Idaho Court of Appeals Civil Opinions

Court of Appeals Civil Opinions

Idaho Court of Appeals opinions are made available online as a public service. All opinions are posted the day of their release. West Publishing Company publishes all cited opinions in the Pacific Reporter and Idaho Reports volumes. The Summary constitutes no part of the opinion of the Court, but has been prepared by court staff for the convenience of the public.

NOTICE: These opinions are subject to formal revision before publication in the preliminary print of the Pacific Reporter. Readers are requested to notify the Clerk of the Court/Reporter of Decisions, Supreme Court of Idaho, Boise, Idaho, 83720-0101, of any typographical or other formal errors, in order that corrections may be made before the preliminary print goes to press.

Release Date	Docket#	Case Name	Opinion	Notes
Feb. 21, 2025	52302	Bartosh v. Campbell	[1]Opinion [2] [3]Summary [4]	Paternity, Custody, and Child Support
Feb. 11, 2025	52192	Ross nka Miller v. Ross	[5]Opinion [1] [3]Summary [6]	Custody, Visitation, and Child Support
Feb. 7, 2025	51667	Yates v. Hull Farms, Inc.	[7]Opinion [5] [3]Summary [8]	Attorney Fees
Dec. 17, 2024	52029	Jane Doe and John Doe I v. John Doe	[9]Opinion [7] [3]Summary [10]	Judgment terminating parental rights
Dec. 4, 2024	52140	Jane Doe v. John Doe	[11]Opinion [9] [3]Summary [12]	Judgment terminating parental rights
Dec 3, 2024	51756	John Doe I & Jane Doe I v. John Doe	[13]Opinion [11] [3]Summary [14]	Judgment terminating parental rights
Nov 15, 2024	51024	Perryman Construction Management Inc. v. Doeppel Premier Properties Idaho, LLC	[15]Opinion [13] [3]Summary [16]	Arbitration Award and Granting Attorney Fees and Costs
October 23, 2024	50446	Farnsworth v. Farnsworth	[17]Opinion [18] [3]Summary [19]	Memorandum Decision and Order Re: Appeal, on intermediate appeal
Sept 5, 2024	51281	Breckon v. Breckon	[20]Opinion [17] [3]Summary [21]	Division of Property; Denial of Spousal Maintenance; Denial of Attorney Fees
August 26, 2024	51494	Jane Doe and John Doe 1 v. John Doe	[22]Opinion [20] [3]Summary [23]	Judgment terminating parental rights
August 19, 2024	51601	IDHW v. John Doe	[24]Opinion [22] [3]Summary [25]	Judgment terminating parental rights
July 18, 2024	51581	IDHW v. Jane Doe	[26]Opinion [27] [3]Summary [28]	Judgment terminating parental rights
February 9, 2024	51137	Jane Doe v. John Doe	[29]Opinion [26] [3]Summary [30]	Abandoned Child; Idaho Code § 32-717
January 9, 2024	51088	IDHW v. Jane Doe	[31]Opinion [29] [3]Summary [32]	Judgment of the District Court on Intermediate Appeal from the Magistrate Court
Nov 1, 2023	50220	Cannon v. Teel	[33]Opinion [31] [3]Summary [34]	Judgment imposing vehicle storage fees in civil action
October 30, 2023	50905	IDHW v. Jane Doe	[35]Opinion [36] [3]Summary [37]	Judgment terminating parental rights
July 26, 2023	50678	IDHW v. Jane Doe	[38]Opinion [35] [3]Summary [39]	Order finding aggravated circumstances in a Child Protective Action (CPA) case.
