; Peremptory challenges; I.C.R. 24; Reversible error
June 29, 2021	48572	State v. Neimeyer	Opinion Summary	Judicial notice; municipal ordinance; motion to suppress; preservation of issue for appeal
June 28, 2021	47365	State v. Maloney	Opinion Summary	Automobile exception; probable cause; container; purse
June 28, 2021	47408	State v. Garcia-Ongay	Opinion Summary	Motion for new trial; post-verdict jury investigation; racial animus in jury deliberations; I.R.E.
June 25, 2021	47242	State v. Gardner	Opinion Summary	Idaho Code § 18-1507; sufficiency of the evidence; prosecutorial misconduct; harmless error; cumulative error.
June 24, 2021	48475	Beck v. Elmore County	Opinion Summary	Writ of Prohibition; Original jurisdiction; Warrant of attachment; Failure to pay; Ability to pay
June 23, 2021	47777	State v. Foeller	Opinion Summary	Restitution; I.C. § 19-5304; Ability to pay; Tax evasion; Issue preservation
June 22, 2021	48578	State v. Hale	Opinion Summary	Fourth Amendment; Extension of a traffic stop; Ordinary inquiries incident to a traffic stop; Motion to suppress evidence
May 27, 2021	47440	State v. Cartwright	Opinion Summary	Enticement; I.C. 18-1509A; overbreadth; First Amendment; expressive conduct; entrapment
May 20, 2021	46565/46566	State v. Anderson	Opinion Summary	Motion to Sever; Idaho Criminal Rule 8(a); Idaho Criminal Rule 14; Idaho Rule of Evidence 404(b); Idaho Rule of Evidence 403; Cumulative Error
May 20, 2021	47334	State v. Heath	Opinion Amended Summary	Idaho Criminal Rule 41; Motion for Return of Property; Contraband; Idaho Const. art. I, section 4; Idaho Const. art. XXI, section 19; Religious liberty.
April 8, 2021	46497	Abdullah v. State	Opinion Summary	Successive petition for port-conviction relief; I.C. § 19-2719; ineffective assistance of counsel; constitutional right to present a defense; conflict of interest; fundamental error; judicial notice.
April 8, 2021	47331	State v. Sutterfield	Opinion Summary	Citizen's arrest; I.C. § 19-608; Idaho Const. art. I, § 17; search incident to a citizen's arrest; suppression of evidence.
Mar 30, 2021	47210	State v. Clark	Opinion Summary	Idaho Code section 18-7034(2); felony unlawful entry; arrest warrant; statutory interpretation
Mar 23, 2020	46451	State v. Rebo	Opinion Amended Summary	Fourth Amendment; warrantless entry; motion to suppress; standing
Mar 23, 2021	48358	State v. Smith	Opinion Summary	Exigent circumstances; hearsay objection; fundamental error
Mar 19, 2021	47263	State v. Orozco	Opinion Summary	Juvenile Corrections Act; I.C. §§ 20-505 and 509; waiver of jurisdiction; Eighth Amendment
Feb 18, 2021	47341	State v. Alvarado	Opinion Summary	Sixth Amendment; conflict of interest; fundamental error doctrine; excessive sentence
Feb 17, 2021	46554	State v. Gorringe	Opinion Summary	No contact order; Idaho Criminal Rule 46.2; subject matter jurisdiction
Feb 10, 2021	47037	State v. Campbell	Opinion Summary	Accessory to a felony; I.C. § 18-205(1); jury instructions; harmless error
Feb 5, 2021	48109	State v. Huckabay	Opinion Substitute Summary	I.C. § 36-1401(c)(3), unlawful possession of a moose, statutory interpretation
Feb 3, 2021	47709	Pizzuto v. State	Opinion Summary	Atkins claim; intellectual idsability; I.C. § 19-2515A; I.R.C.P. 60(b)(6); time-barred; unique and compelling circumstances; dicta
Feb 1, 2021	47337	Chernobieff v. State	Opinion Summary	Petition for post-conviction relief; ineffective assistance of counsel; exigent circumstances; warrantless blood draw
Dec 23, 2020	47280	State v. Sarbacher	Opinion Summary	Bad faith/lost evidence
Dec 22, 2020	47612	State v. Stegall	Opinion Summary	Due process; blood alcohol concentration; DUI; phone call; evidentiary testing; blood draw
Dec 3, 2020	46107	State v. Farrell-Quigle	Opinion Summary	Due process; child testimony; alternative methods of testimony
Nov 10, 2020	47163	State v. Kent	Opinion Summary	Motion to suppress; Miranda warnings; non-custodial interrogation
Nov 2, 2020	47158	State v. Doe	Opinion Summary	Juvenile Corrections Act; Statute of Limitations; I.C. § 5-224
Oct 5, 2020	46849	State v. Loera	Opinion Summary	I.C.R 17(b); restitution; credit for time served
Oct 2, 2020	47800	State v. Haws	Opinion Amended Summary	Validity of appellate waiver; obligation to raise appellate waiver; waiver of appellate rights; relinquishment of jurisdiction
Oct 2, 2020	47102	State v. Winkler	Opinion Summary	Pardon, Idaho Constitution, DUI, enhancement, felony, prior conviction
Oct 1, 2020	46608	State v. Oxford	Opinion Summary	I.C. § 18-852; I.C. § 18-207; restitution
Sept 3, 2020	46665	Hairston v. State	Opinion Substitute Summary	Post-conviction relief; age for death penalty eligibility
Sept 2, 2020	46724	State v. Gomez-Alas	Opinion Summary	Infamous crime against nature; sufficiency of the evidence; dynamite instruction
July 27, 2020	47308	State v. Pylican	Opinion Summary	Investigative detention; extension of a traffic stop; Fourth Amendment; motion to suppress evidence
July 22, 2020	46805	State v. Hansen	Opinion Summary	Fourth Amendment; search; consent; probation; probation agreement; revoke; withdraw
July 15, 2020	46781	State v. Gneiting	Opinion Summary	Possession of contraband within a correctional facility, voluntary, conscious choice, Idaho Code § 18-2510(3)
July 14, 2020	46097	State v. Bonner	Opinion Summary	Reasonable suspicion; detainment; Fourth Amendment
June 11, 2020	47439	State v. Nava	Opinion Summary	Misjoinder; prejudicial joinder; common scheme or plan; I.R.E 404(b)
June 10, 2020	46333	State v. Rodriguez	Opinion Summary	I.C. § 18-8505; issue preservation requirement; constitutional challenge
June 10, 2020	47112	State v. Dix	Opinion Summary	Theft; burglary; ucc; owner
June 10, 2020	47577	State v. Haggard	Opinion AMENDED Summary	Fundamental error; waiver of the right to jury trial
June 5, 2020	47309	State v. Chambers	Opinion Summary	I.R.E. 412; false allegations of past sexual behavior
May 14, 2020	46094	State v. Barr	Opinion AMENDED Summary	Failure to preserve argument for appeal; I.C. § 19-2520(G)
May 06, 2020	47131	State v. Glodowski	Opinion Summary	Sex-offender registration; harmless error
May 04, 2020	45905	State v. Jones	Opinion Summary	Prior crime; wrong, or other act; Idaho Rule of Evidence 404(b); relevance; harmless error; sentencing
May 04, 2020	46992	State v. Blythe	Opinion Summary	Fourth Amendment; search incident to arrest; motion to suppress
Apr 30, 2020	47437	State v. Hess	Opinion Summary	I.C. § 37-2732(k); restitution; issue preservation
Apr 28, 2020	46253	State v. Garcia	Opinion Summary	Harmless error; in-life photographs; relevence; restitution; prosecutorial misconduct
Apr 22, 2020	46841	State v. Burke	Opinion Summary	I.C. 18-309; credit for time served; incarceration; court-ordered commitment to state hospital
Apr 14, 2020	46378	State v. Lodge	Opinion Summary	No contact orders
Apr 13, 2020	45345	State v. Ish	Opinion Summary	Batson challenge; peremptory challenge; discriminatory intent; spoilation; bad faith.