May 25, 2023	49496	State v. John Doe	[40]Opinion [38] [3]Summary [41]	Intermediate Appeal
Sept 19, 2022	49174	Brereton v. Marian	[42]Opinion [40] [3]Summary [43]	Judgment dismissing complaint for personal injury
July 8, 2022	48781	Peterson v. Gunderson	[44]Opinion [42] [3]Summary [45]	Orders denying and granting summary judgment
Nov 23, 2021	48478	Hepworth v. Hepworth	Opinion [44] [3]Summary [46] [47] [48] [49] [50] [51] [52] [53]	Money judgments; prejudgment interest; I.C. § 28-22-104(I)
August 19, 2021	48313	Voss v. Voss	Opinion [54] [3]Summary [55] [47] [48] [49] [50] [51] [52]	Decision affirming an order awarding spousal maintenance and child support
May 18, 2021	48526	John Doe I and Jane Doe I v. Jane Doe	Opinion [52] [3]Summary [56] [47] [48] [49] [50] [51]	Judgment terminating parental rights
Mar 22, 2021	48445	IDHW v. John Doe	Opinion [51] [3]Summary [57] [47] [48] [49] [50]	Judgment terminating parental rights
Mar 22, 2021	48444	IDHW v. Jane Doe	Opinion [50] [3]Summary [58] [47] [48] [49]	Judgment terminating parental rights
Jan 06, 2021	48309	IDHW v. Jane Doe	Opinion [49] [3]Summary [59] [47] [48]	Judgment terminating parental rights
Dec 23, 2020	48269	IDHW v. Jane Doe	Opinion [48] [3]Summary [60] [47]	Judgment terminating parental rights
July 2, 2020	47885	John Doe I v. Jane Doe	Opinion [47] [3]Summary [61]	Parental rights; jurisdiction; default judgment
June 23, 2020	47208	Medical Recovery Services v. Gepford	Opinion [62] [3]Summary [63]	Attorney Fees
May 06, 2020	47662	IDHW v. Jane Doe	Opinion [64] [3]Summary [65]	Termination of parental rights; I.R.E. 803(6) business records exception to the rule against hearsay
Apr 14, 2020	47550	Nicholson v. Bennett	Opinion [66] [3]Summary [67]	Appointment of co-guardian
Feb 11, 2020	47443	IDHW v. Jane Doe	Opinion [68] [69]Summary [70]	Termination of parental rights (mother)
Sept 27, 2019	47007	IDHW v. John Doe	Opinion [71] [69]Summary [72]	Termination of parental rights (father)
Dec 3, 2018	45396	Ricks v. State of Idaho Contractors Bd.	Opinion [73] [69]Summary [74]	Registration denied for failure to provide a social security number
Nov 26, 2018	45391/45645	Credit Bureau of E. Idaho v. Acedo	Opinion [75] [69]Summary [76]	Third-party claim of exemption
Oct 9, 2018	44719	C&M Investment Group v. Campbell	Opinion [77] [69]Summary [78]	Contempt and sanctions
May 7, 2018	45136	Nunez v. Johnson	Opinion [79] [69]Summary [80]	Motion to set aside order of dismissal
May 7, 2018	45024	Medical Recovery Svc v. Merritt	Opinion [81] [69]Summary [82]	Supplemental attorney fees and costs
Mar 9, 2018	44925	John Kirby v. Mark Scotton	Opinion [83] [69]Summary [84]	Motion to set aside default judgment for trespass; nuisance and negligence in irrigation practices
Nov 16, 2017	44466	Action Collection v. Harmony Black	Opinion [85] [69]Summary [86]	An action to collect a debt originally owed to Juvenile Corrections, later assigned to Action Collection
Sept 22, 2017	44522	Thompson v. Thompson	Opinion [87] [69]Summary [88]	Divorce
Sept 19, 2017	44379	Herrmann v. Idaho Dept of Transportation	Opinion [89] [69]Summary [90]	Department appeals from district court decision to set aside ITD's denial of request for administrative license suspension hearing as untimely
Sept 6, 2017	44093	Stephen Boswell v. Amber Dawn Steele	Opinion [91] [69]Summary [92]	Appeal from order dismissing Boswell's liability claims
Aug 31, 2017	44701	Kenneth M. Workman v. Christopher Rich	Opinion [93] [69]Summary [94]	Restitution
June 27, 2017	44075	Crossroads Neighborhood Assoc v. Erickson	2nd Substitute Opinion [95] Summary [96]	Appeal from dismissal of intermediate appeal. Order vacated, case remanded. Costs to Appellant.
June 6, 2017	44775	H & W v. Jane Doe (2017-5)	Opinion [69]	Termination of parental rights
Apr 4, 2017	44350	Mandy Valentine v. Dan Valentine	Opinion [97]	Appeal from district court's order affirming magistrate's judgment and decree of divorce, specifically, child support obligation.