Mar 20, 2020	47324	State v. Hayes	Opinion Summary	Denying a subpoena request; Idaho Rule of Evidence 608(b); Motion for a new trial
Mar 09, 2020	47436	State v. Hooley	Opinion Summary	Petition for post-conviction relief; Motion for new trial; I.C.R. 34; I.C.R. 39; Idaho Uniform Post Conviction Procedure Act
Feb 24, 2020	46494	State v. Villa-Guzman	Opinion Summary	Restitution; I.C. § 37-2732(k)
Feb 24, 2020	46371	State v. Christensen	Opinion Summary	Hearsay exceptions; medical diagnosis or treatment
Feb 18, 2020	47438	Marsalis v. State	Opinion Summary	Petition for Review; petition for post-conviction relief; ineffective assistance of counsel; I.C. § 19-4906
Feb 18, 2020	46265	Ward v. State	Opinion Summary	Post-conviction relief, Pro se, civil proceedings, right to self-representation
Feb 13, 2020	46377	State v. Roth	Opinion Summary	Due process; escape; furlough; Idaho Criminal Rule 48
Feb 7, 2020	45569	State v. Pool	Opinion Amended Summary	Motion to suppress; implied consent
Feb 4, 2020	46335	State v. Dobbs	Opinion Summary	Objectives for sentencing
Jan 31, 2020	46266	Savage v. State	Opinion Summary	Petition for post-conviction relief; ineffective assistance of counsel; Fifth Amendment; I.C. §19-4906
Dec 20, 2019	46145	State v. Phipps	Opinion Summary	Motion to suppress; detention of occupants during a routine parole search of a parolee's residence
Dec 4, 2019	45950	State v. Maxim	Opinion Summary	Motion to suppress; Fourth Amendment standing; Fourth Amendment waiver; inevitable-discovery doctrine
Dec 3, 2019	46252	Stanfield v. State	Opinion Summary	Post-conviction relief; ineffective assistance of counsel; acquittal first rule; exculpatory evidence
Oct 25, 2019	46013	State v. Davis	Opinion Summary	Motion for a new trial; prosecutorial misconduct
Oct 07, 2019	46229	State v. Sessions	Opinion Amended Summary	Motion to suppress; emergency aid exception
Oct 07, 2019	46693	State v. Keeton	Opinion Summary	Credit for time served; I.C. § 18-309
Oct 07, 2019	46973	State v. Gonzales, Jr.	Opinion Summary	Motion to suppress; warrantless seizure
Sept 11, 2019	44182	State v. Samuel	Opinion Summary	First degree murder; second degree murder; I.C. § 18-207 motion; Miranda waiver; voluntary confession; sentencing
Sept 11, 2019	46389	State v. Osborn	Opinion Summary	Credit for time served, I.D. § 19-2603
Sept 3, 2019	45599	State v. Bodenbach	Opinion Summary	Initial aggressor; self-defense; Miranda rights; sentencing
Sept 3, 2019	45635	State v. Partee	Opinion Summary	Confidential informant agreement; contract interpretation
Aug 27, 2019	45117 & 45118	State v. Medina	Opinion Summary	Shackles, conspiracy, overt acts, jury instruction
Aug 27, 2019	46577	State v. Weigle	Opinion Summary	Demonstrative exhibits; procedural v. substantive rules
Aug 26, 2019	45642	State v. Schiermeier	Opinion Summary	Substantial evidence for conviction of grand theft; sentencing
Aug 23, 2019	46171	State v. Lantis	Opinion Summary	I.C. § 18-6409; disturbing the peace
Aug 22, 2019	45290	Thumm v. State	Substitute Opinion Summary	Post-Conviction petition asserting improper joinder and multiple other claims
July 11, 2019	45716	State v. Shanahan	Opinion Summary	Eighth Amendment; de facto life sentence under Miller v. Alabama, 567 U.S. 460 (2012); res judicata
July 11, 2019	46194	State v. Wolfe	Opinion Summary	Unlawful seizure; independent doctrine; unpreserved issue
July 10, 2019	46488	State v. Coats	Opinion Summary	Substantial evidence for conviction of grand theft
July 10, 2019	46432	State v. Cook	Opinion Summary	Motion to suppress; reasonable suspicion; void for vagueness
June 13, 2019	45627	State v. Sanchez	Opinion Summary	Threats against a public servant
June 13, 2019	46605	State v. Hoskins	Opinion Summary	Motion to suppress
June 12, 2019	45062	State v. Clarke	Opinion Summary	Motion to suppress; warrantless misdemeanor arrest outside presence of arresting officer
June 10, 2019	45282	State v. Garnett	Substitute Opinion Summary	Probation search; Reasonable suspicion
June 5, 2019	46098	State v. Saldivar	Opinion Summary	Reasonableness of pat search; status as parolee; inevitable discovery
Apr 2, 2019	45476	State v. Jane Doe (Juvenile)	Opinion Summary	Jurisdiction to modify a juvenile's sentence under the J.C.A.
Mar 28, 2019	45607	State v. Albertson	Opinion Summary	Failure to revoke implied license; motion to suppress
Mar 28, 2019	45193	State v. Wilson	Opinion Summary	Drug trafficking; methamphetamine; sufficiency of evidence
Mar 15, 2010	46517	State v. Miller	Substitute Opinion Summary	injury to a child; jury instruction
Mar 14, 2019	44858	State v. Godwin, Sr.	Opinion Summary	Second degree murder; motion to suppress evidence; jury instruction; prosecutorial misconduct
Mar 8, 2019	45989	State v. Jeske	Opinion Summary	Blood draw; amended information; jury instruction; uncharged misconduct
Mar 5, 2019	45296	State v. Abramowski	Opinion Summary	Expungement; abuse of discretion
Mar 4, 2019	45954	Thompson v. State	Substitute Opinion Summary	Ineffective assistance of counsel; proximate cause; intervening cause
Feb 26, 2019	46382	State v. Smalley	Opinion Summary	Sexual abuse of a vulnerable adult
Feb 21, 2019	45253	State v. Cunningham	Opinion Summary	Drug; restitution; hearsay
Feb 20, 2019	44534	State v. Gonzalez	Opinion Summary	Preservation for appeal
Feb 8, 2019	45351	State v. Perez, Jr.	Opinion Summary	Motion to suppress; reasonable suspicion
Feb 1, 2019	46268	State v. Meyers	Opinion Summary	Abandonment of Sixth Amendment right to self-representation
Jan 30, 2019	45295	State v. Matthews	Opinion Summary	Restitution for prosecuting costs
Dec 26, 2018	45595 & 45596	State v. McDay	Opinion Summary	Insufficient briefing precluded review of issues on appeal
Dec 19, 2018	45632	State v. Mullins	Opinion Summary	Motion to suppress; drug dog sniff
Nov 30, 2018	45547	State v. Herrera	Opinion Summary	Timliness; Sentencing
Nov 30, 2018	44296	State v. Robins	Opinion Summary	Substitute Opinion Attorney-client privilege and constitutional right to counsel
Nov 29, 2018	45140	Rome v. State	Opinion Summary	Ineffective counsel claim
Nov 29, 2018	45707	State v. Amstad	Opinion Summary	Statutory interpretation of I.C. 37-2732
Nov. 28, 2018	45100	State v. Moore	Opinion Summary	Motion to Suppress Eyewitness Identification
Oct 31, 2018	45260	State v. Sunseri	Opinion Summary	Pre-sentencing standard for withdrawal of guilty plea
Oct 29, 2018	45042	State v. Andersen	Opinion Summary	Custodial interrogation; voluntariness of statements
Sept 21, 2018	45743	State v. Alwin	Opinion Summary	Booking photo, Idaho Rule of Evidence 404(b)
Sept 14, 2018	44556	State v. Bernal	Opinion Summary	Variance between information and jury instructions; prosecutorial misconduct
Sept 7, 2018	44596	State v. Herrera	Opinion Summary	Vindictive prosecution; prosecutorial misconduct; vindictive sentencing
Sept 6, 2018	45704	State v. Le Veque	Opinion Summary	Probation; jurisdiction
Sept 6, 2018	43124	State v. Capone	Opinion Summary	First degree murder
Aug 6, 2018	45347	State v. Akins	Opinion Summary	Statutory duty to disclose v. privilege against self-incrimination
Aug 3, 2018	44892	State v. Kraly	Opinion Summary	Care and custody for purposes of injury to child statute
Aug 1, 2018	44627	State v. Salinas	Opinion Summary	Rules of evidence; Propensity; Intent; Attempt Crimes
July 27, 2018	45196	State v. George	Opinion Summary	Jurisdictional dispute
May 1, 2018	45455	State v. Passons	Opinion Summary	Sentencing enhancement; Double Jeopardy Clause
April 26, 2018	44940/44941	State v. Cota-Medina	Opinion Summary	Appeal involving waiver of juvenile court jurisdiction
April 26, 2018	44172	State v. Fuller	Opinion Summary	Motion to suppress evidence seized in a traffic stop
April 16, 2018	45346	State v. Vasquez	Opinion Summary	Express waiver of jury trial; Structural defect
April 11, 2018	31528/41059	State v. Hall	Opinion Summary	First degree murder (death sentence); kidnapping and rape
Mar 26, 2018	45598	State v. Barrett	Opinion Summary	Credit for time served
Mar 16, 2018	43822	State v. Johnson	Opinion Summary	Fifth Amendment; jury bias; refreshing witness's present recollection; cumulative error
Mar 6, 2018	44276	State v. Austin	Opinion Summary	DUI; expert testimony; statutory interpretation
Mar 2, 2018	44489	State v. Tryon	Opinion Summary	Possession of controlled substance; sufficiency of evidence
Jan 18, 2018	44772	State v. Jaskowski	Opinion Summary	State Appeals order suppressing evidence
Jan 5, 2018	45343	State v. Baxter	Opinion Summary	Order denying motion to withdraw guilty plea; Judgement for domestic violence.
Dec 26, 2017	44358	Adamcik v. State	Opinion Summary	Adamcik seeks post-conviction relief from a murder conviction (at age 16) and sentence of life without possibility of parole
Dec 22, 2017	44382	State v. Downing	Opinion Summary	Fourth Amendment suppression case vacated
Dec 21, 2017	45003	State v. Montgomery	Opinion Summary	Unlawful discharge of a firearm at an occupied vehicle. Claim of abuse of discretion for allowing undisclosed rebuttal witnesses.