Feb 23, 2017	44536	H & W v. Jane Doe (2016-43)	Substitute Opinion [98]	Termination of parental rights
Feb 6, 2017	44441	H & W v. Jane Doe (2016-35)	Opinion [99]	Termination of parental rights
Dec 5, 2016	44455	H & W v. John Doe (2016-37)	Opinion [100]	Termination of parental rights
Nov 15, 2016	43918	Hawkins v. Idaho Transportation Dept	Opinion [101]	Dept appeals from order vacating driver's license suspension
Nov 9, 2016	44026	Ada Co Prosecuting Atty v. William Scott Demint	Opinion [102]	Civil forteiture action
Nov 4, 2016	43327	Michael T. Hayes v. Kessler & Armfield	Opinion [103]	Inmate civil rights complaint
Oct 17, 2016	44113	Jon Thompson v. Kel-Lee Bybee	Opinion [104]	Appeal from judgment of contempt
June 15, 2016	43402	Secured Investment Corp. v. Myers Executive Bldg.	- Opinion [105]	SECOND AMENDED 6/24/16 Appeal from the denial of motion to set aside default judgment in breach of contract case.
Mar 2, 2016	42832	David R. Davies v. Susan Davies	- Opinion [106]	Appeal from award of attorney fees and order modifying child custody and support.
Feb 24, 2016	43105	RE: The Estate of Gordon Thomas Lanham, deceased	- Opinion [107]	AMENDED 2/25/16 - Appeal from order dismissing appeal
Dec 30, 2015	43450	H & W v. John Doe (2015-10)	- Opinion [108]	Termination of parental rights
Dec 30, 2015	42287	Hern v. Idaho Transportation Dept	- Opinion [109]	Suspended driver's license
Dec 14, 2015	42626	Hymas v. Meridian Police Department	- Opinion [110]	Appeal from Order denying request for costs and attorney fees.
Oct 20, 2015	43271	H & W v. John Doe (2015-08)	- Opinion [111]	Termination of parental rights
Oct 14, 2015	42860	Hausladen v. Sahlin	- Opinion [112]	Appeal from Order to pay fees.
Sept 30, 2015	42798	Terilyn Gunderson v. Curtis Golden	- Opinion [113]	Petition for equitable division of property in a non-marital relationship.
July 14, 2015	42265	William Rekow v. Ronald Weekes	- Opinion [114]	Landlord - Tenant
Apr 21, 2015	41684	Stephen Boswell v. Amber Dawn Steele	- Opinion [115]	Dog bite
March 30, 2015	42040	Kevin Richard Wernecke v. Idaho Transportation Department	- Opinion [116]	Driver's License Suspension
March 27, 2015	42285	Caleb Hansen v. Lawerence Denney	- Opinion [117]	Appeal from decision declining to place Hansen on the general election ballot
March 16, 2015	42128	Charles Lytle v. Julie Lytle	- Opinion [118]	Affirming Denial of motion for relief from judgment
Jan 14, 2015	41216	Barry Searcy v. State Bd of Corrections	- Opinion [119]	Complaint re fees assessed by correctional institutions
Dec 16, 2014	41733	Idaho Property Mgmt v. Don Macdonald	- Opinion [120]	Financial liability dispute
October 31, 2014	41483	Heather Brown v. Michael Brown	- Opinion [121]	Divorce
Sept 18, 2014	41785	H & W v. Jane Doe (2014-03)	- Opinion [122]	Involuntary hospitalization
Aug 25, 2014	42164	John Doe v. Jane Doe (2014-12)	- Opinion [123]	Decree terminating parental rights
Aug 13, 2014	40527	Daniel Chippewa v. State	- Opinion [124]	Post Conviction claim for ineffective assistance of counsel
July 25, 2014	41156	Hymas v. Meridian Police Deartment	- Opinion [125]	Attorney fees & costs
May 13, 2014	40888	Mahnami v. Mahnami	- Opinion [126]	Custody
Apr 24, 2014	40642	Bonner County v. Cunningham	- Opinion [127]	Attorney Fees
Apr 21, 2014	41328	Rbrt Groves v. State	- Opinion [128]	Sex Offender Registration
Apr 16, 2014	40886	Barry McHugh v. Jeffrey Reid	- Opinion [129]	Civil Forfeiture
Apr 1, 2014	40866	Twylla Robinson v. Connie Mueller	- Opinion [130]	Injury
Feb 21, 2014	40808	Peck v. Idaho Transportation Department	- Opinion [131]
Jan 24, 2014	40441	Atwood v. Idaho Transportation Department	- Opinion [132]
Sept 10, 2013	40149	Idaho Transportation v. Kalani-Keegan	- Opinion [133]
Aug 21, 2013	40150	Wurzburg v. Kootenai County	- Opinion [134]	Valuation of Property
July 25, 2013	39254	McDavid v. Kiroglu	- Opinion [135]	Appeal From Default Judgement
July 3, 2013	40727	Re: Jane Doe	- Opinion [136]	Termination of Parental Rights