Dec 20, 2017	45206	Marr v. State	Opinion Summary	Felony attempted strangulation and domestic battery with traumatic injury. Marr's petition for post-conviction relief based on ineffective assistance of counsel at trial was granted. State appeals.
Nov 29, 2017	45125	State v. Young and Rios-Lopez	Opinion Summary	Seeking credit for time served; trafficking cocaine and three counts of failure to affix illegal drug tax stamps.
Nov 8, 2017	44648	State v. Tollman	Opinion Summary	Order denying motion for a restricted driver's license
Nov 6, 2017	44991	Gilberto Garza, Jr. v. State	Opinion Summary	Dismissal of petitions for post-conviction relief claiming ineffective assistance of counsel for failing to appeal; aggravated assault and possession of a controlled substance with intent to distribute.
Nov 6, 2017	44299	State v. Gibbs	Opinion Summary	Appeal from district court decision to increase, sua sponte, probation from six years to life
Sept 22, 2017	44932	State v. Lee	Opinion Summary	Reversed motion to suppress
Sept 20, 2017	43790	State v. Folk	Opinion Summary	Felony sexual abuse of a child under sixteen
Sept 12, 2017	43673	State v. Anderson	Opinion Summary	SUBSTITUTE OPINION Domestic battery
August 24, 2017	44800	State v. Cohagan	Opinion Summary	Order denying motion to suppress. (State's Petition for Review was granted in Court of Appeals No. 43013)
July 17, 2017	43621	State v. Fisher	Opinion Summary	Appellant challenges the statutory elimination of the insanity defense
July 10, 2017	43943	State v. Tyrell Garrett McNeely	Opinion Summary	Order granting a motion to suppress statements.
July 10, 2017	44037	Ethan Allen Windom v. State	Opinion Summary	Murder. Dismissal of petition for post-conviction relief.
July 3, 2017	35617	State v. Mark Lankford	Opinion Summary	Murder. The State's Petition for Rehearing was granted and this Opinion replaces the July 25, 2016 Opinion. This case is remanded for a new trial.
June 22, 2017	43844-43845	State v. Shawn William Wass	Opinion Summary	Possession of controlled substance
June 21, 2017	44797	Jeremy Ray Wheeler v. State	Opinion Summary	Wheeler appeals the dismissal of his Petition for Post-Conviction relief.
June 20, 2017	43946	State v. Sonnie Flores	Opinion Summary	Order relinquishing jurisdiction
June 20, 2017	42964	Randy L. McKinney v. State	Opinion Summary	Murder. Dismissal of petition for post-conviction relief.
June 14, 2017	44443	State v. Victor Garcia-Rodriguez	Substitute Opinion Summary	State appealed from district court grant of motion to suppress. (Petition for Review was granted in Court of Appeals 42730)
May 31, 2017	44221	State v. Brand & Nall	Opinion Summary	Credit for time served. (Petition for Review was granted in Court of Appeals No. 43441(BRAND) & 43442 (NALL).
May 26, 2017	43015	Jaimi Dean Charboneau v. State	Opinion Summary	Murder. State appeals from district court granting petitioner a new trial in a post-conviction proceeding
May 12, 2017	42857	Sarah Marie Johnson v. State	Opinion Summary	Murder. Johnson appeals from the dismissal of her successive post-conviction petition
Apr 28, 2017	43745	State v. Jesse Eugene Mann	Opinion Summary	Appeal from judgments for trafficking marijuana, driving without privileges and possession of drug paraphernalia.
Apr 12, 2017	44383	State v. James Greer Daly	Opinion Summary	Appeal from denial of motions for substitute counsel and to continue sentencing. (Petition for Review was granted in Court of Appeals published decision 43549)
Apr 11, 2017	44444	State v. Christina Rose Wisdom	Opinion Summary	Restitution. (State's Petition for Review was granted in Court of Appeals published decision 43109)
Apr 10, 2017	44445	State v. Patrick James Bailey	Opinion Summary	Father appeals from life sentence in lewd conduct case with 10 yr old autistic daughter. (Petition for Review was granted in Court of Appeals unpublished decision 43143)
Feb 28, 2017	43493/43494	State v. Jason Zane Garner	Opinion Summary Correction	Appeal from district court's order revoking probation and reinstating sentence for possession of controlled substance; unlawful possession of a firearm
Feb 28, 2017	43384	John David Wurdemann v. State	Opinion Summary	Post-conviction; felony charges of robbery, kidnapping, arson and attempted murder.
Feb 27, 2017	44178	State v. Thomas Campbell Kelley	Opinion Summary	Appeal from restitution award
Feb 27, 2017	44177	State v. Jamie Lee Nelson	Opinion Summary	Appeal from restitution award
Feb 27, 2017	44176	State v. Jeremy York Cunningham	Opinion Summary	Appeal from restitution award
Feb 3, 2017	43332	State v. Douglas Earl Meyer	Opinion Summary	Appeal from conviction of felony possession (marijuana)
Feb 2, 2017	44308	State v. Laura L. Smith	Opinion Summary	Appeal from conviction challenging hearsay and sufficiency of evidence
Jan 23, 2017	44250	State v. Thomas John Kralovec	Opinion Summary	Battery on a correctional officer
Dec 30. 2016	44259	State v. Daniel Chernobieff	Opinion Summary	Warrantless blood draw
Dec 22, 2016	44307	Tarango Deforest Padilla v. State	Opinion Summary	Post Conviction - Claim of ineffective counsel for failure to file motion to suppress evidence
Dec 21, 2016	44123	State v. James W. Clark	Opinion Summary	Trespass
Dec 21, 2016	43496	State v. Blair Olsen	Opinion Summary	Misuse of public funds
Dec 8, 2016	44360	State v. Edgar Farfan-Galvan	Opinion Summary	Felony DUI reversed
Nov 23, 2016	44099	Takhsilov v. State	Opinion Summary	Post Conviction - Claim of ineffective counsel for failing to request competency evaluation prior to entry of guilty please
Nov 23, 2016	44011	State v. Jonathan Alan Hill	Opinion Summary	Challenge of evidentiary ruling. DUI conviction vacated; remanded for new trial.
Nov 10, 2016	43960	State v. John Patrick Linze, Jr.	Opinion Summary	Order denying motion to suppress reversed; judgment vacated.
Nov 3, 2016	42758/42759	State v. Cesar A. Sepulveda	Opinion Summary	Domestic battery; injury to a child; intimidating a witness; attempted violation of a no-contact order
Nov 2, 2016	43389	Miguel Cosio-Nava v. State	Opinion Summary	Post Conviction - Claim of ineffective assistance of counsel with immigration consequences
Nov 2, 2016	43915	State v. Scott Lewis Ostler	Opinion Summary	Lewd conduct with minor child
Nov 2, 2016	42988	State v. Marcelino B. Baeza	Opinion Summary	Lewd conduct with minor child
Nov 1, 2016	43874	State v. Robert Dean Hall	Opinion Summary Order on RH	AMENDED 11-15-16. Primary issue on appeal concerns jury instruction on self-defense. Order Denying Petition for Rehearing (attached).
Aug 5, 2016	42201	State v. Kirk Murray Charlson	- Opinion - Summary	Motion to suppress results of blood draw. (DUI)
July 22, 2016	43938	State v. Marcos Apollo Jimenez	- Opinion - Summary	Sexual battery of a minor with diminished mental capacity
July 22, 2016	43939	State v. William Dee Van Komen, Jr.	- Opinion - Summary	Appeal from order relinquishing jurisdiction following retained jurisdiction and imposing prison sentence because defendant asserted his constitutional right to remain silent regarding an unrelated felony.
June 28, 2016	42664	State v. Kentsler Lee Jones	- Opinion - Summary	DUI; excluded evidence regarding the measurement of uncertainty
June 23, 2016	43643	State v. Jon Steven Huffaker	- Opinion - Summary	State's appeal from order suppressing statements
June 10, 2016	42774	State v. Lance Tyrell Taylor	- Opinion - Summary	Credit for time served
June 1, 2016	43097	State v. Daniel William Leary	- Opinion - Summary	Credit for time served
May 27, 2016	42182	Dale Carter Shackelford v. State	- Opinion - Summary	Appeal from dismissal of petitions for post-conviction relief.
May 27, 2016	43181	State v. Troy Miles Svelmoe	- Opinion - Summary	Felony DUI
May 27, 2016	42766	State v. Dakota Lee Villafuerte	- Opinion - Summary	Failure to update address in the sex offender registry.
May 4, 2016	43286	State v. Gerald K. Umphenour	- Opinion - Summary	On appeal, Appellant asserts he was denied his right to a jury trial without a waiver.
Apr 26, 2016	43017	State v. Kyle Nicholas Rios	- Opinion - Summary	State appeals from order suppressing the results of a warrantless blood alcohol test.
Apr 26, 2016	43383	State v. Brian Neil Pratt	- Opinion - Summary	Appellant alleges a prospective juror prejudiced the jury panel and a mistrial should have been granted.
Apr 6, 2016	43141	Shane Crawford v. State	- Opinion - Summary	Post Conviction - Appeal from dismissal of petition for post-conviction relief.
Apr 4, 2016	43277	State v. Brant Lee Eversole	- Opinion - Summary	On Petition for Review Re: Order denying a suppression motion based on revoked implied consent for blood draw.
Mar 11, 2016	42950	State v. Jamie Lynn Pachosa	- Opinion - Summary	State appeals from order granting motion to suppress.
Feb 29, 2016	43285	State v. Andrey Sergeyevich Yermola	- Opinion - Summary	Willful concealment of evidence
Feb 29, 2016	42650	State v. Darrien Marshall Dabney	- Opinion - Summary	Developmentally disabled defendant appeals the sentence in sexual abuse of a child
Feb 26, 2016	43140	State v. Arthur Gene Schmierer	- Opinion - Summary	Enticing children over the internet
Feb 25, 2016	42219	State v. Jorge Enrique Rodriguez	- Opinion - Summary	Trafficking in methamphetamine
Feb 25, 2016	41910	State v. Michelle Faye McIntosh	- Opinion - Summary	Trafficking in methamphetamine
Feb 25, 2016	43131	State v. Jason McClure	- Opinion - Summary	Criminal contempt Re: Restitution in burglary conviction.
Jan 6, 2016	42398	State v. Benito Razo-Chavez	- Opinion - Summary	Possession Oxycodone
Dec 23, 2015	38477	Hasan Icanovic v. State	- Opinion - Summary	POST-CONVICTION - Claim of innefective assistance of counsel.
Dec 23, 2015	42830	Larry M. Severson v. State	- Opinion - Summary	POST-CONVICTION (murder)
Dec. 22, 2015	41621	State v. Faron Raymond Hawkins	- Opinion - Summary	Competency to stand trial
Dec. 22, 2015	42697	State v. Ryan M. Rawlings	- Opinion - Summary	Challenge of burglary statute
Dec. 22, 2015	42511	Rayland Brown v. State	- Opinion - Summary	Subject-matter jurisdiction in criminal case
Nov 30, 2015	41494	State v. Joseph D. Herrera	- Opinion - Summary	SUBSTITUTE OPINION: Appeal from conviction of second-degree murder.
Nov 23, 2015	42729	State v. Nathan David Neal	- Opinion - Summary	SUBSTITUTE OPINION: Motion to suppress
Nov 4, 2015	40859	State v. Jorge A. Lopez-Orozco	- Opinion - Summary	Three counts 1st Degree Murder
Nov 2, 2015	41105	Timothy Alan Dunlap v. State	- Opinion - Summary	POST-CONVICTION (murder)
Sept 9, 2015	42476	State v. Luis Adame Juarez	- Opinion - Summary	SUBSTITUTE OPINION. The Court's prior Opinion of Sept 1, 2015 is WITHDRAWN.
August 24, 2015	42516	State v. Andrew Garcia	- Opinion - Summary	Appeal from district court decision to dismiss State's motions for contempt.
August 24, 2015	41982	State v. Jesse Carl Riendeau	- Opinion - Summary	Appeal from district court order upholding magistrate ruling to admit breath test results.
August 20, 2015	41924	State v. Felicity Kathleen Haynes	- Opinion - Summary	DUI
August 20, 2015	42823	State v. Bryann Kristine Lemmons	- Opinion - Summary	Trafficking in methamphetamine
August 20, 2015	41004	State v. Shannon Marie McKean	- Opinion - Summary	Possession of controlled substance.
July 21, 2015	39249	State v. Daniel Edward Ehrlick, Jr.	- Opinion - Summary	SUBSTITUTE OPINION. The Court's prior Opinion of April 27, 2015 is WITHDRAWN.
July 1, 2015	42816	State v. Junior Larry Hilbroom	- Opinion - Summary	No contact order.
June 23, 2015	42671	State v. Marvin Orellana-Castro	- Opinion - Summary	Lewd conduct, sexual abuse.
June 22, 2015	41736	State v. Alesha Ann Green	- Opinion - Summary	Motion to suppress.
May 21, 2015	42205	State v. Kristi L. Hurles	- Opinion - Summary	Grand theft (embezzlement)
May 4, 2015	41644	State v. Moses Olivas, Jr.	- Opinion - Summary	Sexual abuse of a child and failure to register as a sex offender
April 8, 2015	42486	State v. Desiree B. Eliasen	- Opinion - Summary	Stalking
April 1, 2015	40301	State v. Katherine Lea Stanfield	- Opinion - Summary	First Degree Murder
April 1, 2015	42357	State v. Kenny Carl Struhs	- Opinion - Summary	Vehicular Manslaughter
Mar 19, 2015	41912	Irwin Ryan Ray Adams v. State	- Opinion - Summary	POST-CONVICTION - Felony vehicular manslaughter.
Mar 2, 2015	31659-39417	State v. Azad Haji Abdullah	- Opinion - Summary	First-degree murder, arson, felony injury to a child. (Death penalty)
Feb 27, 2015	41811	State v. Corey Allen Thiel	- Opinion - Summary	State appeals from district court reversal of magistrate decision not to allow early release on good behavior
Feb 17, 2015	41750	State v. William Franklin Wolfe	- Opinion - Summary	Appeal from denial of motion for reconsideration of Rule 35 motion(s) in fixed life sentence for first-degree murder.
Feb 09, 2015	41174	State v. Dameniel Preston Owens	- Opinion - Summary	Credit for time served
Jan 26, 2015	40803	State v. David Aaron Knutsen	- Opinion - Summary	Four counts of sexual abuse of a vulnerable adult.
Jan 23, 2015	42421	State v. Joseph Anthony Thomas, Jr.	- Opinion - Summary	AMENDED OPINION - First degree murder
Dec 18, 2014	41632	State v. Derek Michael Arrotta	- Opinion - Summary	Warrantless blood draw
Dec 9, 2014	40619	State v. Nathan Wade Herren	- Opinion - Summary	SUBSTITUTE OPINION - No contact order and probation violations.
Dec 2, 2014	40603	State v. Juan Luis Sanchez-Castro	- Opinion - Summary	Trafficking - methamphetamine
Dec 2, 2014	41169	State v. Dennis John Halseth	- Opinion - Summary	DUI - Motion to suppress results of warrantless blood draw.
October 30, 2014	41477	State v. Jesse Elias	- Opinion - Summary	Forcible sexual penetration.
October 29, 2014	41645	State v. Gary L. Schall	- Opinion - Summary	DUI
October 29, 2014	39838	State v. Jonathan Wade Ellington	- Opinion - Summary	Second degree murder
October 29, 2014	41179	State v. Micah Abraham Wulff	- Opinion - Summary	DUI - Forced Blood draw
Sept 19, 2014	40553	State v. Matthew Steven Taylor	- Opinion - Summary	This cross-appeal stems from conspiracy charges re manufacture and delivery of controlled substance.
Sept 15, 2014	41394	State v. James Leroy Skunkcap	- Opinion - Summary Video	[SUBSTITUTE OPINION - Prior Opinion Withdrawn] Eluding a peace officer; Grand theft.
Sept 4, 2014	40294	State v. Michael Eugene Koch	- Opinion - Summary	Lewd conduct with a minor under sixteen
Aug 22, 2014	40554	State v. Charlynda Goggin	- Opinion - Summary Video	Delivery of controlled substance
Aug 6, 2014	38956	State v. Russell James Parker	- Opinion - Summary	[SUBSTITUTE OPINION - Prior Opinion Withdrawn] Lewd & Lascivious conduct with minor under sixteen
July 31, 2014	41395	State v. Michael Rowe Russo	- Opinion - Summary Video	Rape, Kidnapping, Burglary
June 24, 2014	40507	State v. Kyla Alan Richardson	- Opinion - Summary
June 19, 2014	41275	State v. Joshua Michael Moses	- Opinion - Summary
June 17, 2014	41115	State v. Bob Lester Boren	- Opinion - Summary Video
Mar 28, 2014	39710/39711	State v. Krystal Lynn Easley	- Opinion - Summary
Mar 28, 2014	39877	State v. Carey Mitchell Baker	- Opinion - Summary
Mar 19, 2014	40647	State v. Robert Cassidy Hansen	- Opinion - Summary
Mar 19, 2014	39400	Jeffrey Dane Murray v. State	- Opinion - Summary
Feb 25, 2014	40483	Alisha Ann Murphy v. State	- Opinion - Summary
Feb 21, 2014	39567	State v. Samuel Thomas Glenn	- Opinion - Summary
Feb 18, 2014	38769	Sarah M. Johnson v. State	- Opinion - Summary
Feb 10, 2014	40330	State v. David Leroy Lee	- Opinion - Summary
Dec 2, 2013	385228/38704	Erick Virgil Hall v. State	- Opinion - Summary
Nov 27, 2013	40586	Zane Jack Fields v. State	- Opinion - Summary
Nov 26, 2013	39467-2011	State v. Todd W. Carver	- Opinion - Summary
Nov 26, 2013	40076-2012	State v. Sydney Lorelei Neal	- Opinion - Summary
Nov 26, 2013	39830-2012	State v. Matt Eugene Ruck	- Opinion - Summary
Nov 13, 2013	39550	State v. Jose Esteban Brunet	- Opinion - Summary

STATE OF IDAHO JUDICIAL BRANCH
Supreme Court Appeals

Appeals (Menu)